"The Bill of Rights" — Articles in Addition to the Constitution, 1789–1791
SELF-EVIDENT The Road to 1776 Article 21 of 22
Let me add that a bill of rights is what the people are entitled to against every government on earth, general or particular, and what no just government should refuse, or rest on inference. — Thomas Jefferson to James Madison, December 20, 1787¹
One Word
On Tuesday, August 18, 1789, the House of Representatives, sitting as a committee of the whole in Federal Hall in New York, reached the reserved-powers clause, near the end of the amendments it had been debating for most of a week. The clause said that the powers not delegated by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the states, were reserved to the states. Thomas Tucker of South Carolina moved to add one word. The powers reserved, under his motion, would be the powers not expressly delegated.
The word had a history. Massachusetts had put it in the first of its recommended amendments in February 1788. New Hampshire had strengthened it to "expressly and particularly." The old Articles of Confederation had used it, and the Constitution's critics had spent a year arguing that a government left to read its own powers by implication would read them generously. Tucker was asking the House to settle the question in a single adverb.
James Madison answered him. The reporter took down the reply in the third person: Madison "objected to this amendment, because it was impossible to confine a Government to the exercise of express powers; there must necessarily be admitted powers by implication, unless the Constitution descended to recount every minutia." He added that the word "had been moved in the convention of Virginia, by the opponents to the ratification, and, after full and fair discussion, was given up by them."² Tucker's motion failed. Three days later Elbridge Gerry of Massachusetts moved the same word again, on a recorded vote, and the House rejected it 17 to 32.³
The man who rose against Tucker was the same man who had brought the amendments before the House in the first place, despite the reluctance of many members, and who would carry them through a summer when many members wanted to talk about revenue. He was willing to write down the people's rights. He was not willing to write down that word. What Congress added to the Constitution in 1789, and what it declined to add, followed the line Madison drew that day.
Provided It Be So Framed
A year earlier Madison had been on the other side of the amendment question. In Richmond, in June 1788, he had voted with the majority that refused to make ratification wait on amendments, and our article last week left him there.
His private position was more complicated than his votes. On October 17, 1788, he wrote to Thomas Jefferson, then the American minister in Paris, who had been pressing him on the point since December 1787. "My own opinion has always been in favor of a bill of rights," Madison wrote, "provided it be so framed as not to imply powers not meant to be included in the enumeration." But he said that he had "not viewed it in an important light," and he gave four reasons. The federal government's powers were limited, so that rights were reserved in some degree by the manner of the grant. A written declaration of the most essential rights might fall short of the rights themselves. The limited powers of the federal government and the jealousy of the states gave a security of their own. And "experience proves the inefficacy of a bill of rights on those occasions when its controul is most needed."⁴
The fourth reason was the one he believed most. State-level protections of rights already existed, and "Repeated violations of these parchment barriers have been committed by overbearing majorities in every State." The danger, in his view, did not come from where the critics were looking for it. "Wherever the real power in a Government lies, there is the danger of oppression," he wrote. "In our Governments the real power lies in the majority of the Community, and the invasion of private rights is cheifly to be apprehended, not from acts of Government contrary to the sense of its constituents, but from acts in which the Government is the mere instrument of the major number of the constituents."⁵ A list of rights would not stop a majority that wanted to violate them.
Jefferson answered from Paris the following March with an argument Madison had not made. "In the arguments in favor of a declaration of rights, you omit one which has great weight with me, the legal check which it puts into the hands of the judiciary."⁶ A right written into the Constitution was a right a court could enforce.
