top of page

"The Convention" — From a League of Friendship to We the People

Writer: Jeff Kellick
Jeff Kellick
Oct 24
51 min read

SELF-EVIDENT The Road to 1776 Article 19 of 22

Experience must be our only guide. Reason may mislead us. — John Dickinson, in James Madison's notes of the Federal Convention, August 13, 1787¹

A Full Stop


On Monday, July 2, 1787, the Federal Convention voted on one sentence. Oliver Ellsworth of Connecticut had moved that each state have a single vote in the second branch of the new legislature, exactly as each state had a single vote in the Congress of the Confederation. For five weeks the large states had been building a national government on the principle that representation should follow population. For the same five weeks the small states had been warning that they would never join it.


The states answered in turn. Massachusetts, no. Connecticut, aye. New York, aye. New Jersey, aye. Pennsylvania, no. Delaware, aye. Maryland, aye — on the vote of Luther Martin alone, because his colleague Daniel of St. Thomas Jenifer was not in the room. Virginia, no. North Carolina, no. South Carolina, no. Then Georgia. William Houston voted no and Abraham Baldwin voted aye, and a divided delegation cast no vote at all. Five states to five. The motion failed, and nothing had been decided.²


No one mistook the tie for a settlement. Two days earlier Gunning Bedford of Delaware had stood up and told the large states that if they broke the Confederation apart, "the small ones will find some foreign ally of more honor and good faith, who will take them by the hand and do them justice." Rufus King of Massachusetts answered that whatever his own distress, he "wd. never court relief from a foreign power."³ Men who had fought one war together for independence were now talking, in secret session, about allies against each other.


Roger Sherman of Connecticut named the situation. "We are now at a full stop," he said, "and nobody he supposed meant that we shd. break up without doing something." Hugh Williamson of North Carolina put it more bluntly still: "If we do not concede on both sides, our business must soon be at an end." General Charles Cotesworth Pinckney of South Carolina proposed a committee of one member from each state "to devise & report some compromise," and ten states agreed.⁴


The men in the Pennsylvania State House that summer were not new to a broken union. They had been living under one for six years. Eleven years earlier their generation had changed the ordering of its own arguments, setting the laws of nature above the rights of Englishmen, and on that ground it had declared the colonies free. The Declaration supplied a reason for government and no government. In Philadelphia they had to put one in order: which powers belonged to the Union and which to the states, which to the many and which to the few, and which to no government at all. Two problems were waiting for them, and earlier articles in this series have already named both. The first was consent that could be organized across a great distance. The second was limits that would hold when the consenting majority wanted them not to.



A Firm League of Friendship

On June 7, 1776, Richard Henry Lee's resolution had asked for three things: independence, foreign alliances, and "a plan of confederation." On July 12, 1776, a committee brought in a draft, and its original manuscript is in the hand of John Dickinson of Pennsylvania — the man who had argued against declaring independence on July 1.⁵ Congress argued over it for more than a year, agreed to it on November 15, 1777, and sent it to the states. It did not take effect until March 1, 1781, after Maryland, which had refused to ratify until the states claiming western lands agreed to cede them to the Union, finally signed.⁶


The document was honest about what it was. Its second article declared that "Each state retains its sovereignty, freedom, and independence, and every power, jurisdiction, and right, which is not by this Confederation expressly delegated to the United States, in Congress assembled." Its third described the arrangement as "a firm league of friendship."⁷ Congress could make war and peace, send and receive ambassadors, borrow money, and settle disputes between states. It could not lay a tax. Under the eighth article, the common treasury was to be supplied by the states, "laid and levied by the authority and direction of the legislatures of the several States." And under the thirteenth, no part of the Articles could be altered unless the change was confirmed "by the legislatures of every State."⁸


What did the league of friendship accomplish? More than its critics later allowed. It carried the country through the end of the war with Britain and concluded the Treaty of Paris, signed on September 3, 1783, in which Britain acknowledged the states to be "free sovereign and independent." Its Congress laid out the surveying of the western lands in the ordinance of May 20, 1785. And on July 13, 1787 — while the Convention in Philadelphia was arguing about the Senate — the same Congress, sitting in New York, adopted the Northwest Ordinance, which provided for the government of the territory north of the Ohio and declared that "There shall be neither slavery nor involuntary servitude in the said territory."⁹


What it could not do was make anyone pay. Congress asked the states for money by requisition, and the states paid what they chose; by one estimate the payments usually amounted to about half of what was requested.¹⁰ In February 1781 Congress asked the states for the power to lay a duty on imports, which required every state's consent. On November 1, 1782, Rhode Island refused, and the tariff died; a month later Virginia repealed its own approval. A second tariff proposed in 1783 died the same way, against New York's insistence on collecting the revenue itself.¹¹ Thirteen states had to agree to change anything, and one could always say no.


Was the Confederation a failure? The verdict has a history of its own. In 1888 the historian John Fiske called the years after the peace "the critical period of American history," and the phrase stuck, though it was older than Fiske: John Quincy Adams, graduating from Harvard on July 18, 1787, told his audience they were living "At this critical period."¹² In 1940 and 1950 Merrill Jensen challenged the consensus that the Articles were fundamentally flawed, and read them as a truer expression of the Revolution's democratic spirit than the Constitution that replaced them. More recently, George William Van Cleve has argued that the Confederation's failures were real and produced the crisis that led to Philadelphia.¹³


The documents support a verdict between the two. The Articles did what they were built to do. They were built as a league of sovereign states. The thirteenth article declared that every state "shall abide by" the determinations of Congress, but the Articles gave Congress no effective means of compelling a state that did not. Every power the Confederation lacked — to tax, to regulate trade, to act on individuals rather than on states, to amend itself without unanimous consent — was a power the states had deliberately kept. The Articles failed at what they were never designed to do.

That leaves a question for a reader who cares about liberty, and it is the question the men of 1787 were really arguing about. Is a government that cannot tax a failed government, or a successful one?


Influence Is No Government


In the autumn of 1786 the question stopped being theoretical. Farmers in western Massachusetts, pressed by taxes and debts payable in hard money, closed the county courts so that no judgments could be issued against them. On August 29 an armed group shut the Court of Common Pleas at Northampton, and other courts followed.¹⁴ The men were led, at the end, by Daniel Shays, who had risen to captain in the Revolutionary War.


The news reached Mount Vernon and frightened the most admired man in America. Henry Lee had suggested that "influence" might calm the disturbances. Washington answered on October 31, 1786: "Influence is no government. Let us have one by which our lives, liberties, and properties will be secured, or let us know the worst at once." The disorders, he wrote, were "a melancholy proof of what our trans atlantic foe have predicted; and of another thing perhaps, which is still more to be regretted, and is yet more unaccountable; that mankind left to themselves are unfit for their own government."¹⁵ Five days later he told James Madison that "Thirteen Sovereignties pulling against each other, and all tugging at the fœderal head, will soon bring ruin on the whole."¹⁶


On January 25, 1787, about two thousand men under Shays marched on the federal arsenal at Springfield. The militia defending it, under General William Shepard, fired its artillery into the column. Three men were killed and a fourth mortally wounded. Shepard wrote that "the unhappy time is come in which we have been obliged to shed blood."¹⁷ Early in February the rebels were routed at Petersham, and the rebellion collapsed. It had been put down by Massachusetts, not by the Congress of the United States.


An illustration of Shays's troops repulsed from the armory in Springfield in early 1787
An illustration of Shays's troops repulsed from the armory in Springfield in early 1787

Not every founder was alarmed. From Paris, Thomas Jefferson wrote to Madison on January 30, 1787, "I hold it that a little rebellion now and then is a good thing, and as necessary in the political world as storms in the physical."¹⁸ The man who had written that governments derive their just powers from the consent of the governed was not inclined to treat an uprising of debtors as the end of the republic. Washington was, and Washington would be in the chair at Philadelphia.


The road to Philadelphia had already been laid out. In September 1786, commissioners from five states — New York, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Delaware, and Virginia — met at Annapolis to discuss trade. Too few states had come to do anything, and the commissioners issued a report, drafted by Alexander Hamilton, calling for a convention at Philadelphia on the second Monday in May "to take into consideration the situation of the United States."¹⁹ On February 21, 1787, the Congress endorsed the call, but on terms of its own. The convention was to meet "for the sole and express purpose of revising the Articles of Confederation."²⁰ Delaware's legislature went further and forbade its delegates to agree to any change in the rule that gave each state one vote.²¹ Congress's mandate was a revision. What the Convention produced was something else.


The Middle Ground


The delegate who arrived best prepared was James Madison, thirty-six years old, a Virginian who had studied under John Witherspoon at Princeton and who had spent the years before the Convention, as our opening article traced, reading the history of confederacies. In April 1787 he wrote out what he called the "Vices of the Political System of the United States," a catalogue of what the states had done with their sovereignty. The laws of the states, he wrote, multiplied without end — "Every year, almost every session, adds a new volume." They changed before anyone could know whether they worked: "We daily see laws repealed or superseded, before any trial can have been made of their merits." And they were unjust, because the majorities that made them in small states had nothing to check them.²²



His remedy, in the spring of 1787, was startling. Madison wanted the national legislature to hold a veto over every law of every state. He told Jefferson in March that the federal head should be armed "with a negative in all cases whatsoever on the local Legislatures." He told Edmund Randolph in April that it should have a negative "in all cases whatsoever on the Legislative Acts of the States as the K. of G. B. heretofore had." And he told Washington that he had sought "some middle ground, which may at once support a due supremacy of the national authority" and still leave the states a role.²³


In all cases whatsoever. Twenty-one years after the Declaratory Act had used those words to claim Parliament's power over the colonies, Madison proposed giving the same power to Congress over the states. Madison meant the veto as a guard for liberty, a check on state majorities that had passed paper-money laws, debtor relief, and other measures he thought unjust to creditors and minorities. But the instrument he proposed was the one the Revolution had been fought against, and he knew it; he named the King of Great Britain as the model.


