top of page

"The Loyal Opposition" — The Critics of the Constitution, 1787–1788

Writer: Jeff Kellick
Jeff Kellick
Nov 1
42 min read

SELF-EVIDENT The Road to 1776 Article 20 of 22


Instead of being thirteen republics, under a federal head, it is clearly designed to make us one consolidated government. — The Federal Farmer, letter dated October 8, 1787¹

We, the States


On Wednesday, June 4, 1788, Patrick Henry rose in the Virginia ratifying convention at Richmond and asked a question about three words. Eight states had already ratified the Constitution. One more would put it into effect among them, and Virginia — the state of Washington, Madison, and Henry — was deciding whether to be inside or outside the new Union when it began. Henry did not start with taxes, or armies, or courts. He started with the document's very first line.


"What right had they to say, We, the people?" he asked. "My political curiosity, exclusive of my anxious solicitude for the public welfare, leads me to ask, Who authorized them to speak the language of, We, the people, instead of, We, the states?"²


It was the question the Convention in Philadelphia had handed to the following year. The delegates had been sent by state legislatures, under commissions that varied from state to state, to repair a league of sovereign states. They had come home with a government that claimed its authority from the people of a continent, and they had asked the people, state by state, to confirm the claim. Henry's point was that the claim had been made before anyone had confirmed it. The Articles of Confederation spoke for states. The Constitution, in its first three words, spoke for a people that had not yet been asked.

Henry's charge had a documentary basis, and his opponents knew it. Congress had called the Convention "for the sole and express purpose of revising the Articles of Confederation." New York's legislature made those words its own, and Massachusetts and Connecticut recited Congress's resolution in their commissions; most of the other states authorized whatever further provisions the Union needed, and the delegates in Philadelphia had argued among themselves whether that reached a new frame of government.³ The Federalist answer was James Wilson's from the Convention floor: the delegates could conclude nothing and propose anything, and the proposal meant nothing until the people adopted it. Henry's reply was that the proposal had already presumed the answer. A document that began by speaking for the people of the United States had decided, before a single state convention met, that there was such a people to speak for.


The men who agreed with Henry would lose. By the end of July 1788, eleven states had ratified, and the government they had warned against was preparing to meet. But they did not lose quietly, and they did not lose everything. They forced a long public argument over first principles, carried on in newspapers and in the state conventions. They extracted, from convention after convention, lists of amendments the new government would be asked to adopt. And when they had been outvoted, most of them went home and accepted the result. They became what a later political language would call a loyal opposition, and they were opposed to the Constitution itself.


Whether they were also right is a separate question, and the answer is not the same for each of their warnings.


Patrick Henry, a portrait by George Bagby Matthews after Thomas Sully, c. 1891
Patrick Henry, a portrait by George Bagby Matthews after Thomas Sully, c. 1891

A Name Chosen by the Other Side


The first thing to know about the Anti-Federalists is that they did not choose the name. The terms predated the Convention. In the early 1780s the men who supported giving Congress an independent revenue were called federal men, and their opponents anti-federal. In 1787 the Constitution's supporters took the first label for themselves and fastened the second on their critics, who resented it. Those critics argued, with some justice, that they were the real federalists, since it was they who wanted to keep a federal league of states, and their opponents who wanted something closer to a single national government.⁴ The historian Pauline Maier, in the fullest modern account of the ratification contest, refused to use the word at all. She called it, in Jack Rakove's summary, "a disparaging label imposed by the other camp."⁵


The second thing to know is that they were not one party. Some had been leaders of the Revolution. George Mason had written the Virginia Declaration of Rights. Richard Henry Lee had moved the resolution for independence in 1776. Elbridge Gerry had signed the Declaration of Independence and then refused, in Philadelphia, to sign the Constitution, as did Edmund Randolph, the governor of Virginia. Others were farmers and county politicians who never left a mark beyond their own convention votes. Jackson Turner Main, writing in 1961, found the opposition concentrated among small farmers and described its tradition as one founded in a distrust of power.⁶ Saul Cornell, in The Other Founders (1999), divided their thought into elite, middling, and plebeian strands, and showed that the strands did not always agree.⁷ What united them was a set of fears more than a program. A central fear across the opposition was that the new government would swallow the states. Many feared its power to tax, its standing army, and its courts. And the absence of a bill of rights became their most widely shared objection.



Henry himself had been chosen as one of Virginia's delegates to Philadelphia and had declined to go. A story told later has him explaining that he "smelt a rat."⁸ Whatever he said in 1787, by 1788 he had made up his mind about what the Convention had produced.


There Is No Declaration of Rights


George Mason had told the Convention on September 15 that the government it proposed would end in monarchy or a tyrannical aristocracy. In the weeks that followed he wrote out his reasons, first in a draft on the back of a printed copy of the Committee of Style's report, and then in a fair copy that he sent to George Washington on October 7 with a short note: "I take the Liberty to enclose You my Objections to the new Constitution of Government."⁹ The objections circulated first in manuscript copies and were later printed without his consent. In May 1788 Mason complained to Thomas Jefferson that they "were first printed very incorrectly, without my Approbation, or Privity."¹⁰


The objections are a short catalogue of the opposition's case. The first, which the Convention had heard Mason press on September 12, was that "There is no Declaration of Rights; and the Laws of the general Government being paramount to the Laws & Constitution of the several States, the Declarations of Rights in the separate States are no Security."¹¹ Roger Sherman had answered that the state declarations were in force and sufficient. Mason's reply was that the supremacy clause made them no defense against the federal government at all. A state declaration bound a state legislature. It did not bind Congress.


He went on through the structure. The Senate could alter money bills and share in appointments and treaties, "altho' they are not the Representatives of the People, or amenable to them."¹² The president had no constitutional council, and would therefore be "directed by Minions & Favourites" or "become a Tool to the Senate."¹³ There was "no Declaration of any kind for preserving the Liberty of the Press, the Tryal by jury in civil Causes; nor against the Danger of standing Armies in time of Peace."¹⁴


The objection that reached furthest was aimed at a single sentence: the clause at the end of the list of congressional powers authorizing Congress to make all laws "necessary and proper" for carrying the others into execution. "Under their own Construction of the general Clause at the End of the enumerated Powers," Mason wrote, "the Congress may grant monopolies in Trade & Commerce, constitute new Crimes, inflict unusual & severe punishments, and extend their Power as far as they shall think proper; so that the State Legislatures have no Security for the Powers now presumed to remain to them; or the People for their Rights."¹⁵ Mason's fear was not that the clause said too much. It was that Congress, reading it by their own Construction, would be the judge of what it meant.


He closed with a prediction. "This Government will commence in a moderate Aristocracy; it is at prese[nt] impossible to foresee whether it will, in its operation, produce a Monarchy, or a corrupt oppressive Aristocracy; it will most probably vibrate some years between the two, and then terminate in the one or the other."¹⁶


Brutus, Centinel, and the Federal Farmer


Mason signed his name. Most of the Anti-Federalists did not. The argument of 1787 and 1788 was carried on largely in newspapers, under Roman and rustic pseudonyms, and the identity of several of the ablest writers is still disputed.


Centinel

One of the first sustained attacks appeared in Philadelphia on October 5, 1787, under the name Centinel. Its author was almost certainly Samuel Bryan, whose father, George Bryan, sat on the Pennsylvania Supreme Court.¹⁷ Centinel set the tone for much of what followed. The Constitution's grants of taxation and of legislative and judicial power, he argued, "must in their operation, necessarily absorb the state legislatures and judicatories," and the framers had let the state governments survive in form only, "as a blind." He called the plan "a most daring attempt to establish a despotic aristocracy among freemen, that the world has ever witnessed," and he noticed what the document left out: the framers had "made no provision for the liberty of the press, that grand palladium of freedom, and scourge of tyrants, but observed a total silence on that head."¹⁸


Cato

In New York, a writer calling himself Cato published seven letters in the New York Journal between September 27, 1787, and January 3, 1788. They were long attributed to Governor George Clinton, but the attribution rests on little.¹⁹ Cato's fourth letter took up the presidency. Measuring its powers and its long tenure, he asked wherein the president differed from "the king of Great-Britain (save as to name, the creation of nobility and some immaterial incidents, the offspring of absurdity and locality)," and concluded "that if the president is possessed of ambition, he has power and time sufficient to ruin his country."²⁰