Meanwhile the argument had stopped being theoretical. Virginia's legislature, led by Patrick Henry, had chosen Richard Henry Lee and William Grayson, two of the Constitution's opponents, as the state's first senators, and Madison had finished third. The legislature then drew the congressional districts, and it placed Madison's home county of Orange in a district the editors of his papers describe as "heavily tainted with Antifederalism." His opponent there was James Monroe.⁷
Madison went home to campaign, and he changed what he said in public about amendments. To George Eve, a Baptist minister in the district, he wrote on January 2, 1789, that he had "opposed all previous alterations as calculated to throw the States into dangerous contentions." But the Constitution had now been ratified. "Under this change of circumstances, it is my sincere opinion that the Constitution ought to be revised, and that the first Congress meeting under it, ought to prepare and recommend to the States for ratification, the most satisfactory provisions for all essential rights, particularly the rights of Conscience in the fullest latitude."⁸ On February 2, 1789, the voters of eight counties chose Madison over Monroe by 336 votes out of 2,280 cast.⁹
There was a second pressure, and it was larger than one district. New York's convention had called for a second general convention to revise the Constitution. The Center for the Study of the American Constitution, which edits the documentary history of ratification, describes Madison's fear that such a convention "would use many of the proposed amendments made by state ratification conventions as the basis for an entirely new constitution," and calls that concern "paramount in Madison's evolution in thinking on the necessity of amendments."¹⁰ If the new Congress proposed amendments of its own, it could choose which ones. If it did nothing, the choice might pass to a body that could reopen everything.
A Vessel Just Launched
The First Congress met in New York in the spring of 1789, and it had a government to build. It had to raise a revenue, organize the executive departments, and create the federal courts. When Madison rose on June 8 to move that the House take up amendments, the members who answered him were not hostile to rights. They were busy.

James Jackson of Georgia was blunt. "Our Constitution, sir, is like a vessel just launched, and lying at the wharf; she is untried," he said, and "In short, Mr. Speaker, I am not for amendments at this time." Benjamin Goodhue of Massachusetts thought "the present time premature; inasmuch as we have other business before us, which is incomplete." Roger Sherman of Connecticut, who had told the Philadelphia Convention that the state declarations were sufficient, was not persuaded that any change proposed now "would be an amendment, in the true sense of the word."¹¹ Madison answered that he hoped the House would not decline to go into committee, and then he gave his speech anyway.
He told the House why he was moving now. He wanted those who had supported the Constitution to have "the opportunity of proving to those who were opposed to it, that they were as sincerely devoted to liberty and a republican government" as their accusers. He was not speaking to the opposition's leaders. "I believe that the great mass of the people who opposed it, disliked it because it did not contain effectual provision against encroachments on particular rights, and those safeguards which they have been long accustomed to have interposed between them and the magistrate who exercised the sovereign power."¹²
Then he read his proposals, and their form mattered as much as their content. Madison did not want a list appended to the end of the Constitution. He wanted the amendments written into the text. The first would be "prefixed to the constitution," a declaration "That all power is originally vested in, and consequently derived from the people." Most of the rest would go into Article I, section 9 — the list of things Congress may not do — "between clauses 3 and 4," beside the bans on bills of attainder and ex post facto laws.¹³ The freedoms of conscience, speech, the press, assembly and petition, the right to keep and bear arms, the rules against quartering soldiers and unreasonable searches, the protections of the accused, the bar on excessive bail, all were to sit inside the Constitution's existing catalogue of limits on the legislature.
He took up the objection Hamilton had pressed. "It has been objected also against a bill of rights, that, by enumerating particular exceptions to the grant of power, it would disparage those rights which were not placed in that enumeration," he said, and called it "one of the most plausible arguments I have ever heard urged against the admission of a bill of rights into this system." His answer was a rule of construction, placed at the end of the same section: "The exceptions here or elsewhere in the constitution, made in favor of particular rights, shall not be so construed as to diminish the just importance of other rights retained by the people; or as to enlarge the powers delegated by the constitution; but either as actual limitations of such powers, or as inserted merely for greater caution."¹⁴ It said two things. Rights not listed were not surrendered, and the listing of rights did not imply new powers. The first half became the Ninth Amendment. The second half did not survive.