The historian Kevin R. C. Gutzman has argued that the veto was the provision on which Madison was most insistent in Philadelphia, and that its defeat left him convinced the new government would fail. The Constitution, Gutzman writes, "turned out markedly unlike what Madison wanted," and he has suggested that Madison is more accurately called the "unhappy stepfather of the Constitution" than its father.²⁴ The label Madison wore in later life he never claimed for himself. The Constitution, he wrote in 1834, "ought to be regarded as the work of many heads & many hands."²⁵


What Madison did claim was a seat. He chose one, he wrote, "in front of the presiding member, with the other members, on my right and left hand," and he recorded that he was "not absent a single day, nor more than a casual fraction of an hour in any day, so that I could not have lost a single speech, unless a very short one."²⁶ His notes are the fullest record of the Convention.


Behind Closed Doors


Seven states were present on Friday, May 25, 1787, and the Convention organized itself. Robert Morris of Pennsylvania nominated George Washington as president, the presiding officer of the Convention. He was elected unanimously.²⁷ Four days later the delegates adopted their rules, including one that governed everything after it: "That nothing spoken in the House be printed, or otherwise published or communicated without leave."²⁸ The rule held. Madison's notes were not published until 1840, four years after his death.


On May 29 Edmund Randolph, the governor of Virginia, opened the main business. He listed the defects of the Confederation — first, "that the confederation produced no security against foreign invasion"; fourth, "that the foederal government could not defend itself against the incroachments from the states" — and he asked the delegates "not to suffer the present opportunity of establishing general peace, harmony, happiness and liberty" to pass. Then he laid out fifteen resolutions from the Virginia delegation, which drew heavily on the scheme Madison had sketched in his spring letters. The first was cautious: the Articles "ought to be so corrected & enlarged" as to accomplish their own objects. The rest described a new government altogether.²⁹


The next day the mask came off. Sitting as a Committee of the Whole, the delegates resolved "that a national Government ought to be established consisting of a supreme Legislative, Executive and Judiciary." Six states voted for it. Connecticut voted no, and New York divided, with Hamilton voting aye and Robert Yates no.³⁰ In a single vote the Convention had set out on a course that several of its own members would soon say it had no authority to take.


On May 31 the delegates turned to how the people would choose their representatives, and their first instincts would surprise most Americans today. Sherman thought the people "should have as little to do as may be about the Government." Elbridge Gerry of Massachusetts said that "The evils we experience flow from the excess of democracy. The people do not want virtue, but are the dupes of pretended patriots." George Mason, the author of the Virginia Declaration of Rights, answered that the first branch was to be "the grand depository of the democratic principle of the Govt." And James Wilson of Pennsylvania, the Scot who had argued in 1774 that all lawful government rests on consent, said he was "for raising the federal pyramid to a considerable altitude, and for that reason wished to give it as broad a basis as possible."³¹


On June 6 Madison gave the Convention the idea he is best remembered for. In a small republic, he argued, a majority with a common interest could easily combine to oppress the minority. "The only remedy is to enlarge the sphere, & thereby divide the community into so great a number of interests & parties, that in the 1st. place a majority will not be likely at the same moment to have a common interest separate from that of the whole or of the minority; and in the 2d. place, that in case they shd. have such an interest, they may not be apt to unite in the pursuit of it."³² The old fear, from Montesquieu onward, had been that a republic must be small. Madison turned it around. Size was the cure.


Two days later he tried for the veto. Charles Pinckney of South Carolina moved that the national legislature have authority "to negative all laws which they shd. judge to be improper," and Madison seconded him with an image from astronomy. The negative, he said, was "the great pervading principle that must controul the centrifugal tendency of the States; which, without it, will continually fly out of their proper orbits and destroy the order & harmony of the political System." Three states voted for it — Massachusetts, Pennsylvania, and Virginia — seven voted against, and Delaware divided. Madison recorded even the split inside his own delegation, down to the note that Washington, sitting in the chair, was "not consulted."³³


The Limits of a Commission


The small states had been waiting for the large ones to show their hand. On June 9 William Paterson of New Jersey called for the commission of Massachusetts to be read aloud, because it recited Congress's call word for word: the delegates had been sent "for the sole and express purpose of revising the Articles of Confederation." "We have no power to go beyond the federal scheme," he said, and "N. Jersey will never confederate on the plan before the Committee."³⁴ On June 15 he laid before the Convention a plan of his own, whose first resolution was that the Articles "ought to be so revised, corrected & enlarged, as to render the federal Constitution adequate to the exigencies of Government, & the preservation of the Union." Congress would gain powers to tax imports and regulate trade, and each state would keep its single vote.³⁵


The next day brought the argument over authority into the open. John Lansing of New York said that "the power of the Convention was restrained to amendments of a federal nature." Paterson put it in a sentence every delegate understood: "Our object is not such a Governmt. as may be best in itself, but such a one as our Constituents have authorized us to prepare."³⁶ What the constituents had authorized was not uniform. New York's legislature had copied Congress's words exactly. Most of the other states, Paterson's New Jersey among them, had sent their delegates to devise whatever further provisions were necessary to make the federal constitution adequate to the needs of the Union, and South Carolina authorized any provisions needed to make it "entirely adequate."³⁷


Wilson answered that he "conceived himself authorized to conclude nothing, but to be at liberty to propose any thing." Randolph went further. "When the salvation of the Republic was at stake," he said, "it would be treason to our trust, not to propose what we found necessary."³⁸ Those two sentences contain the whole defense of what the Convention did. It could propose. Only someone else could adopt.


Alexander Hamilton then took the floor on June 18 and spoke for most of the day. He proposed an executive and a senate chosen to serve "during good behaviour," for life, and he declared that "the British Govt. was the best in the world: and that he doubted much whether any thing short of it would do in America."³⁹ The speech did not move a single delegation. William Samuel Johnson of Connecticut observed three days later, in Robert Yates's notes, that the gentleman from New York "has been praised by every body, he has been supported by none."⁴⁰ On June 19 the Convention voted seven states to three, with Maryland divided, to keep working from Randolph's resolutions rather than Paterson's.⁴¹


The large states had won the vote. They had not won the small states.


The Great Compromise


Connecticut had offered the answer before anyone else would take it. On June 11 Sherman moved that representation in the first branch follow the number of free inhabitants and that in the second branch "each State should have one vote and no more." It failed, five states to six.⁴²


The rift then grew hot. On June 27 Luther Martin of Maryland began a speech defending the equality of the states that ran, Madison noted, "more than three hours," and Martin "was too much exhausted he said to finish his remarks." He resumed the next morning, speaking, in Madison's tired phrase, "with much diffuseness & considerable vehemence."⁴³ On June 28 Benjamin Franklin, eighty-one years old, tried to cool the room. "I have lived, Sir, a long time," he said, "and the longer I live, the more convincing proofs I see of this truth- that God Governs in the affairs of men." Without that help, he warned, they would succeed in their political building "no better, than the Builders of Babel." He moved that each session open with prayer. Williamson pointed out that the Convention had no funds to pay a chaplain, and after several attempts to postpone the matter without a vote, the delegates adjourned instead.⁴⁴


On June 29 Ellsworth stated the compromise in a phrase — "We were partly national; partly federal" — and moved that the second branch keep the Confederation's rule of suffrage.⁴⁵ On June 30 Bedford made his threat about a foreign ally. On July 2 the vote tied. The committee of one member from each state reported a version of Connecticut's plan, with equal votes for the states in the second branch and money bills originating in the first.


On July 16 the Convention adopted it. Massachusetts was divided, Gerry and Caleb Strong voting aye and King and Nathaniel Gorham no. Connecticut, New Jersey, Delaware, Maryland, and North Carolina voted aye; Pennsylvania, Virginia, South Carolina, and Georgia voted no. Five states to four, with one divided. The equal vote in the Senate passed by the margin of a single state.⁴⁶


The large states did not take it quietly. The next morning, before the Convention met, a number of their delegates gathered to decide what to do. Madison's account of that meeting is one of the most candid passages in his notes: "The time was wasted in vague conversation on the subject, without any specific proposition or agreement." The small states, he concluded, had learned from it "that they had nothing to apprehend from a union of the larger."⁴⁷ The bargain stood.


Madison lost the veto again. On July 17 he argued that "The necessity of a general Govt. proceeds from the propensity of the States to pursue their particular interests in opposition to the general interest," and that the negative was "essential to the efficacy & security of the Genl. Govt." Sherman replied that such a power "involves a wrong principle." It failed, three states to seven. Later that day Luther Martin — of all people — moved that the laws and treaties of the United States "shall be the supreme law of the respective States" and that "the Judiciaries of the several States shall be bound thereby in their decisions." It passed without dissent.⁴⁸ The Convention would not let Congress strike down a state law. It would let a court refuse to apply one.