The Federal Farmer

The most measured of the newspaper writers signed himself the Federal Farmer. His first five letters, dated October 8 to 13, 1787, were published as a pamphlet in New York in November, and thirteen more followed the next spring.²¹ The letters were long credited to Richard Henry Lee, an attribution Federalists first made and historians repeated. In 1974 Gordon Wood questioned it; in 1987 Robert Webking argued for Melancton Smith of New York; and in 2025 the Center for the Study of the American Constitution, which publishes the documentary history of ratification, argued for Elbridge Gerry.²²


The Farmer did not reject union. He laid out three possible plans — distinct republics in a loose league, a complete consolidation of the states into one government, and a "partial consolidation" in which the general government took the powers that were truly common and left the rest with the states. The third, he wrote, "is, in my opinion, the only one that can secure the freedom and happiness of this people." His complaint was that the Constitution was not that plan. "Instead of being thirteen republics, under a federal head, it is clearly designed to make us one consolidated government."²³


His sharpest objection was to the size of the House of Representatives. The Constitution provided for sixty-five members at first, one for every thirty thousand people at most. "We have about 200 state senators in the United States," the Farmer observed, "and a less number than that of federal representatives cannot, clearly, be a full representation of this people, in the affairs of internal taxation and police, were there but one legislature for the whole union."²⁴ Madison's answer to the old doctrine that republics must be small had been that a large republic would filter the passions of the many through a few chosen representatives. The Farmer accepted the premise and drew the opposite conclusion. A few representatives for a great many people would be precisely the men of wealth and reputation who could win a large district, and they would not know or share the concerns of the farmers and tradesmen they represented. What Madison called refinement, the Farmer called distance.


On the army he took the old Whig position. "A militia, when properly formed, are in fact the people themselves, and render regular troops in a great measure unnecessary."²⁵


Brutus

The most penetrating wrote as Brutus, in sixteen essays printed in the New York Journal between October 18, 1787, and April 10, 1788. The essays were long credited to Robert Yates, who had walked out of the Philadelphia Convention in July. The Center for the Study of the American Constitution now reports that recent research points to Melancton Smith instead, and a 2008 study argued for John Williams.²⁶


Brutus began with the necessary and proper clause and the supremacy clause, and from them he drew a prediction. The Constitution was not yet a complete consolidation, he conceded, but "what this constitution wants of being a complete consolidation of the several parts of the union into one complete government, possessed of perfect legislative, judicial, and executive powers, to all intents and purposes, it will necessarily acquire in its exercise and operation." Congress might use its powers "entirely to annihilate all the state governments, and reduce this country to one single government. And if they may do it, it is pretty certain they will; for it will be found that the power retained by individual states, small as it is, will be a clog upon the wheels of the government of the United States; the latter therefore will be naturally inclined to remove it out of the way."²⁷


The power to tax, he wrote, "connects with it almost all other powers, or at least will in process of time draw all other after it; it is the great mean of protection, security, and defense, in a good government, and the great engine of oppression and tyranny in a bad one."²⁸ He warned that a standing army might "subvert the forms of the government, under whose authority, they are raised," and he reached back to the English Civil War for his example: "The same army, that in Britain, vindicated the liberties of that people from the encroachments and despotism of a tyrant king, assisted Cromwell, their General, in wresting from the people, that liberty they had so dearly earned."²⁹


But the essays that have outlived the rest are the ones on the courts. Brutus saw, earlier than most, what an independent federal judiciary might become. "The judicial power will operate to effect, in the most certain, but yet silent and imperceptible manner, what is evidently the tendency of the constitution:—I mean, an entire subversion of the legislative, executive and judicial powers of the individual states." The judges would decide cases "according to what appears to them, the reason and spirit of the constitution," and "The opinions of the supreme court, whatever they may be, will have the force of law; because there is no power provided in the constitution, that can correct their errors, or controul their adjudications."³⁰ In March 1788 he put it more starkly still. Of judges holding office during good behavior he wrote: "There is no authority that can remove them, and they cannot be controuled by the laws of the legislature. In short, they are independent of the people, of the legislature, and of every power under heaven." They would "extend the limits of the general government gradually, and by insensible degrees, and to accomodate themselves to the temper of the people."³¹


What They Had Read

The Anti-Federalists' arguments were not new, and they did not pretend that they were. The small-republic doctrine came from Montesquieu, as an earlier article in this series traced. The fear of a standing army came from the seventeenth century, from the army that had purged Parliament and the Commonwealth that ended in a Lord Protector — the England of the Levellers and of Algernon Sidney. The Scottish writers had restated it for the eighteenth; Adam Ferguson had argued for a citizen militia in 1756. When the Federal Farmer wrote that a militia "are in fact the people themselves," he was writing in a language that ran through all of them, whether or not he had any one of them open on his desk.³² And when the Virginia convention came to write its own list of rights in June 1788, it began with words taken almost directly from Mason's Declaration of Rights of 1776: that there are certain natural rights "of which men when they form a social compact cannot deprive or divest their posterity."³³ Twelve years earlier Mason had written that men "cannot, by any compact, deprive or divest their posterity" of their inherent rights.³⁴ The idea echoes Locke. The words were Mason's, and it was the Anti-Federalists who carried them into the ratifying conventions.


Every Thing Which Is Not Given


The Constitution's defenders did not leave the argument to their opponents. On October 6, 1787, a day after Centinel's first essay, James Wilson addressed a crowd in the State House yard in Philadelphia and gave the answer that would be repeated through the whole contest. A state constitution, he said, granted its legislature every power not expressly withheld, so that "every thing which is not reserved is given." The federal Constitution worked the other way. Under it, "every thing which is not given, is reserved."³⁵ A bill of rights limiting a government of enumerated powers was unnecessary, because the government had no power over the things a bill of rights would protect.


Madison made the same promise in the forty-fifth Federalist, published January 26, 1788: "The powers delegated by the proposed Constitution to the Federal Government, are few and defined. Those which are to remain in the State Governments are numerous and indefinite."³⁶ Hamilton went further in the eighty-fourth. Bills of rights, he wrote, "are not only unnecessary in the proposed Constitution, but would even be dangerous. They would contain various exceptions to powers not granted; and, on this very account, would afford a colorable pretext to claim more than were granted. For why declare that things shall not be done which there is no power to do?"³⁷


The Federalist case deserves its full weight, because it was not a dodge. Wilson, Madison, and Hamilton were describing a real design. The final Constitution gave Congress no general legislative competence: the Committee of Detail replaced the Virginia Plan's broad grant with a list of congressional powers, and the Convention adopted the list. The states kept their own governments, their own courts, their own militias, and their own declarations of rights. Hamilton's warning about bills of rights was a serious one: a list of protected rights can be read as implying that everything not on the list is unprotected, and that the government holds every power not expressly denied to it.


The Anti-Federalist reply turned on two words in Mason's objection: their own Construction. A government of enumerated powers was only as limited as the people who interpreted the enumeration. The necessary and proper clause, the general welfare language in the taxing clause, and the supremacy of federal law would all be interpreted, in the end, by the federal government itself. Wilson's principle might be true on paper and false in practice. And if the Federalists were right that the federal government had no power over the press or religion or juries, then a bill of rights would cost nothing. If they were wrong, it was the only protection there was. Patrick Henry put it in a sentence in June 1788: "If you intend to reserve your unalienable rights, you must have the most express stipulation." He answered Hamilton's danger with a danger of his own. Every nation, he argued, had read it the other way — "That all rights not expressly and unequivocally reserved to the people, are impliedly and incidentally relinquished to rulers" — and a bill of rights would end the question before it began: "A Bill of Rights, even if its necessity be doubtful, will exclude the possibility of dispute, and with great submission, I think the best way is to have no dispute."³⁸


Both sides, in other words, feared the same thing: a government reading its powers by implication. They disagreed about which list would invite it.


Nine States


The Constitution needed nine states. The fight to reach nine, and then to bring in the large states that could not be left out, ran from December 1787 to July 1788, and it was closer than the early returns suggested.


The First Five

The first five states ratified within five weeks. Delaware ratified unanimously, 30 to 0, on December 7, 1787. Pennsylvania followed on December 12, 46 to 23. New Jersey ratified unanimously on December 18, Georgia unanimously on December 31, and Connecticut on January 9, 1788, by 128 to 40.³⁹ Several were small states that had won an equal vote in the Senate.