He proposed a reserved-powers clause as well: "The powers not delegated by this constitution, nor prohibited by it to the states, are reserved to the States respectively." The word "expressly" was not in it.¹⁵ And he proposed a clause that ran the other way from the conventions' lists, to be inserted among the limits on the states in Article I, section 10, forbidding any state to violate the equal rights of conscience, the freedom of the press, or trial by jury in criminal cases.¹⁶
He did not claim that any of it would be enough. He granted the skeptics their point before they made it: "It may be thought all paper barriers against the power of the community, are too weak to be worthy of attention." His reply was modest. Such declarations "have a tendency to impress some degree of respect for them, to establish the public opinion in their favor, and rouse the attention of the whole community." And he took up Jefferson's argument as his own. "If they are incorporated into the constitution, independent tribunals of justice will consider themselves in a peculiar manner the guardians of those rights; they will be an impenetrable bulwark against every assumption of power in the legislative or executive."¹⁷
Not everyone was impressed. Fisher Ames of Massachusetts wrote to a friend three days later that Madison "has hunted up all the grievances and complaints of newspapers—all the articles of Conventions—and the small talk of their debates." Upon the whole, Ames thought, "it may do good towards quieting men who attend to sounds only, and may get the mover some popularity—which he wishes."¹⁸
A Supplement, Not a Revision
The House put the subject off for six weeks. On July 21 it voted, 34 to 15, to send Madison's proposals and the amendments of the state conventions to a select committee of one member from each state, and John Vining of Delaware reported for the committee a week later.¹⁹
Among the committee's papers is a draft in Sherman's hand, though he had thought a bill of rights unnecessary in 1787. It opened with the people's power over their government: "The powers of government being derived from the people, ought to be exercised for their benefit," and the people "have an inherent and unalienable right, to change or amend their political constitution." Its second article stated a theory of rights in a sentence. "The people have certain natural rights which are retained by them when they enter into society," and "Of these rights therefore they Shall not be deprived by the government of the united States."²⁰ Rights were not grants from the government. They were what people kept when they formed one. That is the language of the social compact as Locke had framed it a century earlier, and it was by now the common speech of American constitutions. The committee did not report Sherman's draft, and the House later rejected the prefatory declaration of popular sovereignty Madison had proposed. But the idea of rights "retained" by the people outlived both drafts. It is the word the Ninth Amendment uses.
The enumeration in the Constitution, of certain rights, shall not be construed to deny or disparage others retained by the people. — Ninth Amendment
The full House took up the report on August 13, and the first fight was over form.
Sherman moved that the amendments be added at the end of the Constitution rather than woven into it. "We ought not to interweave our propositions into the work itself, because it will be destructive of the whole fabric," he said. "The Constitution is the act of the people, and ought to remain entire." Madison replied that "Form, sir, is always of less importance than the substance," and that there was "a neatness and propriety in incorporating the amendments into the Constitution itself." The House rejected Sherman's motion on August 13. On August 19 he moved it again, and it carried by two-thirds of the House.²¹ The amendments would be a supplement. The original text would stand as the convention had written it and the states had ratified it, and the changes would follow it, each one dated and separate. Madison lost the argument over form, and the result is the shape the Constitution still has.
The substance moved in the same week. The religion clause went through several drafts. The select committee had reported that "no religion shall be established by law, nor shall the equal rights of conscience be infringed." Members worried aloud that the words might be read as hostile to religion itself. Samuel Livermore of New Hampshire offered "that Congress shall make no laws touching religion, or infringing the rights of conscience," which passed 31 to 20, and Fisher Ames reworded it again on August 20.²² The militia clause carried a proviso that "no person religiously scrupulous shall be compelled to bear arms." Egbert Benson of New York moved to strike it. "It may be a religious persuasion, but it is no natural right," he said, and the matter should be left "to the benevolence of the Legislature." His motion failed, 22 to 24, and the proviso went to the Senate, which removed it.²³
By the middle of August the House had been at it for a week and Madison was tired of it. On August 19 he sent Richard Peters of Pennsylvania the latest papers with a note: "The papers inclosed will shew that the nauseous project of amendments has not yet been either dismissed or despatched." And then: "We are so deep in them now, that right or wrong some thing must be done."²⁴
What the States Did Not Get
The state conventions had asked for a great deal. The documentary history of ratification counts 292 amendments proposed during the contest, or 102 once the duplicates are removed.²⁵ Starting with Virginia, the conventions divided their proposals into two lists. One was a declaration of rights. The other asked for changes to the government itself — to its powers to tax, to keep an army, to regulate trade, and to reach into the states through its courts. The House took up both lists in August 1789. It adopted much of the first and almost none of the second.