Gutzman has written that the moderates, Sherman and Ellsworth above all, "triumphed in shaping the new government."⁴⁹ The record of June and July bears him out. Connecticut's men did not give the most speeches. They wrote the terms.


One Man or Three


The executive was the office the delegates feared most, and they feared it in two directions at once. The Articles had provided no separate executive at all; Congress ran the Union's affairs through committees and officers of its own choosing.⁵⁰ A strong executive raised the opposite fear. It looked like the king they had just fought.


On June 1 Wilson moved that the executive "consist of a single person." The room went silent. "A considerable pause ensuing and the Chairman asking if he should put the question," Madison wrote, Franklin said it was a point of great importance and asked the gentlemen to speak.⁵¹ Randolph did. He "strenuously opposed a unity in the Executive magistracy," and called it "the foetus of monarchy." Wilson answered that unity in the executive, "instead of being the fetus of monarchy would be the best safeguard against tyranny." Sherman, for his part, thought that an executive independent of the legislature "was in his opinion the very essence of tyranny."⁵² Mason, the next day, insisted that "Some mode of displacing an unfit magistrate is rendered indispensable by the fallibility of those who choose, as well as by the corruptibility of the man chosen."⁵³


The delegates went back and forth on the executive for most of the summer — chosen by the legislature, chosen by the people, chosen by electors, serving one long term or several short ones. The settlement came late. On September 4 David Brearley of New Jersey reported from a committee of eleven that each state should appoint, "in such manner as its Legislature may direct," a number of electors equal to its senators and representatives.⁵⁴ The first man to hold the office was sitting in the chair, saying almost nothing.


Persons Held to Service


The Declaration's struck passage on the slave trade did not end the argument; it only moved it. In Philadelphia the argument came back in three clauses, and the delegates' own words show what each of them cost.


The Three-Fifths Clause

The ratio itself was not new. In April 1783 the Confederation Congress had proposed to apportion the common expenses among the states by counting free inhabitants and "three fifths of all other persons," and Madison later explained the fraction as the product of "despair on both sides of a more favorable rate of the slaves."⁵⁵ On June 11, 1787, Wilson, seconded by Charles Pinckney, moved to use the same rule for representation. Gerry asked the obvious question: "Why then shd. the blacks, who were property in the South, be in the rule of representation more than the Cattle & horses of the North."⁵⁶


On July 11 the question became a fight. Pierce Butler and General Pinckney of South Carolina demanded that slaves be counted equally with free persons. Gouverneur Morris of Pennsylvania said he "could never agree to give such encouragement to the slave trade as would be given by allowing them a representation for their negroes." Wilson put the contradiction in four questions: "Are they admitted as Citizens? then why are they not admitted on an equality with White Citizens? are they admitted as property? then why is not other property admitted into the computation? These were difficulties however which he thought must be overruled by the necessity of compromise."⁵⁷ The next day William Davie of North Carolina announced that his state "would never confederate on any terms that did not rate them at least as 3/5," and General Pinckney insisted that "property in slaves should not be exposed to danger under a Govr. instituted for the protection of property." The fraction passed.⁵⁸


On August 8 Morris gave the most furious speech of the summer. "He never would concur in upholding domestic slavery," Madison recorded. "It was a nefarious institution. It was the curse of heaven on the States where it prevailed." The three-fifths rule, he said, came down to this: "that the inhabitant of Georgia and S. C. who goes to the Coast of Africa, and in defiance of the most sacred laws of humanity tears away his fellow creatures from their dearest connections & damns them to the most cruel bondages, shall have more votes in a Govt. instituted for protection of the rights of mankind, than the Citizen of Pa. or N. Jersey who views with a laudable horror, so nefarious a practice." He "would sooner submit himself to a tax for paying for all the negroes in the U. States, than saddle posterity with such a Constitution."⁵⁹ His motion to count only free inhabitants received the vote of New Jersey and no other state.


The Slave Trade

On August 21 Luther Martin proposed allowing Congress to tax or prohibit the importation of slaves, calling the trade "inconsistent with the principles of the revolution and dishonorable to the American character." John Rutledge of South Carolina replied in two sentences that ended the pretense: "Religion & humanity had nothing to do with this question. Interest alone is the governing principle with nations." The real question, he said, was "whether the Southn. States shall or shall not be parties to the Union." Charles Pinckney added that "South Carolina can never receive the plan if it prohibits the slave trade."⁶⁰


The next day Mason, himself a Virginia slaveholder, called the trade "This infernal trafic" and said that "Every master of slaves is born a petty tyrant. They bring the judgment of heaven on a Country." Ellsworth answered that "As he had never owned a slave could not judge of the effects of slavery on character," but that if the matter was to be considered morally, "we ought to go farther and free those already in the Country." He predicted that "Slavery in time will not be a speck in our Country." General Pinckney said plainly that "S. Carolina & Georgia cannot do without slaves," and Morris saw where it was heading: "These things may form a bargain among the Northern & Southern States."⁶¹


They did. On August 25 General Pinckney moved to protect the trade until 1808 rather than 1800. Madison objected: "Twenty years will produce all the mischief that can be apprehended from the liberty to import slaves. So long a term will be more dishonorable to the National character than to say nothing about it in the Constitution." The motion passed, seven states to four, with New Hampshire, Massachusetts, and Connecticut joining Maryland, North Carolina, South Carolina, and Georgia. The same day, when a tax on imported slaves was debated, Sherman objected to it "as acknowledging men to be property," and Madison "thought it wrong to admit in the Constitution the idea that there could be property in men." The clause was amended without dissent to permit a duty on "such importation" of no more than ten dollars "for each person."⁶² Four days later Pinckney explained what the Southern states had received in return. Commerce laws would pass by a simple majority, and he credited "the liberal conduct" of the Eastern states toward South Carolina's views; Madison added a footnote saying what Pinckney meant: "the permission to import slaves."⁶³


The Fugitive Clause

On August 28 Butler and Pinckney moved "to require fugitive slaves and servants to be delivered up like criminals." Sherman objected that he "saw no more propriety in the public seizing and surrendering a slave or servant, than a horse." The next day a revised clause was agreed to without dissent.⁶⁴ In its final form it never uses the word slave: "No Person held to Service or Labour in one State, under the Laws thereof, escaping into another, shall, in Consequence of any Law or Regulation therein, be discharged from such Service or Labour, but shall be delivered up on Claim of the Party to whom such Service or Labour may be due."⁶⁵


What the Record Shows

The same summer produced both the Northwest Ordinance, which closed a territory to slavery, and three clauses that accommodated and protected slaveholding interests. Madison had objected to admitting the idea of property in men, and the document of 1787 nowhere uses the words "slave" or "slavery." The protections stayed in it all the same. Historians have read the result in opposite ways. Sean Wilentz has argued that the Convention's refusal to recognize property in man excluded slavery from national law, even as its concessions helped secure slavery where it already existed. David Waldstreicher has argued that slavery was as important to the making of the Constitution as the Constitution was to slavery's survival. Don Fehrenbacher argued that the Constitution itself was more or less neutral on slavery, and found the federal government's support for slavery chiefly in the policy that came after it.⁶⁶ The abolitionists divided the same way. William Lloyd Garrison burned a copy of the Constitution on July 4, 1854, and called it "a covenant with death and an agreement with hell." Frederick Douglass, who had once agreed with Garrison, announced in 1851 that he had abandoned the proslavery reading.⁶⁷


What the record shows is men who knew what they were doing. Morris named the curse. Mason named the tyrant. Madison objected to property in men. The Constitution never expressly recognized it, but the trade stayed protected all the same. Rutledge told them that humanity had nothing to do with it, and the Convention voted as though he were right. The truths called self-evident in 1776 were bargained over in 1787, and the bargain bought the Union at a price that men who were never asked would pay.


The Bookshelf, Again


The previous article sorted the evidence for the Declaration's sources into three kinds: a source a participant named, a book a participant demonstrably owned or recommended, and a proposition carried in the shared language without attribution. The Convention can be sorted the same way, and the result is not what the popular memory of the founding expects.


What Was Named

Across the summer, Madison's notes record remarkably few political philosophers by name. Luther Martin, on June 27, read aloud from "Locke, Vattel, Lord Summers- Priestly," and then from "Locke & Vattel, and also Rutherford" — the jurist Thomas Rutherforth — to prove that states, like individuals in a state of nature, were equal until they surrendered their equality.⁶⁸ That is the only place Locke appears in Madison's notes. Montesquieu appears in them three times: Madison on June 30, recalling the Lycian confederacy "which Montesquieu recommends as the fittest model for that form of Government"; Randolph on July 11, citing "the celebrated Montesquieu" on suffrage; and Madison on July 17, on the danger of an executive dependent on the legislature.⁶⁹ Other delegates' notes add a few more, as an earlier article in this series found. Dickinson consulted Blackstone's Commentaries on August 29 to learn what "ex post facto" covered.⁷⁰ And David Hume appears exactly once, in a bracket. On June 22 Hamilton told the Convention that "one of the ablest politicians" had called the crown's influence an essential part of the British constitution, and Madison, writing the speech up, supplied the name: "[Mr. Hume,]."⁷¹


What the delegates named constantly was history. Britain and its constitution come up on most days of the Convention. Rome, Greece, Holland, Switzerland, the German empire, and the ancient leagues come up again and again, as earlier articles in this series traced. And when Dickinson gave the Convention its method, he named no author at all. "Experience must be our only guide," he said on August 13. "Reason may mislead us. It was not Reason that discovered the singular & admirable mechanism of the English Constitution. It was not Reason that discovered or ever could have discovered the odd & in the eye of those who are governed by reason, the absurd mode of trial by Jury."⁷²


What Was on the Shelf

The second kind of evidence reaches further. In January 1783 Madison drew up a list of books that Congress ought to own. It includes "Locke on Government," "Montesquieu's works," Vattel, "Hume's political essays," Hume's History of England, and "Smith on the wealth of Nations."⁷³ Hume and Smith were on Madison's list. A Scot, Witherspoon, had taught him, and another, Wilson, sat in the room.


