top of page

Not a Red Line but a Lever: Who Decides Who Governs Europe?

Writer: Jeff Kellick
Jeff Kellick
Nov 3
3 min read

Contemporary Application to Self-Evident: The Road to 1776 — Episode 19B



The Federalist Papers and the European Union: Who Decides Who Governs?


On the night of October 30, riot police lined the street outside Poland's Constitutional Tribunal in Warsaw. One of the tribunal's own judges had suspended its president and his deputy, Poland's president had turned his plane around to confront the judges, and the government pointed to a ruling from the Court of Justice of the European Union that the tribunal is not an independent and impartial court. Both sides said they were defending the constitution.


On Election Day, as Americans vote in a union of fifty states that has held for more than two centuries, the question is what that union's builders feared. In 1787 the answer was Europe: a continent of rival sovereignties, standing armies and endless war. Hamilton warned in Federalist No. 8 that a people made more safe "become willing to run the risk of being less free."


The history behind it is in Saturday's Episode 19, "The Convention," and in Article 19 of the written series, free with every source in its endnotes.


Since 1950, Europe has built its union by a road the Americans never had to take: coal and steel, a common market, a common court, a common currency, each step a treaty among sovereign governments. Voters did not always agree; much of the constitutional treaty France and the Netherlands rejected in 2005 returned in the Treaty of Lisbon, ratified by parliaments. Since 2020 the union has added powers over money, through joint borrowing and rule-of-law conditions on funds, and over elections and information, through the European Democracy Shield. The Commission's case begins with Russian interference. Its critics answer that more of the decision about who governs a nation is being made outside that nation's voting booths.


Seven countries from an October 30 post on X are sorted by two questions: who decided who could govern, and was it the nation, the union, or both? Romania's constitutional court annulled an election on intelligence whose evidence was never tested in open court. Hungary's new two-thirds majority amended a constitution the old majority wrote in 2011, with a term limit counted back to 1990 that bars Viktor Orbán for life, and frozen EU funds followed the reforms. Poland's tribunal is contested by both sides. In Germany, France, Spain and Britain the decisions were national, and Marine Le Pen remains free to run in 2027 with one more appeal pending; Spain does not fit the pattern at all. Three objections follow at full strength, and so does the liberty movement's own failure.


Did this leave us more free, or more governed?


⏱️ CHAPTERS

0:00 — Election Day, and riot police at Poland's Constitutional Tribunal

6:12 — What the American union was for: Jay and Hamilton on a divided continent

12:45 — A union built the other way: treaties, referendums and conditional money

19:21 — Seven countries, sorted

30:15 — Three objections and the Liberty Test


📚 Article 19, "The Convention: From a League of Friendship to We the People": https://www.consequentialactions.com/post/the-convention-from-a-league-of-friendship-to-we-the-people


🎙️ Consequential Actions · Self-Evident: The Road to 1776 · Episode 19B


Next: Saturday, November 7 — Episode 20, "The Loyal Opposition," and the Americans who warned that the Federalists' union would consolidate the states the way Europe's empires had.


—

Consequential Actions is a libertarian, non-interventionist analysis of American constitutional and foreign policy. New episodes weekly.



Comments


bottom of page