The Right to Instruct
On August 15 Tucker moved to add to the assembly clause a right of the people "to instruct their Representatives." Several state constitutions recognized it, and Virginia's 1788 declaration put assembly and instruction in the same sentence. The objection was that a representative bound by instructions was no longer a deliberator. "If they were to be guided by instructions, there would be no use in deliberation," Sherman said. The motion failed on a standing count, 10 to 41.²⁶
Aedanus Burke of South Carolina used the same debate to say what he thought of the whole enterprise. The amendments before the House, he said, were "little better than whip-syllabub, frothy and full of wind, formed only to please the palate; or they are like a tub thrown out to a whale, to secure the freight of the ship." Sailors threw an empty barrel to a whale to distract it from the vessel. Burke's charge was that the rights were the barrel, and the structural amendments were the freight.²⁷
Express Powers
Of all the structural demands, a reserved-powers clause was the most widely shared. All nine sets of proposals — those of seven state conventions, the Pennsylvania minority, and the Maryland committee — included a reserved-powers clause, and Massachusetts, New Hampshire, South Carolina, the Maryland committee and the Pennsylvania minority had all put the word "expressly" into it.²⁸ Virginia had not. Its first structural amendment reserved to each state every power "which is not by this Constitution delegated," and New York's said "clearly delegated." That was the record Madison cited when he told the House the word had been given up in Richmond.
The Tenth Amendment as finally written kept the shape of Madison's clause, specified powers "delegated to the United States," and added at the end the words "or to the people." It reserves the powers not delegated. It does not say how much was delegated, and it leaves the question of implied powers exactly where Madison wanted it left.
The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people. — Tenth Amendment
Direct Taxes
On August 22 Tucker tried a major structural amendment. His motion opened, "The Congress shall never impose direct taxes," and allowed them only where the duties and excises fell short of the public needs, "nor then until Congress shall have made a requisition upon the States." Massachusetts had asked that Congress requisition the states before laying any direct tax, as had South Carolina, New Hampshire and New York, and Rhode Island did later; Virginia had asked that a state be allowed to raise its own quota and keep the federal collectors out. Tucker's motion failed on a recorded vote, 9 to 39.²⁹
Armies, Trade and the Courts
Virginia had asked that "no standing army or regular troops shall be raised or kept up in time of peace, without the consent of two thirds of the members present in both houses," that navigation and commercial laws require two-thirds of both houses, and that the judicial power be redefined. New York had asked for two-thirds to borrow money and to declare war. Neither the two-thirds rules nor the limits on the federal courts appear among the articles Congress sent to the states.³⁰
What the Senate Took Out
The House sent seventeen articles to the Senate on August 24, and the Senate struck two of them outright. One was a separation-of-powers article, providing that no branch should exercise the powers vested in another. The other was the article that had grown out of Madison's proposal to restrain the states: "No State shall infringe the right of trial by Jury in criminal cases, nor the rights of conscience, nor the freedom of speech, or of the press." Madison had told the House on August 17 that he "conceived this to be the most valuable amendment in the whole list." The Senate struck it.³¹
Two Readings
The Virginia senators wrote home in despair. "As they came from the H. of R. they were very far short of the wishes of our Convention," Lee wrote to Patrick Henry on September 14, "but as they are returned by the Senate they are certainly much weakened." He thought the idea of amendments after ratification had been "delusion altogether," and he complained that "too many look at the Rights of the people as a Miser examines a Security to find a flaw in it!" The rights that survived would not help much: "Some valuable Rights are indeed declared, but the powers that remain are very sufficient to render them nugatory at pleasure."³² Grayson was harsher. The amendments, he wrote to Henry two weeks later, "are so mutilated & gutted that in fact they are good for nothing," and "The Virginia amendments were all brought into view, and regularly rejected."³³
The Center for the Study of the American Constitution puts it in a sentence: Madison "essentially ignored the structural amendments that had been proposed by many of the state conventions."³⁴ He did not ignore them by accident. He had told the House on June 8 whom he was trying to reach, and it was not Lee and Grayson. It was the great mass of people who had opposed the Constitution for want of protections they were accustomed to. On Madison's reading of June 8, the rights were what most of those people wanted, and the structural changes were what their leaders wanted. The Anti-Federalist reply was that the structural changes were what would have made the rights safe.