What Moved Through the Language

The third kind is where the previous article left a claim to be tested. It said that the Scottish writers' work on order arising without design "bore less on the Declaration than on the problems of organizing a government that followed it." The Convention allows a partial verdict.


For Hume, the claim holds, as an echo rather than a debt. In his essay "Idea of a Perfect Commonwealth," Hume had argued against the received wisdom that republics must be small: "In a large government, which is modelled with masterly skill, there is compass and room enough to refine the democracy," and "the parts are so distant and remote, that it is very difficult, either by intrigue, prejudice, or passion, to hurry them into any measures against the public interest."⁷⁴ Madison's speech of June 6 makes the same move, and when he wrote it up for the public in the tenth Federalist, in November 1787, the parallel became closer still: a representative body would "refine and enlarge the public views," and "Extend the sphere, and you take in a greater variety of parties and interests; you make it less probable that a majority of the whole will have a common motive to invade the rights of other citizens."⁷⁵ Madison never names Hume in the speech or the essay. Since Douglass Adair's study of 1957, the parallel has been the standard example of Hume's influence on Madison.⁷⁶ It is an echo — a close one, from a writer Madison had listed for Congress — and not a citation.


For Adam Smith, the claim does not hold in the record. Smith is on Madison's list of 1783. He is never named in Madison's notes of the Convention, and his name appears nowhere in the eighty-five papers of The Federalist.⁷⁷ Whatever the founders took from The Wealth of Nations, they did not take it into the Convention by name.


And the idea at the center of the claim — that the best institutions are found by experience rather than designed by reason — was stated on the floor by Dickinson, who cited no Scot for it. The Scots had written it down. Dickinson had lived it, in a war that was won and a confederation that was not working. The likelier lesson is that the idea had passed, as natural rights had passed by 1776, into the common sense of the men in the room.⁷⁸


What They Built

The Convention left Philadelphia with answers to both of the problems it had inherited, and neither answer was the one its leading planner had wanted.


Consent across a continent. The first problem was how a people spread over a thousand miles could consent to anything. The Convention's answer came in three parts. Representation in the House would follow population, so that consent would be counted by persons. Representation in the Senate would follow the states, so that consent would also be counted by political communities that already existed. And the Constitution itself would be ratified not by the state legislatures but by conventions elected by the people. On July 23 Mason argued that the legislatures were "the mere creatures of the State Constitutions, and can not be greater than their creators," and that the question belonged to "the people with whom all power remains." Madison drew the distinction that mattered: "the true difference between a league or treaty, and a Constitution" was that one rested on legislatures and the other on the people. The Convention voted nine states to one to send the plan to assemblies chosen by the people.⁷⁹ On September 12 the Committee of Style returned with a preamble that no longer listed the thirteen states by name, as the August draft had done. In its final form it begins "We the People of the United States."⁸⁰ The league of friendship among sovereign states was to become a government of the people of a continent, and the people would decide whether it did.


Limits against the majority. The second problem was how to hold a majority back when it wanted to go forward. Madison's answers were the extended republic and the veto. The Convention accepted the first and refused the second. In place of a congressional negative over state laws it wrote a supremacy clause and left enforcement to judges. In place of the Virginia Plan's general grant, a power to legislate "in all cases to which the separate States are incompetent," it enumerated the powers Congress would have.⁸¹ And on September 12, when Mason wished that the plan had been "prefaced with a Bill of Rights" and Gerry moved for a committee to write one, Sherman replied that "The State Declarations of Rights are not repealed by this Constitution; and being in force are sufficient." Ten states voted against the motion, and Massachusetts abstained.⁸² The limits the Convention trusted were the structure itself — divided powers, a divided legislature, a federal union of states that kept their own governments, and a long list of things Congress was not given.


Madison was not satisfied. He wrote to Jefferson on September 6 that "the plan should it be adopted will neither effectually answer its national object nor prevent the local mischiefs which every where excite disgusts agst the state governments." On October 24 he sent a long explanation of the negative and its fate, which he described as "finally rejected by a bare majority."⁸³ The man who had done as much as anyone to bring the Convention about, who had shaped its first plan, and who recorded its debates thought it had failed at the thing he cared about most. That the Constitution turned out more federal than its chief planner intended is, for a reader who values divided power, among the more fortunate facts of the founding.


The Skeptic's Case


That It Was About Money

In 1913 Charles Beard argued in An Economic Interpretation of the Constitution of the United States that the movement for the Constitution was "originated and carried through principally by four groups of personalty interests" that had suffered under the Articles: "money, public securities, manufactures, and trade and shipping." The men who framed it, he argued, represented those interests and understood them. The argument shaped a generation of historians, and it contains a truth. The delegates were men of property, and they wrote a document that forbade the states to issue paper money or impair the obligation of contracts.


The evidence has been hard on Beard's version. Forrest McDonald, in We the People (1958), re-examined the delegates' economic interests and concluded that "the facts did not substantiate" Beard's assumptions. A generation later Robert McGuire, studying the delegates' individual votes with statistical methods, revived the economic argument in a qualified form: the delegates' own interests and their constituents' interests mattered, alongside ideology, but they did not explain everything.⁸⁴ Interest was in the room, as it had been in 1765 and 1776. But the debates that consumed the summer divided large states from small and North from South far more visibly than they divided creditors from debtors.


That It Was a Usurpation

The strongest constitutional objection is the one Paterson and Lansing made in June. Congress had called the Convention "for the sole and express purpose of revising the Articles of Confederation," and New York had sent its delegates on exactly those terms. The Convention threw the Articles away. The Articles required every state to consent to any change, and the Constitution provided that nine would suffice.


The reply has two parts. The first is that the delegates' authority was never uniform. Most of the states had sent their delegates to devise whatever provisions the Union needed, and whether that reached an entirely new frame of government was disputed inside the room from the first week. The second is Wilson's: the delegates were authorized to conclude nothing and free to propose anything. The Convention enacted nothing. It wrote a proposal and sent it out, and it insisted that the proposal be judged not by the legislatures that had sent the delegates but by conventions elected by the people. Gutzman puts the point sharply: in a constitutional sense, the Philadelphia Convention did not do anything; what mattered was ratification.⁸⁵ That leaves the harder question, which the Convention handed to the following year. The Articles derived their authority from the states. The Constitution claimed its authority from the people. Could a body assembled by the existing governments appeal past them to the people themselves? The claim would be worthless unless the people, in each state, actually gave their consent, and that test was still ahead.


That We Cannot Know What Was Said

The third objection is aimed at the record. Madison's notes are the main source for nearly everything in this article, and Madison revised them for years. Mary Sarah Bilder's Madison's Hand (2015) showed, from the manuscript itself, that Madison completed his notes during the Convention only through August 21 and wrote out the rest in the fall of 1789, and she argued that his later revisions tracked his changing views.⁸⁶


The objection is right that the notes are Madison's account and not a transcript. But the record does not rest on Madison alone. The notes of Yates, King, McHenry, and others, the Convention's own journal, and the delegates' letters stand beside his. The debates of 1787 — the equal vote, the veto, the executive, the three-fifths clause, the slave trade — are attested from several directions. What Madison's revisions most affect is how Madison himself appears, which is a reason to read his own speeches with particular care.


A Rising Sun


On Monday, September 17, 1787, the engrossed Constitution was read to the Convention. Nathaniel Gorham moved a last-minute change, reducing the number of people each representative would serve from forty thousand to thirty thousand. Washington, who had kept almost entirely silent in the chair through four months of debate, rose to put the question and spoke. His position, he said, "had hitherto restrained him from offering his sentiments," but he had always thought the small number of representatives "among the exceptionable parts of the plan." The change was agreed to unanimously.⁸⁷


Franklin rose with a speech he had written out "for his own conveniency," and Wilson read it for him. "I confess that there are several parts of this constitution which I do not at present approve," it began. It ended with a request: "I can not help expressing a wish that every member of the Convention who may still have objections to it, would with me, on this occasion doubt a little of his own infallibility, and to make manifest our unanimity, put his name to this instrument."⁸⁸


Three men refused. Randolph, who had introduced the Virginia Plan, would not sign. Neither would Gerry. And neither would Mason, who had told the Convention two days earlier that the government it proposed "would end either in monarchy, or a tyrannical aristocracy," and that "he could not sign here what he could not support there." He wrote out his objections, and the first of them was that "There is no Declaration of Rights."⁸⁹ Thirty-nine men signed. Hamilton signed alone for New York.