Pennsylvania was the exception to the calm. Its Federalists had moved quickly, and the outvoted minority answered with a public address. The Address and Reasons of Dissent of the Minority of the Convention of the State of Pennsylvania to their Constituents, dated December 12 and printed on December 18, listed the propositions the minority had wanted adopted. The first was "The right of conscience shall be held inviolable." Another protected "the freedom of speech, of writing and publishing their sentiments," and declared that "the freedom of the press shall not be restrained by any law of the United States."⁴⁰ The minority dissented, they wrote, "because the powers vested in Congress by this constitution, must necessarily annihilate and absorb the legislative, executive, and judicial powers of the several states, and produce from their ruins one consolidated government," which "from the nature of things will be an iron handed despotism."⁴¹


Massachusetts

Massachusetts was the first state where the result was in doubt. Its convention met in January 1788, and the Federalists found a way through. On January 31 Governor John Hancock, the convention's president, proposed that it ratify and at the same time recommend amendments for the new Congress to consider. On February 6, 1788, the convention ratified by 187 to 168, and it attached nine recommended amendments.⁴² The first was the principle the Federalists had been promising all along, put in writing: "That it be explicitly declared that all Powers not expressly delegated by the aforesaid Constitution are reserved to the several States to be by them exercised."⁴³


The Massachusetts compromise changed the contest. A delegate who doubted the Constitution no longer had to choose between voting it down and accepting it as it was. He could vote to ratify and, in the same act, put the new government on notice. Maryland ratified on April 26 by 63 to 11, and South Carolina on May 23 by 149 to 73, with amendments of its own.⁴⁴ New Hampshire's convention had met in February and adjourned without a vote. It met again in June and, on June 21, 1788, ratified by 57 to 47, with amendments. It was the ninth state.⁴⁵


Nine states were enough to put the Constitution into effect among them. They were not enough to make a nation. Virginia and New York had not decided, and a union without either of them was hard to imagine.


Richmond

Henry spoke in Richmond often and at length, and the record of what he said is one man's shorthand. David Robertson took the debates down, and the printed editions descend from his record.⁴⁶ Even through a reporter's hand, the speeches keep their force. On June 5 Henry told the convention that the Constitution had "an awful squinting; it squints towards monarchy." He asked what would become of the states' defense when the militia was "put into the hands of Congress," and he predicted that "A standing army we shall have, also, to execute the execrable commands of tyranny." And he gave the convention his creed in a sentence: "Liberty, the greatest of all earthly blessings—give us that precious jewel, and you may take every thing else!"⁴⁷


The Federalist reply in Richmond was not Hamilton's reply. Edmund Randolph, who had refused to sign in Philadelphia, now supported ratification, because eight states had adopted the Constitution and he did not believe they would turn back. "I will assent to the lopping of this limb," he said — meaning his arm, as the reporter noted — "before I assent to the dissolution of the Union."⁴⁸ He, George Nicholas, and Madison made the case for the Constitution in terms the doubters in the room could accept. Kevin Gutzman has traced what those terms were. In his account, Randolph told the convention that Congress would have only the powers "expressly" granted to it. Gutzman's reading is that "Virginia Federalists secured ratification only by promising Virginia's ratification convention that the new Constitution would have left Virginia's sovereignty essentially untouched," and that Randolph knew of delegates whose doubts had been quieted by those assurances.⁴⁹


The opposition's last stand was a motion to require amendments before ratification. On June 25 it failed, 80 to 88. The convention then ratified by 89 to 79.⁵⁰ Two days later it adopted a list of recommended amendments in two parts: a declaration of rights of twenty articles, and twenty amendments to the body of the Constitution. The first of the structural amendments repeated the Massachusetts principle, that each state "shall respectively retain every power, jurisdiction and right" not delegated by the Constitution.⁵¹ Henry had lost. A shift of five delegates would have carried the motion for prior amendments.


Poughkeepsie

New York was harder still. When its convention assembled at Poughkeepsie on June 17, the opposition outnumbered the Federalists by more than two to one, and the opposition's leader on the floor was Melancton Smith — the same Smith whom some historians believe to have written as Brutus, and others as the Federal Farmer.⁵² On June 24 the convention learned that New Hampshire had become the ninth state, and on July 2 that Virginia had followed.⁵³ New York could now stay out only by staying out of a Union that already existed. It was also the state for which the most famous defense of the Constitution had been written. Hamilton, Madison, and John Jay had addressed every one of the eighty-five essays of The Federalist "To the People of the State of New York," and Hamilton and Jay were at Poughkeepsie to argue the case in person.⁵⁴


Smith had come to Poughkeepsie intending to make ratification conditional on amendments. The Federalists' reply was that Congress would not accept such a ratification at all, and Hamilton read the convention a letter from Madison on the point. Smith came to believe them.⁵⁵ On July 23 he told the convention: "I cannot help concluding that a conditional adoption is a rejection." His amendments, he said, "should be recommendatory," and he warned of the alternative: "Disunion on the contrary will not only beget weakness and of Course insecurity against foreign dangers." The question before the delegates was plain. "It is now for us to decide whether we will become the eleventh or not."⁵⁶ That day the convention voted 31 to 29 to strike the words "upon condition" from its form of ratification and substitute "in full confidence."⁵⁷ On July 26, 1788, New York ratified by 30 to 27, the closest margin among the first eleven states.⁵⁸


The same day, the convention unanimously approved a circular letter to the other states, signed by Governor Clinton as its president. "Several articles in it appear so exceptionable to a majority of us," the letter said, "that nothing but the fullest confidence of obtaining a revision of them by a General Convention, and an invincible reluctance to separating from our sister States, could have prevailed upon a sufficient number to ratify it, without stipulating for previous amendments."⁵⁹ New York had ratified, and in the same breath it had called for a second convention to revise what it had ratified.


The Last Two

North Carolina's convention met at Hillsborough in July and, on August 2, 1788, voted by roughly a hundred votes neither to ratify nor to reject, until amendments had been put before Congress. Rhode Island, which had sent no delegates to Philadelphia, put the Constitution to its towns in a referendum on March 24, 1788, and rejected it by 2,711 to 239. North Carolina ratified on November 21, 1789, after the new government was in operation. Rhode Island held out until May 29, 1790, and ratified by 34 to 32.⁶⁰


Were They Right?


The Anti-Federalists have been called prophets, and they have been called men of little faith. Both readings have a case. The way to judge between them is to take their warnings one at a time.


Where the Record Supports Them

On the direction of power, Brutus and Mason saw further than their opponents. Brutus predicted that the necessary and proper clause and the supremacy of federal law would carry the general government, "by insensible degrees," far past the "few and defined" powers Madison described. He predicted that the federal courts would decide cases by "the reason and spirit of the constitution," and that no power in the government could correct them. He predicted that the power to tax would "draw all other after it." On implied national powers and on the reach of the federal courts, those warnings describe the later history of American government more closely than Madison's description in Federalist 45.


Mason's fear about "their own Construction" proved even more exact. Less than three years after ratification, Congress debated whether it could charter a national bank. Madison, who had promised a government of few and defined powers, told the House on February 2, 1791, that "the power exercised by the bill was condemned by the silence of the constitution." Hamilton answered, in an opinion for the president, that "necessary often means no more than needful, requisite, incidental, useful, or conducive to." Washington signed the bill, and in 1819 the Supreme Court adopted Hamilton's reading.⁶¹ The national government took the broader construction Mason had feared, and in McCulloch v. Maryland the Court gave it lasting constitutional authority.


Gutzman's work on Virginia adds a further point. The opposition did not only predict. It extracted promises. The Federalists who carried Virginia did so on assurances that Congress would have only the powers expressly granted, and Gutzman has faulted later readings of Madison for neglecting his "concern to maintain fidelity to vows about limited central government—federalism—Federalists had made during the ratification campaign."⁶² On this reading, the Anti-Federalists' arguments became part of what the Constitution was understood to mean when it was adopted. When later generations read federal power broadly, they were departing not only from the Anti-Federalists' fears but from the Federalists' own promises.