Seventeen Articles, Then Twelve
The Senate began on the House's articles on September 2. Its journal records motions and votes rather than speeches. It rewrote the religion clause twice, once on September 3 and again on September 9, when it adopted "Congress shall make no law establishing articles of faith, or a mode of worship, or prohibiting the free exercise of religion."³⁵ It merged articles, struck the two described above, removed the conscientious objectors' proviso from the militia clause, and restored to the reserved-powers article the words "or to the people," which had been agreed in the House debate and then dropped from the House's final text. By September 9 the seventeen were twelve.³⁶
A conference committee — Madison, Sherman and Vining for the House; Oliver Ellsworth, Charles Carroll and William Paterson for the Senate — settled the remaining differences. It produced the religion clause the country knows: "Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof."³⁷ The House agreed to the conference terms on September 24, and Congress completed its agreement on September 25, 1789.³⁸ On October 2 President Washington sent copies to the governors under a cover letter of a single sentence, transmitting "a copy of the amendments proposed to be added to the Constitution of the United States."³⁹
The resolution Congress sent out explained itself in a preamble. "The Conventions of a number of the States," it began, "having at the time of their adopting the Constitution, expressed a desire, in order to prevent misconstruction or abuse of its powers, that further declaratory and restrictive clauses should be added." It called what followed "ARTICLES in addition to, and Amendment of the Constitution of the United States of America." The resolution did not formally title them a bill of rights. Madison had described the first of his June 8 proposals as relating to "what may be called a bill of rights." Gerard Magliocca has argued that identifying the first ten amendments as the Bill of Rights did not become dominant until the twentieth century.⁴⁰
There were twelve articles. The first would have fixed the size of the House as the population grew. The second provided that no change in congressional pay would take effect until an election had intervened. The third began "Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion."⁴¹
No law, varying the compensation for the services of the Senators and Representatives, shall take effect, until an election of Representatives shall have intervened. — Twenty-Seventh Amendment (ratified May 7, 1992)
Where the Words Came From
The ideas in these amendments are old, and earlier articles in this series followed them: conscience from Luther at Worms, the law of the land from Runnymede, the security of a man's house from Coke's law reports and the Boston writs. The words themselves had a nearer and better-documented route. Most of them came through Virginia.