While the last of them were signing, Franklin looked toward the president's chair, on the back of which a sun was painted. Painters, he remarked to the men near him, had always found it difficult to distinguish a rising sun from a setting one. "I have said he, often and often in the course of the Session, and the vicisitudes of my hopes and fears as to its issue, looked at that behind the President without being able to tell whether it was rising or setting: But now at length I have the happiness to know that it is a rising and not a setting Sun."⁹⁰


Washington’s Sun Chair, Independence Hall, Philadelphia, PA
Washington’s Sun Chair, Independence Hall, Philadelphia, PA

The doors opened. James McHenry of Maryland recorded that a lady asked Franklin what the delegates had made, a republic or a monarchy, and set down the answer: "A republic replied the Doctor if you can keep it."⁹¹ Washington went back to his lodgings and, as he wrote that night, "retired to meditate on the momentous wk. which had been executed."⁹²


In 1776 the Americans changed the ordering of their arguments. In 1787 they set a government in order, and it was not the order any one of them had planned. Madison wanted a national veto and got a federal union. Hamilton wanted a government modeled on Britain and got a republic. The small states wanted a league and got a Senate. Morris condemned slavery and signed a Constitution with three clauses that protected slaveholding interests. What emerged was a government strong enough to tax and too divided to rule by any single will — the work, as Madison finally admitted, of many heads and many hands.


The Declaration settled why the Americans were free. The Constitution proposed how they would govern themselves across a continent, and it answered both of the old problems by dividing power rather than trusting it. But a proposal binds no one. The plan now went to the people it named in its first line, and some of the ablest men in America — Mason among them — were already preparing to tell those people to refuse it.


The sun was rising. Whether the people would let it was the next question.


Self-Reflection Prompts

  1. Congress called the Convention "for the sole and express purpose of revising the Articles of Confederation," and the Convention produced an entirely new government. Wilson said the delegates could "conclude nothing" but were free to "propose any thing." Is that a sufficient answer to the charge of usurpation, or does it depend entirely on what happened next?

  2. Madison wanted Congress to hold a veto over every state law, "as the K. of G. B. heretofore had," in order to protect individuals from unjust state majorities. The Convention refused every time it was asked. Was Madison wrong about the danger, or wrong about the remedy?

  3. Madison argued that a large republic would protect minorities better than a small one, because a majority would find it harder to form and act. Does the size of the United States today protect minorities from majorities, or has the national government become the very majority he feared?

  4. Gouverneur Morris called slavery "the curse of heaven," and Madison objected to admitting the idea of "property in men" into the text — and both signed a Constitution that protected the slave trade for twenty years. Was the Union worth the bargain, and who had the right to make it?

  5. The Liberty Test. The Congress of the Confederation could not tax a single citizen directly; the money for its common treasury had to be raised by the states. The Constitution gave Congress the power to tax individuals directly. If no individual may take another's property without consent, was the Confederation's weakness a failure of government or a protection of liberty — and did the Constitution leave Americans more free or more governed?


Endnotes

  1. James Madison, notes of debates in the Federal Convention, August 13, 1787, as printed by the Avalon Project, Yale Law School, from The Debates in the Federal Convention of 1787 Which Framed the Constitution of the United States of America, Reported by James Madison, ed. Gaillard Hunt and James Brown Scott (New York: Oxford University Press, 1920), https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_813.asp. Hereafter cited as Madison, Notes, with the date and the Avalon page. Madison's notes are mostly third-person summaries, and the words quoted from them throughout this article are his record of what was said, not a transcript. On the reliability of the notes, see the note to Bilder in the Skeptic's Case. Avalon preserves Madison's spellings and abbreviations (Pinkney, Sharman, Elseworth, Govt., shd., wd.), and quotations here keep them.

  2. Madison, Notes, July 2, 1787, Avalon, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_702.asp. Madison's note records Jenifer's absence in brackets and lists Houston no and Baldwin ay for Georgia; Avalon's footnote gives the result as five to five with Georgia divided. That Baldwin changed his vote to produce the tie is a later reading not stated in the text and is not asserted here.

  3. Madison, Notes, June 30, 1787, Avalon, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_630.asp. Bedford's words follow "The Large States dare not dissolve the Confederation. If they do". A sharper version of the speech, beginning "I do not, gentlemen, trust you," circulates in secondary accounts and is usually attributed to Robert Yates's notes; it is not in Madison, and Yates's entry for June 30 could not be consulted here, so it is not used.

  4. Madison, Notes, July 2, 1787, Avalon, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_702.asp. The proposer is identified in the text as "General PINKNEY," that is, Charles Cotesworth Pinckney, as distinct from his cousin Charles Pinckney, also of South Carolina. The vote to refer the question to a committee of one member from each state was ten to one, Pennsylvania voting no.

  5. Journals of the Continental Congress, July 12, 1776, as printed by the Avalon Project, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/contcong_07-12-76.asp, which records the plan "as brought in by the committee" and notes that the original manuscript "is in the writing of John Dickinson." The entry does not name the members of the committee. On Lee's resolution and Dickinson's speech of July 1, see Article 18.

  6. Articles of Confederation, as printed by the Avalon Project, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/artconf.asp ("Agreed to by Congress 15 November 1777"; "In force after ratification by Maryland, 1 March 1781"). On Maryland's condition, Center for the Study of the American Constitution, University of Wisconsin–Madison, https://archive.csac.history.wisc.edu/706.htm, which gives the Maryland act of ratification as February 2, 1781, and the signing by its delegates as March 1.

  7. Articles of Confederation, arts. II and III, Avalon Project.

  8. Articles of Confederation, arts. VIII, IX, and XIII, Avalon Project. Article IX also required the assent of nine states before Congress could engage in war, coin money, borrow, emit bills, or appropriate money; Congress could borrow and emit bills of credit, but it could not lay a tax.

  9. Definitive Treaty of Peace, September 3, 1783, art. 1, as printed by the Avalon Project, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/paris.asp (the page heading gives an incorrect date; the text is dated "this third day of September"); Library of Congress catalog record for the printed Land Ordinance, https://www.loc.gov/item/90898212/, giving May 20, 1785; Northwest Ordinance, July 13, 1787, art. 6, as printed by the Avalon Project, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/nworder.asp. Article 6 also provided that a person escaping into the territory from whom labor or service was lawfully claimed in one of the original states "may be lawfully reclaimed."

  10. Center for the Study of the American Constitution, "America's First Proposed Federal Tariff: The Imposts of 1781 and 1783," April 8, 2025, https://csac.history.wisc.edu/2025/04/08/americas-first-proposed-federal-tariff-the-imposts-of-1781-and-1783/, which gives no author: state payments "usually amounted to about half of what Congress had requested." The figure is the Center's general estimate and is not a total for any particular year. A starker figure for the requisition of 1786, cited from Calvin H. Johnson by the Congressional Research Service's Constitution Annotated, has not been checked against Johnson's book and is not used.

  11. CSAC, "Imposts of 1781 and 1783": Congress adopted the first impost on February 3, 1781; Rhode Island rejected it on November 1, 1782, the only state to do so; Virginia repealed its ratification on December 7, 1782. New York ratified the second impost in May 1786 on condition that it collect the revenue itself, which Congress would not accept; the New York legislature held to its conditions in February 1787.

  12. John Fiske, The Critical Period of American History, 1783–1789 (Boston and New York: Houghton, Mifflin, 1888), as transcribed by Project Gutenberg; Fiske himself quotes the phrase "the most critical period of the country's history" from William Henry Trescot. John Quincy Adams, commencement oration at Harvard, July 18, 1787, in Diary of John Quincy Adams, vol. 2, Massachusetts Historical Society, https://www.masshist.org/publications/adams-papers/index.php/view/DQA02p257.

  13. Merrill Jensen, The Articles of Confederation: An Interpretation of the Social-Constitutional History of the American Revolution, 1774–1781 (Madison: University of Wisconsin Press, 1940), and The New Nation: A History of the United States during the Confederation, 1781–1789 (New York: Knopf, 1950); George William Van Cleve, We Have Not a Government: The Articles of Confederation and the Road to the Constitution (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2017). The summaries of Jensen's and Van Cleve's arguments are drawn from published descriptions of their books, not from the books themselves, which have not been consulted here.

  14. Mass Humanities, "Rebels Attack Springfield Arsenal," Mass Moments, https://massmoments.org/moment-details/rebels-attack-springfield-arsenal.html, for the closing of the Northampton court on August 29, 1786.

  15. George Washington to Henry Lee Jr., October 31, 1786, Papers of George Washington, Confederation Series, vol. 4, Founders Online, National Archives, https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Washington/04-04-02-0286. Founders Online transcribes "government" in lowercase in both passages.

  16. Washington to James Madison, November 5, 1786, Founders Online, https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Washington/04-04-02-0299.

  17. Richard Colton, "Conflict and Ambivalence in Shays's Rebellion" (Springfield Armory National Historic Site, 2007), consulted in a federal-government copy in the govdocs1 corpus, which spells the general's name "Shepherd" and quotes his report; Mass Moments, "Rebels Attack Springfield Arsenal," for the date and the number of attackers. Accounts differ on the toll, some giving four killed; Colton gives three dead on the ground and a fourth mortally wounded. Mass Moments also gives the rout at Petersham; no day is asserted here.

  18. Thomas Jefferson to James Madison, January 30, 1787, Papers of Thomas Jefferson, vol. 11, Founders Online, https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Jefferson/01-11-02-0095. The more famous line about the tree of liberty is from Jefferson to William Stephens Smith, November 13, 1787, Founders Online, 01-12-02-0348.

