From a League of Friendship to We the People: The Constitutional Convention of 1787
Self-Evident: The Road to 1776 — Ep. 19
From a League of Friendship to We the People: The Constitutional Convention of 1787
Philadelphia, Monday, July 2, 1787. The states answer one motion in turn, an equal vote for every state in the second branch of the new legislature, and the tally comes back five to five, with Georgia divided. Roger Sherman of Connecticut names what the vote has shown: "We are now at a full stop."
James Madison went to Philadelphia asking for a national veto over every law of every state, "in all cases whatsoever," the same words Parliament had used to claim its power over the colonies. He came home with a federal union.
Under the Articles of Confederation, Congress could make war and borrow money, but it could not lay a tax, and nothing in the Articles could change without every state's consent. After Shays's Rebellion, a convention met in May 1787 "for the sole and express purpose of revising the Articles of Confederation." What it proposed was a new government: a House apportioned mainly by population, a Senate in which the states were equal, a list of the powers Congress would have, ratification by conventions chosen by the people, and, in place of Madison's veto, federal law made supreme over conflicting state law, binding the state judges. The Great Compromise passed by the margin of a single state.
The delegates' own words carry the story, from Washington's "Influence is no government" to Franklin's rising sun on September 17, when thirty-nine men signed and three refused, by way of the three clauses that accommodated and protected slaveholding interests. The Skeptic's Case takes up Charles Beard, the charge of usurpation, and the reliability of Madison's own notes.
Companion to Article 19, published October 25, 2026.
Was the Confederation's inability to tax a failure of government, or a protection of liberty? And did the Constitution leave Americans more free, or more governed?
⏱️ CHAPTERS
0:00 — Cold Open: A Full Stop, July 2, 1787
2:21 — How a League Became a Government
5:10 — A Firm League of Friendship
7:46 — A Congress That Could Not Tax
8:41 — Was the Confederation a Failure?
10:33 — Shays's Rebellion
13:09 — Annapolis and the Call to Philadelphia
13:51 — Madison's Remedy: A Veto Over the States
16:01 — Behind Closed Doors
18:49 — Enlarge the Sphere
19:45 — Madison Tries for the Veto
21:26 — Conclude Nothing, Propose Anything
22:43 — Hamilton's British Model
23:34 — The Great Compromise
26:40 — The Bargain Stands
27:41 — Federal Law Made Supreme
28:27 — One Executive or Three
30:39 — Consent Across a Continent
32:27 — Limits That Hold Against a Majority
34:11 — What Was on the Delegates' Bookshelf
36:34 — The Honest Reckoning: Three-Fifths
41:44 — The Slave Trade Bargain
44:48 — The Fugitive Clause
46:54 — The Skeptic's Case: Was It About Money?
48:19 — The Skeptic's Case: A Usurpation?
49:58 — The Skeptic's Case: Madison's Notes
51:10 — The Liberty Test
52:18 — September 17, 1787: The Signing
55:10 — "A Republic, If You Can Keep It"
55:47 — What Came Out of the Room
📚 Article 19, "The Convention": https://www.consequentialactions.com/post/the-convention-from-a-league-of-friendship-to-we-the-people
📚 Every article, free each Sunday: https://www.consequentialactions.com/subscribe
🎙️ Self-Evident: The Road to 1776 — Episode 19: "The Convention" | Consequential Actions Podcast
Next: Episode 19B, Tuesday, November 3, carries the Convention's argument into our own time. Episode 20, "The Loyal Opposition," Saturday, November 7.
—
Consequential Actions is a libertarian, non-interventionist analysis of American constitutional and foreign policy. New episodes weekly.
Comments