Where It Does Not

Other warnings did not come true, or not on the Anti-Federalists' schedule. Mason's prediction that the government would "vibrate some years" between monarchy and aristocracy and then "terminate in the one or the other" was wrong. The presidency did not become a crown, and the Senate, whose powers Mason had attacked at length, was made elective by the people in 1913.⁶³ Cato's fear that an ambitious president would have "power and time sufficient to ruin his country" was answered, for a long time, by the first president's own example: Washington retired after two terms, and no president served a third until 1941.⁶⁴


And the alarm subsided quickly. Michael Klarman, who has written that the Federalists "barely won the ratification contest despite enjoying a number of structural advantages," also observes that by the end of 1789, on Madison's report to Washington, "the fears of former Antifederalists had been laid largely to rest."⁶⁵ The first Congress under the Constitution did not abolish the states, raise a standing army against the people, or silence the press. The government Brutus and Mason feared took decades to arrive, and when it came it came by routes they had not named as well as by the ones they had.


The Dialogue

Herbert Storing, who edited the Anti-Federalists' writings in seven volumes, concluded that their importance did not depend on whether they won. The country's principles, in the words of his publisher's summary of his argument, are to be found "in the dialogue, not merely in the Federalist victory."⁶⁶ The Federalists supplied the Constitution. The Anti-Federalists supplied the questions it would be measured against, and much of what Americans still argue about — the reach of federal power, the authority of the courts, the meaning of a bill of rights — was first argued in their newspapers.


Their arguments also had a political afterlife. Cornell traces the dissenting tradition into the Jeffersonian opposition of the 1790s, and Gutzman traces the Virginia version of it into the Virginia and Kentucky Resolutions of 1798, which Madison and Jefferson wrote against the Alien and Sedition Acts. From the point of view of Virginians who remembered what the Federalists had promised in Richmond, Gutzman writes, those resolutions were "merely 'an appeal to the real laws of our country.'"⁶⁷ The men who had defended the Constitution in 1788 were, ten years later, using the opposition's reading of it against the government it had created.


On the main question, the record supports the Anti-Federalists more than their opponents. They were wrong about monarchy and wrong about how fast it would come, but they were right about the direction, and they were right that a government left to construe its own powers would construe them generously. On the question of consolidation, this writer tends to side with the Anti-Federalist case.


The Skeptic's Case


That They Were Men of Little Faith

In 1955 Cecelia Kenyon gave the Anti-Federalists a name that stuck: "men of little faith." Her reading, as it is usually summarized, was that they distrusted every form of power and offered no workable alternative to the government they opposed.⁶⁸ There is something in this. The Articles of Confederation had failed to raise a revenue, regulate trade, or bind the states to their own commitments, as the previous article traced, and most Anti-Federalists conceded that the Articles needed strengthening. Their own proposals often amounted to a stronger Confederation that would have depended on the same states that had refused to pay before. A critic who will accept no government strong enough to act is not offering an alternative.


The reply is that most of them accepted more than Kenyon allowed. The Federal Farmer wanted a "partial consolidation." The recommended amendments of Massachusetts, Virginia, and New York accepted the Constitution and asked for limits on it. Smith voted to ratify. Their faith was not in no government but in a government whose limits were written down.


That Prophecy Is Easy at a Distance

A prediction that power will grow is hard to get wrong. Governments tend to grow, and a reader two centuries later can find confirmation of nearly any warning about consolidation. They also predicted that consolidation would come through particular clauses — the necessary and proper clause, the taxing power, the courts. Much of the later shift toward national power came instead through amendments adopted under Article V: the Fourteenth, which imposed new federal restraints on the states and later became the vehicle through which most of the Bill of Rights was applied to them; the Sixteenth, which removed the apportionment requirement from federal income taxes; and the Seventeenth, which transferred the choice of senators from the state legislatures to the voters. Those changes were not consolidation by construction. They were consolidation by consent.⁶⁹


The objection is fair, and it limits the claim. What the critics got right was not that power would grow but that a government judging its own limits would not hold them, and that the states, having surrendered the final word on federal power, would not get it back. The amendments that enlarged federal power were adopted under a Constitution whose amendment process the Anti-Federalists had accepted, and the Sixteenth Amendment is, if anything, evidence that the original taxing clause had limits that held for a long time. A claim that the critics were right about everything is not supported. A claim that they were right about the main thing is.


That They Defended Their Own Interests

Klarman has described the making of the Constitution as "ordinary interest group politics," and the description cuts both ways. Federalist support ran strongest among merchants, creditors, and the commercial towns, where a government that could pay its debts and enforce contracts had obvious value. Anti-Federalist strength was greater among small farmers in the interior, and some of the state governments they defended had passed the paper-money and debtor-relief laws Madison had listed among the vices of the states. Some of their devotion to the states was devotion to governments that had protected debtors from their creditors.⁷⁰


That is true of some of them, and it does not settle what their arguments were worth. An argument about the dangers of a government that judges its own powers does not become false because the man making it owed money. Brutus on the courts and Mason on the necessary and proper clause stand or fall on what happened to the courts and the clause.


The Loyal Opposition

When New York ratified, Melancton Smith voted aye. He had led the opposition at Poughkeepsie for nearly six weeks, and he may well have written as Brutus, and he decided that a Union which existed was better than a Union his state stood outside. Henry, outvoted in Richmond, told the convention, in the words his biographer Jon Kukla quotes as his closing remarks, "Yet I will be a peaceable citizen!"⁷¹ The opposition did not take up arms against the result or walk out of the Union. It accepted the decision and kept the argument. That is what a loyal opposition does, and the Anti-Federalists of 1788 did it under a Constitution they had opposed.


They lost the vote, and they left behind three things. The first was a record: the essays of Brutus, Centinel, the Federal Farmer, and the rest, and the debates of the state conventions, taken down and printed. The second was a set of promises. In Richmond and elsewhere the Constitution's friends had told the conventions that the new government would have only the powers expressly given, and that promise was now part of what the people had been told they were adopting. The third was a list. Massachusetts, South Carolina, New Hampshire, Virginia, and New York had each recommended amendments, and North Carolina declined to ratify in 1788 until amendments had been put before Congress. Some were declarations of rights — conscience, the press, trial by jury. Others would have cut the new government's powers to tax and to keep an army.⁷² New York wanted a second convention.


In Richmond, Madison had been with the majority that refused to amend the Constitution before ratifying it.⁷³ Whether the new government would amend it afterward, which amendments it would choose, and who would draft them, was the question the opposition left to the First Congress.


Self-Reflection Prompts

  1. Patrick Henry asked who had authorized the delegates in Philadelphia to speak for "We, the people" rather than "We, the states." Did ratification by popularly elected conventions in each state answer his question, or only confirm the claim he was objecting to?

  2. James Wilson argued that under the Constitution "every thing which is not given, is reserved," and Hamilton warned that a bill of rights might imply powers that were never granted. Mason answered that Congress would read its own powers by "their own Construction." Which side does the history of the necessary and proper clause support?

  3. The Federal Farmer argued that a House of sixty-five members could not fully represent the people of thirteen states, and Madison argued that a few representatives for many people would refine the public's views. After the 2020 census, each member of the House represents an average of 761,169 people.⁷⁴ Which of them better described what that would mean?

  4. Melancton Smith led the opposition in New York and then voted to ratify, because "a conditional adoption is a rejection." Was he right to put the Union first, or did he give up the one moment when the opposition could have secured amendments before the government began?

  5. The Liberty Test. Brutus warned that federal judges would be "independent of the people, of the legislature, and of every power under heaven," and that they would extend federal power "by insensible degrees." If no individual may claim authority over another that no one can review, can a court that answers to no one be the guardian of liberty — and did the Constitution, on this point, leave Americans more free or more governed?


Endnotes


  1. The Federal Farmer, letter I, dated October 8, 1787, in Observations Leading to a Fair Examination of the System of Government Proposed by the Late Convention (New York, 1787), as reprinted in The Documentary History of the Ratification of the Constitution (hereafter DHRC), vol. 14, by the Center for the Study of the American Constitution (hereafter CSAC), University of Wisconsin–Madison, https://csac.history.wisc.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/281/2024/04/DC3-01-03-05_Federal-Farmer-Letters_8Nov87.pdf. On the authorship of the letters, see the note on the Federal Farmer's attribution below.

  2. Patrick Henry, Virginia ratifying convention, June 4, 1788, in Jonathan Elliot, ed., The Debates in the Several State Conventions on the Adoption of the Federal Constitution, 2nd ed., vol. 3, 22–23, as reprinted in The Founders' Constitution, ed. Philip B. Kurland and Ralph Lerner (University of Chicago Press), Preamble, document 14, https://press-pubs.uchicago.edu/founders/documents/preambles14.html. The italics of the printed text are not reproduced. Eight states had ratified by that date; the eighth, South Carolina, ratified on May 23, 1788 (see the note on the first five states for the CSAC table).