  19. Proceedings of Commissioners to Remedy Defects of the Federal Government, Annapolis, September 14, 1786, as printed by the Avalon Project, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/annapoli.asp. On Hamilton's authorship, the editorial headnote in Papers of James Madison, vol. 9, Founders Online, https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Madison/01-09-02-0043, which names Madison as the chief witness to it.

  20. Resolution of Congress, February 21, 1787, as printed by the Avalon Project, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/const04.asp.

  21. Act of the Delaware General Assembly appointing deputies, February 3, 1787, as reprinted by the Center for the Study of the American Constitution, https://csac.history.wisc.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/281/2024/04/DC2-01-01-08_Delaware_3Feb87.pdf; Madison, Notes, May 30, 1787, Avalon, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_530.asp, which records that the Delaware deputies "were restrained by their commission from assenting to any change of the rule of suffrage."

  22. James Madison, "Vices of the Political System of the United States," April 1787, Papers of James Madison, vol. 9, Founders Online, https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Madison/01-09-02-0187, headings 9 ("Multiplicity of laws"), 10 ("mutability of the laws"), and 11 ("Injustice of the laws of States"). Madison's preparatory reading and his notes on ancient and modern confederacies are treated in Article 1.

  23. Madison to Thomas Jefferson, March 19, 1787, Founders Online, https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Madison/01-09-02-0169; Madison to Edmund Randolph, April 8, 1787, Founders Online, 01-09-02-0197; Madison to George Washington, April 16, 1787, Founders Online, 01-09-02-0208. On the Declaratory Act of 1766 and its phrase "in all cases whatsoever," see Article 18.

  24. Kevin R. C. Gutzman, "A Friendship That Shaped America," review of Jeff Broadwater, Jefferson, Madison, and the Making of the Constitution, Law & Liberty, June 19, 2020, https://lawliberty.org/book-review/a-friendship-that-shaped-america/, for the quoted sentence and for Madison's expectation that without the veto the Constitution would fail; Western Connecticut State University news release on the publication of Gutzman's James Madison and the Making of America (New York: St. Martin's Press, 2012), https://www.wcsu.edu/news-archives/?p=441, quoting Gutzman, for "unhappy stepfather"; Kevin Raeder Gutzman, "From Interposition to Nullification: Peripheries and Center in the Thought of James Madison," Essays in History 36 (1994), as reproduced at constitution.org, for the veto as the provision on which Madison was most insistent. The biography itself has not been consulted here, and no page is asserted.

  25. Madison to William Cogswell, March 10, 1834, Founders Online, https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Madison/99-02-02-2952, an unannotated early-access text.

  26. Madison, preface to his debates ("A Sketch Never Finished nor Applied"), printed in Max Farrand, ed., The Records of the Federal Convention of 1787, rev. ed. (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1937), vol. 3, appendix A; the first passage as quoted in Farrand's introduction, Online Library of Liberty, https://oll.libertyfund.org/pages/farrand-on-the-federal-convention-of-1787, and the second as transcribed by ConSource from Farrand. No page is asserted.

  27. Madison, Notes, May 25, 1787, Avalon, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_514525.asp.

  28. Madison, Notes, May 29, 1787, Avalon, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_529.asp, additional rules. The first edition of Madison's notes appeared in The Papers of James Madison, Purchased by Order of Congress, ed. Henry D. Gilpin, 3 vols. (Washington: Langtree & O'Sullivan, 1840), per the catalog of the Historical Society of Pennsylvania. The Convention's official journal was published in 1819 and Robert Yates's notes in 1821.

  29. Madison, Notes, May 29, 1787, Avalon, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_529.asp. Randolph's sixth resolution gave the national legislature power to negative state laws "contravening in the opinion of the National Legislature the articles of Union"; the negative on all state laws that Madison wanted was moved separately on June 8.

  30. Madison, Notes, May 30, 1787, Avalon, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_530.asp. The House "went into Committee of the Whole on the State of the Union," and the resolution was adopted in committee, not yet as a final act of the Convention. The states' commissions were not uniform, and whether the delegates had authority to propose a new frame of government was disputed among them; see the note on the credentials. The phrasing quoted is the motion as Madison records it; the committee's adopted form is abbreviated ("a national governt. ought to be established consisting of a supreme Legislative Executive & Judiciary").

  31. Madison, Notes, May 31, 1787, Avalon, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_531.asp. On Wilson's Considerations of 1774, see Article 18.

  32. Madison, Notes, June 6, 1787, Avalon, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_606.asp.

  33. Madison, Notes, June 8, 1787, Avalon, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_608.asp. Madison's tally of the Virginia delegation reads "Mr. R. Mr. Mason no. Mr. Blair, Docr. Mc. g. Mr. M. ay. Genl. W. not consulted."

  34. Madison, Notes, June 9, 1787, Avalon, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_609.asp.

  35. Madison, Notes, June 15, 1787, Avalon, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_615.asp.

  36. Madison, Notes, June 16, 1787, Avalon, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_616.asp.

  37. Credentials of the delegates, as printed by the Avalon Project (Connecticut, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New York, and Pennsylvania, linked from https://avalon.law.yale.edu/subject_menus/constpap.asp) and by Teaching American History from Charles C. Tansill, ed., Documents Illustrative of the Formation of the Union of the American States (Washington, D.C., 1927) (Delaware, Georgia, Maryland, North Carolina, South Carolina, and Virginia), https://teachingamericanhistory.org/resource/tansill/credentials-of-members. New York's resolution of March 6, 1787, used Congress's words, "for the sole and express purpose of revising the Articles of Confederation." Massachusetts and Connecticut recited Congress's resolution; Connecticut then authorized its delegates to discuss such alterations and provisions, "agreeable to the general Principles of Republican Government," as they thought proper. The others did not use Congress's phrase. New Jersey's act of November 23, 1786, which preceded Congress's resolution, authorized "devising such other Provisions as shall appear to be necessary to render the Constitution of the Federal Government adequate to the exigencies thereof." Pennsylvania, Virginia, Delaware, Georgia, and Maryland authorized, in nearly identical words, such "alterations and further Provisions" as might be necessary to render the federal constitution adequate to the exigencies of the Union, Delaware with its proviso on the equal vote. North Carolina and New Hampshire authorized their delegates to decide upon "the most effectual means to remove the defects of our Fæderal Union" (New Hampshire: "remedy"). South Carolina's act of March 8, 1787, authorized "all such Alterations, Clauses, Articles and Provisions, as may be thought necessary to render the Fæderal Constitution entirely adequate to the actual Situation and future good Government of the confederated States." Rhode Island sent no delegates. On June 9 Paterson asked that the Massachusetts commission be read, saying that Congress's act "was recited in several of the Commissions, particularly that of Massts." (https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_609.asp).

  38. Madison, Notes, June 16, 1787, Avalon, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_616.asp.

  39. Madison, Notes, June 18, 1787, Avalon, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_618.asp. No note-taker records the length of the speech. Hamilton's own outline, Papers of Alexander Hamilton, vol. 4, Founders Online, https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Hamilton/01-04-02-0098-0002, names "Aristotle—Cicero—Montesquieu—Neckar"; Madison's notes name only Necker.

  40. Robert Yates, notes of the Federal Convention, June 21, 1787, as printed by the Avalon Project, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/yates.asp. Madison's version of the same remark refers to Hamilton as the one gentleman who "boldly and decisively contended for an abolition of the State Govts." (https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_621.asp).

  41. Madison, Notes, June 19, 1787, Avalon, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_619.asp.

  42. Madison, Notes, June 11, 1787, Avalon, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_611.asp.

  43. Madison, Notes, June 27, 1787, Avalon, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_627.asp; Madison, Notes, June 28, 1787, Avalon, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_628.asp.

  44. Madison, Notes, June 28, 1787, Avalon, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_628.asp. The punctuation after "truth" is Avalon's.

  45. Madison, Notes, June 29, 1787, Avalon, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_629.asp.

  46. Madison, Notes, July 16, 1787, Avalon, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_716.asp. The committee's report, delivered by Gerry on July 5, recommended one member of the first branch for every forty thousand inhabitants, money bills originating in the first branch and not to be amended by the second, and an equal vote for each state in the second branch, "on condition that both shall be generally adopted" (https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_705.asp).

  47. Madison's account of the meeting is printed at the end of his notes for July 16, 1787, Avalon, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_716.asp.

  48. Madison, Notes, July 17, 1787, Avalon, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_717.asp. The vote on the negative: Massachusetts, Virginia, and North Carolina aye; Connecticut, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Delaware, Maryland, South Carolina, and Georgia no. Martin's resolution was agreed to "nem: con:". It became, in revised form, the supremacy clause of Article VI.

  49. Western Connecticut State University, "When Moderates Ruled: A History of the U.S. Constitution at WCSU," August 30, 2017, https://news.wcsu.edu/when-moderates-ruled-a-history-of-the-u-s-constitution-at-wcsu/, quoting Gutzman. The same release quotes his view that Washington and Madison went to Philadelphia "planning to propose a radically centralizing constitution."

  50. Articles of Confederation, art. IX, Avalon Project, authorizing Congress to appoint "a committee, to sit in the recess of Congress, to be denominated 'A Committee of the States'," to appoint one of its members to preside, and to appoint "such other committees and civil officers as may be necessary for managing the general affairs of the United States under their direction."

  51. Madison, Notes, June 1, 1787, Avalon, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_601.asp.

  52. Madison, Notes, June 1, 1787, Avalon, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_601.asp. On June 2 Franklin's written speech on executive salaries referred to Randolph's phrase.