  3. Resolution of Congress, February 21, 1787, as printed by the Avalon Project, Yale Law School, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/const04.asp. The variation in the delegates' credentials, state by state, is set out in the note on the commissions in Article 19, and Wilson's remark that he was "authorized to conclude nothing, but to be at liberty to propose any thing" is from Madison's notes for June 16, 1787 (Avalon, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_616.asp), also treated there. The commissions did not fall into two clean categories. New York adopted Congress's words; Massachusetts and Connecticut recited Congress's resolution, and Connecticut then authorized such alterations and provisions as its delegates thought proper; the others used their own operative terms, from "such alterations and further Provisions" as might render the federal constitution adequate, in Pennsylvania, Virginia, Delaware, Georgia, and Maryland, to South Carolina's grant of whatever was necessary to make it "entirely adequate."

  4. Center for the Study of the American Constitution, "Federalist and Antifederalist: The Origin of the Terms," https://csac.history.wisc.edu/popular-culture-and-ratification/federalist-and-antifederalist/, which traces the terms to the contest over the impost of 1783, quotes Samuel Bryan that they "grew up in New York & in the Eastern States, some Time before the Calling of the Convention," and records that the Constitution's opponents resented the label and claimed to be the true federalists. The New York opposition organized in 1788 as the Federal Republican Committee (CSAC, "New York Attempts," https://csac.history.wisc.edu/states-and-ratification/new-york/new-york-attempts/). This article uses "Anti-Federalists" and "the Constitution's critics" interchangeably.

  5. Jack Rakove, review of Pauline Maier, Ratification: The People Debate the Constitution, 1787–1788 (New York: Simon & Schuster, 2010), Harvard Magazine, December 16, 2010, https://www.harvardmagazine.com/print/30248: "She refuses to call the Constitution's opponents Anti-Federalists, a disparaging label imposed by the other camp." The words are Rakove's description of Maier's choice, not Maier's own.

  6. Jackson Turner Main, The Antifederalists: Critics of the Constitution, 1781–1788 (Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press for the Institute of Early American History and Culture, 1961; reprinted 2004 with a foreword by Edward Countryman). The characterization follows the Omohundro Institute's description of the book, which speaks of "a libertarian tradition founded in a distrust of power," https://oieahc.wm.edu/publications/books/available-titles/the-antifederalists/; the book itself has not been consulted here.

  7. Saul Cornell, The Other Founders: Anti-Federalism and the Dissenting Tradition in America, 1788–1828 (Chapel Hill: Omohundro Institute of Early American History and Culture and University of North Carolina Press, 1999). The characterization follows the book's chapter titles as listed in its table of contents ("Elite Anti-Federalist Political and Constitutional Thought," "Middling Constitutionalism," "Plebeian Populism"), Historical Society of Pennsylvania catalog, https://discover.hsp.org/Record/marc-290369/TOC, and the publisher's description, https://uncpress.org/book/9780807847862/the-other-founders. The book has not been consulted beyond these.

  8. No contemporary source for the remark has been found. Michael J. Klarman repeats it ("like Patrick Henry, they 'smelt a rat'") in "The Founding Revisited," Harvard Law Review 125 (2011): 544, https://harvardlawreview.org/wp-content/uploads/2011/12/vol125_klarman.pdf, and Thomas S. Kidd, a biographer of Henry, has called it the way Henry "famously explained his refusal to attend" (The Imaginative Conservative, March 2017, https://theimaginativeconservative.org/2017/03/patrick-henry-oppose-constitution-timeless-thomas-kidd.html). The popular form "I smell a rat" is a modernization. Klarman's review is cited for Henry's having declined his appointment.

  9. George Mason to George Washington, October 7, 1787, Papers of George Washington, Confederation Series, vol. 5, Founders Online, National Archives, https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Washington/04-05-02-0331. Mason's objections survive in more than one form. The text quoted in this article is the fair copy among Washington's papers at the Library of Congress, as transcribed by the American Revolution Institute of the Society of the Cincinnati, "Objections to The Constitution of Government formed by the Convention," https://www.americanrevolutioninstitute.org/?p=6907, and printed in DHRC, vol. 8, 40–46 (CSAC, https://csac.history.wisc.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/281/2024/04/DC2-05-05-01_Masons-Objections_7Oct87.pdf, which dates it by the cover letter of October 7). An earlier draft, headed "Objections to This Constitution of Government," was written on a printed copy of the Committee of Style's report; its manuscript is described as being in the Chapin Library, Williams College (as reproduced at constitution.org, https://www.constitution.org/gmason/objections.html), and its wording differs in places, including the closing prediction. Printed versions, including a Richmond printing of 1787 titled The Objections of the Hon. George Mason, to the Proposed Federal Constitution, differ again in title and capitalization.

  10. Mason to Thomas Jefferson, May 26, 1788, as reprinted by CSAC, https://csac.history.wisc.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/281/2024/04/DC2-05-05-05_Mason-to-Jefferson_26May88.pdf. When and where the objections were first printed is disputed. The American Revolution Institute's headnote states that a Philadelphia printer obtained the document and issued it "about October 4," naming no newspaper. The editors of the Washington Papers state that the objections "first appeared in print on 22 Nov. in the Virginia Journal, and Alexandria Advertiser," after Tobias Lear gave a copy to its printer (editorial note to Mason to Washington, October 7, 1787, Founders Online), and the DHRC headnote to an essay printed in the same issue agrees that the Virginia Journal printed the objections on November 22, 1787 (CSAC, https://csac.history.wisc.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/281/2024/04/DC2-05-05-03_Brutus_22Nov87.pdf). No first-printing date is asserted here. Both accounts describe copies passing from hand to hand before any newspaper printing: the Institute's printer "obtained" the document, and Tobias Lear, Washington's secretary, carried a copy to the Alexandria printer.

  11. Mason, "Objections," American Revolution Institute transcription. Mason's wish for a bill of rights on September 12, 1787, Gerry's motion, and Sherman's reply are treated in Article 19, from Madison's notes for that day.

  12. Mason, "Objections," American Revolution Institute transcription.

  13. Mason, "Objections," American Revolution Institute transcription. The full passage reads that the president "will generally be directed by Minions & Favourites—or He will become a Tool to the Senate—or a Council of State will grow out of the principal Officers of the great Departments."

  14. Mason, "Objections," American Revolution Institute transcription.

  15. Mason, "Objections," American Revolution Institute transcription. The printed text in Paul Leicester Ford, ed., Pamphlets on the Constitution of the United States (Brooklyn, 1888), as reprinted by the Online Library of Liberty, https://oll.libertyfund.org/page/1787-mason-objections-to-the-proposed-constitution-letter, reads "no security for the powers now presumed to remain to them." Capitalization in the American Revolution Institute transcription should be checked against the manuscript image before republication.

  16. Mason, "Objections," American Revolution Institute transcription; the bracketed letters are the Institute's. The early draft reads "This government will set out a moderate aristocracy" and "a corrupt, tyrannical aristocracy."

  17. Centinel I, Independent Gazetteer (Philadelphia), October 5, 1787, DHRC, vol. 13, 326–37, as reprinted by CSAC, https://csac.history.wisc.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/281/2024/04/DC3-01-03-01_Centinel-I_5Oct87.pdf, whose headnote states that the essays, "despite contemporary opinion, appear to have been written by Samuel Bryan." Contemporaries credited his father, George Bryan, a justice of the Pennsylvania Supreme Court; Samuel Bryan later identified himself as Centinel in his own letters.

  18. Centinel I, as printed by Teaching American History, https://old.teachingamericanhistory.org/document/centinel-i/, except the second passage, which follows the DHRC reading ("a most daring attempt"); the Teaching American History text reads "the most daring."

  19. Teaching American History, Cato index, for the dates of the seven letters in the New York Journal; DHRC New York chronology for Cato I, September 27, 1787. The attribution to George Clinton was made by Paul Leicester Ford in 1892. Joel A. Johnson, "'Brutus' and 'Cato' Unmasked: General John Williams's Role in the New York Ratification Debate, 1787–88," Proceedings of the American Antiquarian Society 118, pt. 2 (2008): 297–337, https://www.americanantiquarian.org/proceedings/45147499.pdf, finds little evidence for Clinton and argues for John Williams.

  20. Cato IV, New York Journal, November 8, 1787. The first passage is from the DHRC excerpt reprinted by CSAC, https://archive.csac.history.wisc.edu/Cato_IV.pdf; the second from Teaching American History, https://teachingamericanhistory.org/library/document/cato-iv/, whose header gives the date as November 8, 1787 (the page elsewhere gives an incorrect date of January 3, 1788).

  21. CSAC, "Identifying the Federal Farmer: Unravelling the Mystery of an Antifederalist Treasure," April 1, 2025, https://csac.history.wisc.edu/2025/04/01/identifying-the-federal-farmer-unravelling-the-mystery-of-an-antifederalist-treasure/, for the first pamphlet (about November 8, 1787; five letters dated October 8–13, 1787) and An Additional Number of Letters from the Federal Farmer to the Republican (New York, May 2, 1788; thirteen letters dated December 25, 1787, to January 25, 1788).

  22. Gordon S. Wood, "The Authorship of the Letters from the Federal Farmer," William and Mary Quarterly, 3rd ser., 31, no. 2 (April 1974): 299 ff.; Robert H. Webking, "Melancton Smith and the Letters from the Federal Farmer," William and Mary Quarterly, 3rd ser., 44, no. 3 (July 1987): 510–28, bibliographic data confirmed from the journal's tables of contents; CSAC, "Identifying the Federal Farmer" (2025), which states that "A far more likely author is Elbridge Gerry" and that the case for Smith rests on a shared quotation that "provides no viable proof of Smith's authorship." The attribution to Richard Henry Lee was first made by Federalists and adopted by Paul Leicester Ford in 1888. The question is open, and the letters are cited here by their pseudonym.

  23. The Federal Farmer, letter I, dated October 8, 1787, DHRC, vol. 14, as reprinted by CSAC (see the note to the epigraph).

  24. The Federal Farmer, letter II, dated October 9, 1787, as printed by Teaching American History, https://teachingamericanhistory.org/document/federal-farmer-ii/. The House's initial size and the ratio of one representative for every thirty thousand are from the Constitution, art. I, sec. 2, as transcribed by the National Archives, https://www.archives.gov/founding-docs/constitution-transcript. The summary of the Farmer's argument about who would win large districts paraphrases the reasoning of his second and fifth letters. Madison's argument for the extended republic and its debt to Hume are treated in Article 19.

  25. The Federal Farmer, letter XVIII, dated January 25, 1788, in An Additional Number of Letters, as printed by Teaching American History, https://teachingamericanhistory.org/document/federal-farmer-xviii/.

  26. CSAC, "The Debate Begins," Document of the Month no. 7 (February 2014), https://archive.csac.history.wisc.edu/dotm_0214_the_debate_begins.pdf: historians credited Yates "for almost a century… but recent research indicates that Smith was the author"; CSAC, "Identifying the Federal Farmer" (2025), describes Smith as "far more likely to have written the sixteen essays"; Johnson, "'Brutus' and 'Cato' Unmasked," argues for John Williams, calling his own evidence "not conclusive." On Yates's departure from the Convention on July 10, 1787, see Article 19. The DHRC reprints consulted here carry no note on the authorship of Brutus.

  27. Brutus I, New York Journal, October 18, 1787, DHRC, vol. 19, 103–15, as reprinted by CSAC, https://csac.history.wisc.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/281/2024/04/DC3-05-04-03_Brutus-I_18Oct87.pdf. Brutus I's argument that a free republic cannot extend over so large a territory was treated in Article 14 and is not repeated here.

  28. Brutus I, as printed by Teaching American History, https://teachingamericanhistory.org/document/brutus-i/, whose text modernizes spelling ("defense").

  29. Brutus X, New York Journal, January 24, 1788, as reprinted in The Founders' Constitution, art. 1, sec. 8, cl. 12, document 23, from Herbert J. Storing, ed., The Complete Anti-Federalist, https://press-pubs.uchicago.edu/founders/print_documents/a1_8_12s23.html.

  30. Brutus XI, New York Journal, January 31, 1788, DHRC, vol. 15, 512–17, as reprinted by CSAC, https://csac.history.wisc.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/281/2024/04/DC3-05-02-01_Brutus-XI_31Jan88.pdf.

  31. Brutus XV, New York Journal, March 20, 1788, DHRC, vol. 16, 431–35, as reprinted by CSAC, https://csac.history.wisc.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/281/2024/04/DC3-05-05-04_Brutus-XV_20Mar88.pdf. The spellings "controuled" and "accomodate" are the printed text's.

  32. This is an inference from shared language, not a demonstrated chain of transmission. Montesquieu and the small-republic doctrine are treated in Article 14; the Levellers and the army of the 1640s in Article 9; Sidney in Article 10; Ferguson's militia pamphlet of 1756 in Article 13. The Federal Farmer names none of them in the passage quoted.

  33. Virginia ratifying convention, recommended amendments, June 27, 1788, declaration of rights, art. 1, DHRC, vol. 10, 1550–59, as reprinted by CSAC, https://csac.history.wisc.edu/constitutional-debates/debate-about-amendments/recommendatory-amendments-from-state-conventions/virginia-recommendatory-amendments-27-june-1788/.

  34. Virginia Declaration of Rights, adopted June 12, 1776, sec. 1, as transcribed by the National Archives, https://www.archives.gov/founding-docs/virginia-declaration-of-rights. Mason's committee draft of the Declaration and its relation to Jefferson's are treated in Article 18.

  35. James Wilson, speech in the State House Yard, Philadelphia, October 6, 1787, printed in a special edition of the Pennsylvania Herald, October 9, 1787, DHRC, vol. 13, as reprinted by CSAC, https://csac.history.wisc.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/281/2025/11/James-Wilson-Speech-in-PA-State-House-Yard-Oct-6-1787.pdf.

  36. The Federalist No. 45, Independent Journal (New York), January 26, 1788, as reprinted by CSAC, https://csac.history.wisc.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/281/2023/12/DC6-04-45_Federalist-45_26Jan88.pdf, which preserves the newspaper's capitals. The Avalon Project's text of the McLean edition lowercases "federal government" and "State governments."

  37. The Federalist No. 84, as printed by the Avalon Project from the McLean edition, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/fed84.asp. The essay first appeared in the second volume of the McLean edition, published May 28, 1788, and was then serialized in the New York newspapers in July and August (editorial note, Papers of Alexander Hamilton, vol. 4, Founders Online, https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Hamilton/01-04-02-0247).

  38. Henry, Virginia ratifying convention, June 16, 1788, in Elliot, Debates, vol. 3, as reprinted in The Founders' Constitution, vol. 1, ch. 14, document 39, https://press-pubs.uchicago.edu/founders/documents/v1ch14s39.html.

  39. CSAC, "State-by-State Table of Ratification Information, 1787–1791," https://csac.history.wisc.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/1026/2024/05/DC9_Ratification-at-a-Glance-Table-v2.pdf, and CSAC, "General Ratification Chronology, 1786–1939," https://csac.history.wisc.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/1026/2024/05/DC6-00-06_Gen.-Rat.-Chron_1786-1939.pdf, for the dates and votes of all the state conventions given in this article. The dates are those of the convention votes; the signed instruments of ratification in several states bear later dates (Georgia's, for example, January 2, 1788).

  40. The Address and Reasons of Dissent of the Minority of the Convention of the State of Pennsylvania to their Constituents, dated December 12, 1787, first printed in the Pennsylvania Packet, December 18, 1787, DHRC, as reprinted by CSAC, https://archive.csac.history.wisc.edu/The_Dissent_of_the_Minority_of_the_Conventio1.pdf; first proposition as reprinted by CSAC, https://csac.history.wisc.edu/constitutional-debates/debate-about-amendments/recommendatory-amendments-from-state-conventions/dissent-of-the-minority-of-the-convention-of-pennsylvania-12-december-1787/; sixth proposition from CSAC, https://archive.csac.history.wisc.edu/pa_18.pdf.

  41. Address and Reasons of Dissent, as printed by Teaching American History from the broadside printed by Eleazer Oswald, https://teachingamericanhistory.org/document/the-address-and-reasons-of-dissent-of-the-minority-of-the-convention-of-the-state-of-pennsylvania-to-their-constituents/.

  42. CSAC, Massachusetts chronology, https://csac.history.wisc.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/281/2023/12/DC9-06-00-02_Mass.-Chronology.pdf: "31 January Hancock proposes conciliatory proposition recommending amendments"; "6 February Convention ratifies Constitution 187–168 with nine recommendatory amendments." Hancock's speech of January 31 is in DHRC, vol. 6, as reprinted by CSAC, https://csac.history.wisc.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/281/2025/11/Hancocks-speech-in-Mass-Convention-31-Jan-1788.pdf.