  53. Madison, Notes, June 2, 1787, Avalon, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_602.asp.

  54. Madison, Notes, September 4, 1787, Avalon, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_904.asp.

  55. Amendment to the Articles of Confederation proposed by Congress, April 18, 1783, as reprinted with editorial note in The Documentary History of the Ratification of the Constitution, vol. 1, by the Center for the Study of the American Constitution, https://csac.history.wisc.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/281/2024/04/DC1-01-01-05_Amendment-to-Share-Expenses-According-to-Population_18Apr83.pdf. The phrase on despair is Madison's, as quoted in the editors' note.

  56. Madison, Notes, June 11, 1787, Avalon, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_611.asp. The motion passed nine states to two, New Jersey and Delaware voting no.

  57. Madison, Notes, July 11, 1787, Avalon, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_711.asp. The motion of Butler and Pinckney to count slaves equally with free inhabitants failed, three states to seven.

  58. Madison, Notes, July 12, 1787, Avalon, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_712.asp. Ellsworth's motion fixing the rule at "the number of white inhabitants, and three fifths of every other description" passed six states to two, with Massachusetts and South Carolina divided.

  59. Madison, Notes, August 8, 1787, Avalon, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_808.asp. Morris's motion to insert "free" before "inhabitants" received the vote of New Jersey alone.

  60. Madison, Notes, August 21, 1787, Avalon, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_821.asp. The record of the debates from this point to the end of the Convention carries a particular caution: Mary Sarah Bilder's examination of Madison's manuscript indicates that his account of the debates after August 21 was completed from rough notes in the fall of 1789. See the note to Bilder in the Skeptic's Case.

  61. Madison, Notes, August 22, 1787, Avalon, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_822.asp. Ellsworth's remark about Mason begins the reply quoted. The vote to send the slave-trade and navigation questions to a committee passed seven states to three.

  62. Madison, Notes, August 25, 1787, Avalon, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_825.asp. Between Sherman's objection and Madison's, King, Langdon, Pinckney, Mason, Gorham, and Gouverneur Morris spoke; the amendment to "such importation" followed Madison's remark and was agreed to without dissent. The vote on substituting 1808: New Hampshire, Massachusetts, Connecticut, Maryland, North Carolina, South Carolina, and Georgia aye; New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Delaware, and Virginia no. The clause as amended referred to "the Legislature"; the final text of Article I, section 9, reads "the Congress" and permits a tax "not exceeding ten dollars for each Person."

  63. Madison, Notes, August 29, 1787, Avalon, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_829.asp, including Madison's footnote. The motion to require two-thirds of each house for navigation acts failed, and the requirement was struck.

  64. Madison, Notes, August 28, 1787, Avalon, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_828.asp; Madison, Notes, August 29, 1787, Avalon, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_829.asp, where the revised clause is recorded as agreed to nem. con.

  65. Constitution of the United States, art. IV, sec. 2, cl. 3, as transcribed by the National Archives, https://www.archives.gov/founding-docs/constitution-transcript.

  66. Sean Wilentz, No Property in Man: Slavery and Antislavery at the Nation's Founding (Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 2018); the summary follows his own words in his reply to Nicholas Guyatt, New York Review of Books, June 27, 2019, https://www.nybooks.com/articles/2019/06/27/no-property-in-man-wilentz-guyatt-exchange/, that "The concessions to the slaveholders helped secure slavery where it already existed while leaving open its expansion" and that by refusing to acknowledge "property in man" the Convention "excluded slavery from national law." David Waldstreicher, Slavery's Constitution: From Revolution to Ratification (New York: Hill and Wang, 2009); the summary follows the publisher's description, https://academic.macmillan.com/academictrade/9780809016501/slaverysconstitution. In a reply to Wilentz in The Atlantic in 2015, seen here only as quoted by a secondary source, Waldstreicher called the Constitution "deliberately ambiguous – but operationally proslavery." Don E. Fehrenbacher, The Slaveholding Republic: An Account of the United States Government's Relations to Slavery, completed and edited by Ward M. McAfee (New York: Oxford University Press, 2001); the summary follows the publisher's description that "the Constitution itself was more or less neutral on the issue of slavery" and the book's own subject, the federal government's later relations to slavery. None of the three books has been consulted directly here.

  67. Massachusetts Historical Society, "Garrison burns the Constitution," https://masshist.org/database/431?pid=36, on Framingham, July 4, 1854; Frederick Douglass to Gerrit Smith, May 21, 1851, Frederick Douglass Papers Project, https://frederickdouglasspapersproject.com/item/5407. Garrison had used the phrase in print by January 1845.

  68. Madison, Notes, June 27, 1787, Avalon, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_627.asp, in Madison's spellings. "Lord Summers" is John Somers; "Priestly" is Joseph Priestley; "Rutherford" is Thomas Rutherforth, author of Institutes of Natural Law.

  69. Madison, Notes, June 30, 1787, Avalon, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_630.asp; Madison, Notes, July 11, 1787, Avalon, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_711.asp; Madison, Notes, July 17, 1787, Avalon, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_717.asp. The count rests on a page-by-page search of all eighty-eight daily pages of Madison's notes on Avalon, and other spellings may have escaped it. Other note-takers record further references: King for Wilson on June 1, Yates for Butler on June 23, and Hamilton's own outline for June 18. Article 14 discussed these and Donald Lutz's citation study, which covers published political writing and not the Convention floor.

  70. Madison, Notes, August 29, 1787, Avalon, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_829.asp.

  71. Madison, Notes, June 22, 1787, Avalon, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_622.asp. The bracket is Madison's.

  72. Madison, Notes, August 13, 1787, Avalon, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_813.asp. Dickinson spoke on the question whether money bills should originate only in the House.

  73. Madison, "Report on Books for Congress," [January 23,] 1783, Papers of James Madison, vol. 6, Founders Online, https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Madison/01-06-02-0031. The list shows that Madison knew and recommended these works; it does not show what he owned.

  74. David Hume, "Idea of a Perfect Commonwealth," in Essays, Moral, Political, and Literary, as printed by davidhume.org, https://davidhume.org/texts/pld/ipc, paragraph 69 of that edition.

  75. The Federalist No. 10, as printed by the Avalon Project from the New York Packet, November 23, 1787, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/fed10.asp.

  76. Douglass Adair, "'That Politics May Be Reduced to a Science': David Hume, James Madison, and the Tenth Federalist," Huntington Library Quarterly 20, no. 4 (August 1957): 343–60. Adair's reading has been extended and complicated rather than overturned. Mark G. Spencer, "Hume and Madison on Faction," William and Mary Quarterly, 3rd ser., 59, no. 4 (October 2002), revised as chapter 6 of his David Hume and Eighteenth-Century America (Rochester: University of Rochester Press, 2005), argues, in the chapter's published summary, that "A choice between books and experience — between theory and practice — is a false one," and that Hume's History of England influenced Madison "more significantly, and in different ways," than the essays Adair emphasized. Neither the article nor the chapter has been consulted beyond its summary.

  77. The search of The Federalist was a full-text search of the eighty-five papers in the Project Gutenberg text; Smith is not named, Hume is named once, in a footnote to No. 85, and Montesquieu twelve times, in Nos. 9, 43, 47, and 78. The search of Madison's notes is described in the note on Montesquieu above.

  78. This is an inference from convergence, not a demonstrated chain of transmission. That Dickinson named no source is evidence against a claim that he was citing one; it does not show how the idea reached him.

  79. Madison, Notes, July 23, 1787, Avalon, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_723.asp. Ellsworth's motion to refer the plan to the state legislatures had failed, three states to seven; the vote to refer it to assemblies chosen by the people was nine to one, Delaware voting no. Ratification was not a national referendum. Under Article VII and the Convention's resolution of September 17, 1787 (Avalon Project, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/ressub01.asp), each state legislature called a convention of delegates "chosen in each State by the People thereof," elected under that state's own arrangements and by its own qualified voters. On how the legislatures called the conventions, see the Center for the Study of the American Constitution, https://csac.history.wisc.edu/multimedia/maps/; New York, for one, admitted "all free male citizens of the age of twenty-one years, and upwards" to vote for its convention delegates.

  80. Report of the Committee of Detail, Madison, Notes, August 6, 1787, Avalon, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_806.asp, whose preamble begins "We the people of the States of New Hampshire, Massachussetts" and names all thirteen; report of the Committee of Style, Madison, Notes, September 12, 1787, Avalon, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_912.asp; the final text as transcribed by the National Archives. On Gouverneur Morris as the hand behind the final wording, Madison to Jared Sparks, April 8, 1831, Founders Online, https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Madison/99-02-02-2323: "The finish given to the style and arrangement of the Constitution, fairly belongs to the pen of Mr. Morris."

  81. Madison, Notes, May 29, 1787, Avalon, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_529.asp, Randolph's sixth resolution, which would also have given the national legislature power to legislate "in which the harmony of the United States may be interrupted by the exercise of individual Legislation"; the enumerated powers first appear in the report of the Committee of Detail, Madison, Notes, August 6, 1787, Avalon, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_806.asp.

  82. Madison, Notes, September 12, 1787, Avalon, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_912.asp.

  83. Madison to Jefferson, September 6, 1787, Papers of James Madison, vol. 10, Founders Online, https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Madison/01-10-02-0115 (partly in cipher); Madison to Jefferson, October 24, 1787, Founders Online, 01-10-02-0151. "Bare majority" is Madison's description; the vote of July 17 as recorded in his notes was three states to seven.