  43. Massachusetts form of ratification, February 6–7, 1788, as reprinted by CSAC, https://archive.csac.history.wisc.edu/mass_form_of_ratification.pdf. Hancock's proposal of January 31 had read "that all powers not expressly delegated to Congress, are reserved to the several States."

  44. CSAC table and chronology, as in the note on the first five states. South Carolina recommended amendments; the chronology records none for Maryland.

  45. CSAC table and chronology. The first session of the New Hampshire convention met February 13–22, 1788.

  46. David Robertson, Debates and Other Proceedings of the Convention of Virginia (Petersburg, 1788–1789). The speeches are quoted here from Elliot's Debates, vol. 3, and from The Founders' Constitution, both of which descend from Robertson's record; Robertson's original edition has not been consulted.

  47. Henry, Virginia ratifying convention, June 5, 1788, Elliot, Debates, vol. 3, as printed by Teaching American History, https://teachingamericanhistory.org/resource/elliot/vol3/june5. Teaching American History's transcription prints "blessing"; other reprints of the speech give "blessings," which is followed here.

  48. Edmund Randolph, Virginia ratifying convention, June 4, 1788, DHRC, vol. 9, 931–36, as reprinted by CSAC, https://csac.history.wisc.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/281/2025/11/Edmund-Randolph-speech-in-Va-Conv-4-June-1788.pdf, which also gives his remark that "those eight States which have adopted the Constitution will not recede." The parenthesis "(meaning his arm)" is in the printed text.

  49. Kevin R. C. Gutzman, Virginia's American Revolution: From Dominion to Republic, 1776–1840 (Lanham, Md.: Lexington Books, 2007), introduction, as reprinted by The Imaginative Conservative, April 2012, https://theimaginativeconservative.org/2012/04/virginias-american-kevin-gutzman.html, for the quoted sentence; Gutzman, "The Virginians," Law & Liberty, May 3, 2012, https://lawliberty.org/the-virginians/, for Randolph's assurance that Congress would have only the powers "expressly" granted and for Randolph's knowledge of delegates whose "scruples" had "been quieted." The assurances are part of the Virginia record, but whether they bound the Constitution to an "express powers only" construction is disputed by two pieces of evidence. Virginia's form of ratification of June 26, 1788, declared that "every power not granted thereby remains with them and at their will," without the word "expressly" (Avalon Project, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/ratva.asp). And on August 18, 1789, opposing a motion to insert "expressly" into the amendment that became the Tenth, Madison told the House "that it was impossible to confine a Government to the exercise of express powers," and recalled that the word "had been moved in the convention of Virginia, by the opponents to the ratification, and, after full and fair discussion, was given up by them" (Annals of Congress 1:761, 767–68, as reprinted in The Founders' Constitution, Amendment X, document 6, https://press-pubs.uchicago.edu/founders/documents/amendXs6.html). Gutzman's reading rests on what the Federalists told the convention; Madison's later account rests on what the convention adopted. The book's third chapter, "The Virginia Ratification Convention of 1788" (East Carolina University library catalog, https://lib.ecu.edu/catalog-preview/catalog/1272949), has not been consulted, and no page is asserted.

  50. Madison to George Washington, June 25, 1788, Papers of George Washington, Confederation Series, vol. 6, Founders Online, https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Washington/04-06-02-0318: on prior amendments "the votes stood 80 ays—88 noes," and "the ratification passed 89 ays—79 noes." Elliot's Debates, vol. 3, gives the same figures.

  51. Virginia recommended amendments, June 27, 1788, DHRC, vol. 10, 1550–59, as reprinted by CSAC (see the note on the Virginia declaration of rights). The committee's report was made by George Wythe.

  52. CSAC, "New York Ratifies the Constitution, 26 July 1788," https://archive.csac.history.wisc.edu/essay_newyork.pdf: the convention "assembled on 17 June in Poughkeepsie," and "Antifederalists outnumbered Federalists by more than two to one." On Smith's role, DHRC, vol. 18, 294–97, as reprinted by CSAC, https://csac.history.wisc.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/281/2024/04/DC7-02-01-02_N.Y.-Ratifies-the-Constitution_26Jul88.pdf.

  53. CSAC, "New York Ratifies the Constitution."

  54. The Federalist, as printed by the Avalon Project, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/subject_menus/fed.asp, each paper addressed "To the People of the State of New York." On Hamilton's and Jay's part in the Poughkeepsie proceedings, DHRC, vol. 18, 294–97 (see the note on the New York convention), which records Jay moving unconditional ratification and chairing the committee on the circular letter.

  55. DHRC, vol. 18, 294–97: Smith, "Convinced that Congress would never accept ratification with previous amendments," had "abandoned that alternative which he believed would keep New York out of the Union," and Hamilton read the convention a letter from Madison bearing on the question. The letter's contents are not quoted here.

  56. Melancton Smith, speech in the New York convention, July 23, 1788, from the manuscript in the Papers of John Williams, New York State Library, as reprinted by CSAC, https://csac.history.wisc.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/281/2025/11/Melancton-Smith-Speech-23-July-1788.pdf. Spelling and capitalization are the manuscript's.

  57. CSAC, "New York Ratifies the Constitution": Samuel Jones moved "that the words upon condition should be obliterated, and the words in full confidence should be substituted in their stead," and "Jones's motion carried 31 to 29."

  58. CSAC table and chronology, and CSAC New York chronology, https://csac.history.wisc.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/281/2023/12/DC9-11-00-02_N.Y.-Chronology.pdf: "26 July Convention adopts Constitution 30 to 27 with proposed amendments."

  59. Circular letter of the New York convention, July 26, 1788, signed "GEO. CLINTON, President," as printed in the Country Journal (Poughkeepsie), August 5, 1788, DHRC, vol. 18, as reprinted by CSAC, https://archive.csac.history.wisc.edu/circular_letter7.26.pdf. John Jay drafted it (editorial note, Papers of Alexander Hamilton, vol. 5, Founders Online, https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Hamilton/01-05-02-0012-0101).

  60. CSAC table and chronology. The two sources differ by one vote on the North Carolina tally of August 2, 1788: the CSAC table gives 184 to 83, and the North Carolina Department of Natural and Cultural Resources gives 184 to 84 (https://www.dncr.nc.gov/blog/2016/07/21/hillsborough-convention-fails-ratify-constitution). The Rhode Island figures of March 24, 1788, are the votes cast in the town meetings. Vermont, not one of the thirteen, ratified on January 10, 1791.

  61. Madison, "The Bank Bill," speech in the House of Representatives, [February 2,] 1791, Papers of James Madison, vol. 13, Founders Online, https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Madison/01-13-02-0282 (the speech survives in a reporter's third-person summary); Hamilton, "Final Version of an Opinion on the Constitutionality of an Act to Establish a Bank," [February 23,] 1791, Papers of Alexander Hamilton, vol. 8, Founders Online, https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Hamilton/01-08-02-0060-0003; McCulloch v. Maryland, 17 U.S. (4 Wheat.) 316 (1819).

  62. Kevin R. C. Gutzman, "James Madison, Politico," review of Jay Cost, James Madison: America's First Politician, Law & Liberty, January 20, 2022, https://lawliberty.org/book-review/james-madison-politico/. Gutzman names Randolph, George Nicholas, and Madison as the Federalists whose assurances in the Richmond convention set the terms. On the contrary evidence of Virginia's form of ratification and Madison's account of 1789, see the note on Gutzman's reading of the Richmond convention.

  63. Constitution of the United States, amend. XVII, ratified 1913, as transcribed by the National Archives, https://www.archives.gov/founding-docs/amendments-11-27.

  64. Washington announced his retirement in his Farewell Address, dated September 19, 1796. Franklin D. Roosevelt's third term began in January 1941; the Twenty-Second Amendment, ratified in 1951, limited presidents to two elected terms (National Archives, https://www.archives.gov/founding-docs/amendments-11-27).

  65. Michael J. Klarman, "The Founding Revisited," review of Maier, Ratification, Harvard Law Review 125 (2011): 544, https://harvardlawreview.org/wp-content/uploads/2011/12/vol125_klarman.pdf. Klarman's own account of the period is The Framers' Coup: The Making of the United States Constitution (New York: Oxford University Press, 2016), which has not been consulted here. No pages are asserted for the quoted sentences.