  84. Charles A. Beard, An Economic Interpretation of the Constitution of the United States (New York: Macmillan, 1913), quoted from the first of the numbered conclusions that close the book, as transcribed by Wikisource; Project Gutenberg's text (no. 70677) reproduces the reprint of July 1914. Beard denied the cruder reading of his thesis. Opening his chapter on the economic interests of the members of the Convention, he wrote that "The purpose of such an inquiry is not, of course, to show that the Constitution was made for the personal benefit of the members of the Convention." Forrest McDonald, We the People: The Economic Origins of the Constitution (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1958); McDonald's words are quoted from Jac C. Heckelman and Keith L. Dougherty, "An Economic Interpretation of the Constitutional Convention of 1787 Revisited," Journal of Economic History 67, no. 4 (2007): 829–48, at 830, who cite McDonald, We the People, 400, a page not seen here. Robert A. McGuire and Robert L. Ohsfeldt, "Economic Interests and the American Constitution: A Quantitative Rehabilitation of Charles A. Beard," Journal of Economic History 44, no. 2 (1984): 509–19, and "An Economic Model of Voting Behaviour over Specific Issues at the Constitutional Convention of 1787," Journal of Economic History 46, no. 1 (1986): 79–111, whose authors' abstracts report that economic interests, constituents' interests, and ideology all mattered in the delegates' votes; Robert A. McGuire, To Form a More Perfect Union: A New Economic Interpretation of the United States Constitution (Oxford University Press, 2003). Heckelman and Dougherty, 830–31, note that McGuire and Ohsfeldt did not claim, as Beard had, that economic holdings fully explained the votes; Russell S. Sobel, reviewing the book in The Independent Review 8, no. 3 (Winter 2003/04), describes it as essentially resurrecting Beard's hypothesis. McGuire's book has not been consulted directly. Article 1 named Beard and McDonald.

  85. Kevin R. C. Gutzman, "Can You Trust James Madison?," review of Bilder, Madison's Hand, The American Conservative, June 23, 2016, https://www.theamericanconservative.com/can-you-trust-james-madison/. The point is paraphrased.

  86. Mary Sarah Bilder, Madison's Hand: Revising the Constitutional Convention (Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 2015), winner of the Bancroft Prize in 2016. The chronology is given in Bilder's own words in an interview with the Society for Historians of the Early American Republic, The Panorama, August 29, 2016, https://thepanorama.shear.org/2016/08/29/interview-with-mary-sarah-bilder-2016-james-bradford-biography-prize-winner/: "In the summer of 1787, Madison only completed the Notes through August 21," and "In the fall of 1789, he wrote the remaining section using rough notes." The book itself has not been consulted here, and no page is asserted. Her interpretation of what particular revisions meant is more contested than her chronology. Stuart Leibiger, "James Madison, Constitutional Convention Spin Doctor?," Commonplace, https://commonplace.online/article/james-madison-constitutional-convention-spin-doctor/, accepts the late writing-out of the notes after August 21 and regards some of her other conclusions as speculative. Farrand noted that Madison also revised his record of votes to match the Convention's journal after its publication in 1819. On the other note-takers, Farrand, Records, and James H. Hutson, ed., with Leonard Rapport, Supplement to Max Farrand's The Records of the Federal Convention of 1787 (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1987).

  87. Madison, Notes, September 17, 1787, Avalon, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_917.asp. Gorham's motion was "agreed to unanimously."

  88. Madison, Notes, September 17, 1787, Avalon, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_917.asp.

  89. Madison, Notes, September 15, 1787, Avalon, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_915.asp; Mason, "Objections to The Constitution of Government formed by the Convention," as reproduced by the American Revolution Institute from the manuscript copy among Washington's papers at the Library of Congress, https://www.americanrevolutioninstitute.org/?p=6907, which dates it to about September 16, 1787. Mason's objections belong to the ratification contest and are taken up in the next article. For the signers, National Archives, "Meet the Framers of the Constitution," https://www.archives.gov/founding-docs/founding-fathers: fifty-five delegates attended and thirty-nine signed. Hamilton's colleagues Yates and Lansing had left the Convention on July 10, per the New York chronology in The Documentary History of the Ratification of the Constitution, vol. 19 (2003), as published by CSAC.

  90. Madison, Notes, September 17, 1787, Avalon, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_917.asp.

  91. James McHenry, anecdote, in Farrand, Records, vol. 3, appendix A, no. CXVI, as transcribed by Wikisource, where a starred note adds that "The lady here aluded to was Mrs. Powel of Philada." Farrand's own footnote cites the first printing in the American Historical Review 11 (1906): 618, and says that "The date of this is uncertain." The Library of Congress, which holds McHenry's journal, describes the note naming Elizabeth Willing Powel as an addition in McHenry's hand. The anecdote is a single-witness account written down at an uncertain date.

  92. Washington, Diary, September 17, 1787, Founders Online, https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Washington/01-05-02-0002-0009-0017. A second, shorter version of the entry on Founders Online does not contain the passage.


Sources and Further Reading


Primary Sources

Articles of Confederation. 1777–1781. Avalon Project, Yale Law School.

Constitution of the United States. 1787. National Archives.

Continental Congress. Resolution of February 21, 1787, calling the Federal Convention. Avalon Project.

Farrand, Max, ed. The Records of the Federal Convention of 1787. 3 vols. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1911; rev. ed., 4 vols., 1937.

The Federalist. Nos. 10 and 85. New York, 1787–1788.

Gilpin, Henry D., ed. The Papers of James Madison, Purchased by Order of Congress. 3 vols. Washington: Langtree & O'Sullivan, 1840.

Hamilton, Alexander. Notes for a speech of June 18, 1787. In The Papers of Alexander Hamilton, vol. 4. Founders Online.

Hume, David. "Idea of a Perfect Commonwealth." In Essays, Moral, Political, and Literary.

Hunt, Gaillard, and James Brown Scott, eds. The Debates in the Federal Convention of 1787, Reported by James Madison. New York: Oxford University Press, 1920. Avalon Project.

Hutson, James H., ed., with Leonard Rapport. Supplement to Max Farrand's The Records of the Federal Convention of 1787. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1987.

Jefferson, Thomas. Letter to James Madison, January 30, 1787. Founders Online.

Madison, James. "Vices of the Political System of the United States." April 1787. Founders Online.

Madison, James. "Report on Books for Congress." January 1783. Founders Online.

Madison, James. Letters to Thomas Jefferson, March 19, September 6, and October 24, 1787; to Edmund Randolph, April 8, 1787; to George Washington, April 16, 1787; to Jared Sparks, April 8, 1831; to William Cogswell, March 10, 1834. Founders Online.

Mason, George. "Objections to The Constitution of Government formed by the Convention." September 1787.

Northwest Ordinance. July 13, 1787. Avalon Project.

Proceedings of Commissioners to Remedy Defects of the Federal Government. Annapolis, September 14, 1786. Avalon Project.

Washington, George. Letters to Henry Lee Jr., October 31, 1786, and to James Madison, November 5, 1786; Diary, September 17, 1787. Founders Online.

Yates, Robert. Notes of the Federal Convention. Avalon Project.


Secondary Works

Adair, Douglass. "'That Politics May Be Reduced to a Science': David Hume, James Madison, and the Tenth Federalist." Huntington Library Quarterly 20, no. 4 (1957): 343–60.

Beard, Charles A. An Economic Interpretation of the Constitution of the United States. New York: Macmillan, 1913.

Bilder, Mary Sarah. Madison's Hand: Revising the Constitutional Convention. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 2015.

Fehrenbacher, Don E. The Slaveholding Republic: An Account of the United States Government's Relations to Slavery. Completed and edited by Ward M. McAfee. New York: Oxford University Press, 2001.

Fiske, John. The Critical Period of American History, 1783–1789. Boston and New York: Houghton, Mifflin, 1888.

Gutzman, Kevin R. C. James Madison and the Making of America. New York: St. Martin's Press, 2012.

Gutzman, Kevin Raeder. "From Interposition to Nullification: Peripheries and Center in the Thought of James Madison." Essays in History 36 (1994).

Gutzman, Kevin R. C. "A Friendship That Shaped America." Law & Liberty, June 19, 2020.

Gutzman, Kevin R. C. "Can You Trust James Madison?" The American Conservative, June 23, 2016.

Jensen, Merrill. The Articles of Confederation. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press, 1940.

Jensen, Merrill. The New Nation: A History of the United States during the Confederation, 1781–1789. New York: Knopf, 1950.

McDonald, Forrest. We the People: The Economic Origins of the Constitution. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1958.

McGuire, Robert A. To Form a More Perfect Union: A New Economic Interpretation of the United States Constitution. Oxford University Press, 2003.

Spencer, Mark G. "Hume and Madison on Faction." William and Mary Quarterly, 3rd ser., 59, no. 4 (2002).

Van Cleve, George William. We Have Not a Government: The Articles of Confederation and the Road to the Constitution. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2017.

Waldstreicher, David. Slavery's Constitution: From Revolution to Ratification. New York: Hill and Wang, 2009.

Wilentz, Sean. No Property in Man: Slavery and Antislavery at the Nation's Founding. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 2018.

Next: Article 20 — "The Loyal Opposition"

Comments


bottom of page