  66. Herbert J. Storing, with Murray Dry, What the Anti-Federalists Were For: The Political Thought of the Opponents of the Constitution (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1981), also published as volume 1 of Storing, ed., The Complete Anti-Federalist, 7 vols. (1981). The quoted words are from the University of Chicago Press's description of the book, https://www.chicagoreference.com/ucp/books/book/chicago/W/bo3643133.html, not from Storing's text, which has not been consulted here.

  67. Cornell, The Other Founders, whose chapters include "The Emergence of a Loyal Opposition" and "The Principles of '98" (HSP table of contents); Gutzman, Virginia's American Revolution, introduction, as reprinted by The Imaginative Conservative. Madison drafted the Virginia Resolutions and Jefferson the Kentucky Resolutions; the resolutions themselves belong to a later part of the story than this series covers.

  68. Cecelia M. Kenyon, "Men of Little Faith: The Anti-Federalists on the Nature of Representative Government," William and Mary Quarterly, 3rd ser., 12, no. 1 (January 1955): 3–43, volume, issue, and first page confirmed from the Omohundro Institute's issue listing, https://oieahc.wm.edu/publications/wmq/browse/volume-12-1955/january-1955/. The summary of her argument follows the Online Library of Liberty's bibliographic essay on the Anti-Federalists, https://oll.libertyfund.org/page/anti-federalists-a-bibliography; the article itself has not been consulted here.

  69. Constitution of the United States, art. V, and amends. XIV, XVI, and XVII, as transcribed by the National Archives, https://www.archives.gov/founding-docs/amendments-11-27. "Consent" here means adoption by the procedure Article V prescribes — for these amendments, proposal by two-thirds of each house of Congress and ratification by three-fourths of the states — which is not the same thing as unanimous popular consent. Article V also permits proposal by a convention called on the application of two-thirds of the state legislatures.

  70. On the social pattern, Main, The Antifederalists, as described by the Omohundro Institute (see the note on Main): small and middling farmers against "urban and commercial elites." The pattern is a tendency, not a clean division. Klarman, The Framers' Coup, as described in the Harvard Law School faculty bibliography, https://hls.harvard.edu/bibliography/the-framers-coup-the-making-of-the-united-states-constitution, which calls the Constitution the product not of disinterested reflection "but rather ordinary interest group politics." The book has not been consulted directly. Madison's "Vices of the Political System of the United States" (April 1787) and its complaint of the injustice of state laws are treated in Article 19.

  71. Jon Kukla, "A Time to Listen," Origins: Current Events in Historical Perspective (Ohio State University and Miami University), December 2000, https://origins.osu.edu/index.php/history-news/time-listen, quoting Henry's "closing words to the Virginia convention." The line has not been checked against Robertson's or Elliot's text.

  72. North Carolina ratified on November 21, 1789, after the First Congress had proposed amendments to the states in September 1789. Virginia recommended amendments, June 27, 1788, as reprinted by CSAC; Massachusetts form of ratification, as reprinted by CSAC; Pennsylvania minority's propositions, as above. Which of these amendments the First Congress took up is the subject of Article 21.

  73. Madison to Washington, June 25, 1788, Founders Online, reporting the vote on prior amendments; Elliot, Debates, vol. 3, records the vote by name.

  74. U.S. Census Bureau, "2020 Census Apportionment Results Delivered to the President," April 26, 2021, https://census.gov/newsroom/press-releases/2021/2020-census-apportionment-results.html: "each member will represent an average of 761,169 people based on the 2020 Census."


Sources and Further Reading


Primary Sources

The Address and Reasons of Dissent of the Minority of the Convention of the State of Pennsylvania to their Constituents. Philadelphia, December 1787.

Brutus. Essays I, X, XI, and XV. New York Journal, October 18, 1787–March 20, 1788.

Cato. Letter IV. New York Journal, November 8, 1787.

Centinel. Letter I. Independent Gazetteer (Philadelphia), October 5, 1787.

Constitution of the United States. 1787. National Archives.

Elliot, Jonathan, ed. The Debates in the Several State Conventions on the Adoption of the Federal Constitution. 2nd ed. Vol. 3. Philadelphia, 1836–1845.

The Federal Farmer. Observations Leading to a Fair Examination of the System of Government Proposed by the Late Convention. New York, 1787; and An Additional Number of Letters from the Federal Farmer to the Republican. New York, 1788.

The Federalist. Nos. 45 and 84. New York, 1788.

Hamilton, Alexander. "Opinion on the Constitutionality of an Act to Establish a Bank." February 23, 1791. Founders Online.

Kaminski, John P., et al., eds. The Documentary History of the Ratification of the Constitution. Madison: Wisconsin Historical Society Press; Charlottesville: University of Virginia Press, 1976–. Center for the Study of the American Constitution, University of Wisconsin–Madison.

Kurland, Philip B., and Ralph Lerner, eds. The Founders' Constitution. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1987.

Madison, James. "The Bank Bill." February 2, 1791. Founders Online.

Madison, James. Letter to George Washington, June 25, 1788. Founders Online.

Mason, George. "Objections to The Constitution of Government formed by the Convention." 1787. American Revolution Institute of the Society of the Cincinnati.

Mason, George. Letters to George Washington, October 7, 1787, and to Thomas Jefferson, May 26, 1788.

Massachusetts Convention. Form of Ratification. February 6, 1788.

New York Convention. Circular Letter to the States. July 26, 1788.

Smith, Melancton. Speech in the New York Convention, July 23, 1788. Papers of John Williams, New York State Library.

Storing, Herbert J., ed. The Complete Anti-Federalist. 7 vols. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1981.

Virginia Convention. Recommended Amendments. June 27, 1788.

Virginia Declaration of Rights. June 12, 1776. National Archives.

Wilson, James. Speech in the State House Yard, Philadelphia, October 6, 1787.

Secondary Works

Center for the Study of the American Constitution. "Federalist and Antifederalist: The Origin of the Terms." University of Wisconsin–Madison.

Center for the Study of the American Constitution. "Identifying the Federal Farmer: Unravelling the Mystery of an Antifederalist Treasure." April 1, 2025.

Cornell, Saul. The Other Founders: Anti-Federalism and the Dissenting Tradition in America, 1788–1828. Chapel Hill: Omohundro Institute of Early American History and Culture and University of North Carolina Press, 1999.

Gutzman, Kevin R. C. Virginia's American Revolution: From Dominion to Republic, 1776–1840. Lanham, Md.: Lexington Books, 2007.

Gutzman, Kevin R. C. "The Virginians." Law & Liberty, May 3, 2012.

Gutzman, Kevin R. C. "James Madison, Politico." Law & Liberty, January 20, 2022.

Johnson, Joel A. "'Brutus' and 'Cato' Unmasked: General John Williams's Role in the New York Ratification Debate, 1787–88." Proceedings of the American Antiquarian Society 118, pt. 2 (2008): 297–337.

Kenyon, Cecelia M. "Men of Little Faith: The Anti-Federalists on the Nature of Representative Government." William and Mary Quarterly, 3rd ser., 12, no. 1 (1955): 3–43.

Klarman, Michael J. "The Founding Revisited." Harvard Law Review 125 (2011): 544.

Klarman, Michael J. The Framers' Coup: The Making of the United States Constitution. New York: Oxford University Press, 2016.

Kukla, Jon. "A Time to Listen." Origins: Current Events in Historical Perspective, December 2000.

Maier, Pauline. Ratification: The People Debate the Constitution, 1787–1788. New York: Simon & Schuster, 2010.

Main, Jackson Turner. The Antifederalists: Critics of the Constitution, 1781–1788. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 1961.

Rakove, Jack. Review of Pauline Maier, Ratification. Harvard Magazine, December 16, 2010.

Storing, Herbert J., with Murray Dry. What the Anti-Federalists Were For: The Political Thought of the Opponents of the Constitution. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1981.

Webking, Robert H. "Melancton Smith and the Letters from the Federal Farmer." William and Mary Quarterly, 3rd ser., 44, no. 3 (1987): 510–28.

Wood, Gordon S. "The Authorship of the Letters from the Federal Farmer." William and Mary Quarterly, 3rd ser., 31, no. 2 (1974): 299 ff.


Next: Article 21 — "The Bill of Rights"

Comments


bottom of page