The clearest case is the Eighth Amendment. The English Bill of Rights of 1689 declared "That excessive bail ought not to be required, nor excessive fines imposed; nor cruel and unusual punishments inflicted." George Mason's Virginia Declaration of Rights of 1776 repeated it with only a change of punctuation. Virginia's convention put it in its 1788 declaration, North Carolina copied Virginia, and Madison and the House carried it into the final text with one change of substance: "ought" became "shall." Across a hundred years and an ocean, a declaration of what ought not to be done became a command.⁴²
The Fourth Amendment follows the same road, but with more change along the way. Mason's Declaration condemned general warrants that let an officer search suspected places "without evidence of a fact committed," and called them "grievous and oppressive." Virginia's 1788 declaration kept that language and added that "every freeman has a right to be secure from all unreasonable searches and siezures of his person, his papers and his property," and that warrants must issue on oath "of legal and sufficient cause." The final text kept the security of persons, houses and papers, the unreasonable searches and seizures, the oath or affirmation, and the description of the place to be searched. The phrase "probable cause" is not in Virginia's text.⁴³
The Sixth Amendment's list of the rights of the accused runs from Mason's eighth section through Virginia's 1788 declaration to the final text, with the same phrases at every stage — criminal prosecutions, the "cause and nature" of the accusation (the final text turned the pair around), confrontation with the witnesses, a speedy trial, an impartial jury. Virginia's 1788 version added the right to counsel. The First Amendment's "free exercise" comes from Mason's sixteenth section through Virginia's twentieth article, and its "peaceably to assemble" and "redress of grievances" from Virginia's fifteenth. The Second Amendment's "well regulated Militia" and "free State" are Mason's; the right of the people to keep and bear arms is in Virginia's 1788 declaration, and New York's.⁴⁴
The Fifth Amendment is where the route through Virginia gives out. Virginia's 1788 declaration, like Mason's, said no man could be deprived of his life, liberty or property "but by the law of the land" — the phrase of Magna Carta's thirty-ninth chapter, "per legem terrae."⁴⁵ The words "due process of law" came from New York, the only state that used them, and Madison took them into his June 8 draft. The protection against being "twice put in jeopardy of life or limb" and much of the grand jury clause came from New York as well; Massachusetts supplied "infamous" crimes and the exception for the land and naval forces. And the last clause of the Fifth Amendment, "nor shall private property be taken for public use, without just compensation," came from no state at all. No convention proposed it. Madison's June 8 draft provided that no person should "be obliged to relinquish his property, where it may be necessary for public use, without a just compensation."⁴⁶
The Ninth Amendment came from the states by a turn. Virginia and New York had each asked that the clauses forbidding Congress certain powers not be read to imply any other powers, but "construed either as making exceptions to the specified powers," in Virginia's words, "or otherwise as inserted merely for greater caution." Those state proposals were about powers. Madison's June 8 draft kept their language — "inserted merely for greater caution" — and added the people's other rights. The final text kept only the rights: "The enumeration in the Constitution, of certain rights, shall not be construed to deny or disparage others retained by the people."⁴⁷
Much of this language arrived in 1789 through Mason's draft of 1776 and Virginia's convention of 1788, with other state proposals and the House drafts supplying the rest.
Three-Fourths of the States
New Jersey ratified first, on November 20, 1789, accepting every article except the second. Maryland, North Carolina, South Carolina, New Hampshire, Delaware, New York, Pennsylvania and Rhode Island followed over the next seven months.⁴⁸ North Carolina had ratified the Constitution itself on November 21, 1789, by 194 to 77, and it approved the amendments within a month. Rhode Island ratified the Constitution on May 29, 1790, by 34 to 32, eleven days after the Senate passed a bill to cut off commerce with it.⁴⁹
Virginia's House of Delegates approved the articles in November 1789. Its Senate would not. On December 8 it postponed the third, eighth, eleventh and twelfth articles — the ones that became the First, Sixth, Ninth and Tenth Amendments — and on December 12 eight senators entered their reasons in the journal. The third article, they wrote, "does not prohibit the rights of conscience from being violated or infringed," and Congress might still "levy taxes to any amount, for the support of religion or its preachers." It did not "declare and assert the right of the people to speak and publish their sentiments." Taken together the amendments were "far short of what the people of Virginia wish, and have asked," and "we think our countrymen ought not to be put off with amendments so inadequate."⁵⁰ Edmund Randolph, reporting to Washington, wrote that "the responsibility for this conduct will, I hope, be thrown upon the senate."⁵¹
Virginia waited two years. Vermont's admission to the Union on March 4, 1791, raised the number of states to fourteen and the number needed to eleven, and Vermont ratified all twelve articles on November 3, 1791. On December 15, 1791, the Virginia Senate agreed to the remaining articles, and with Virginia's assent the third through the twelfth became part of the Constitution.⁵² The state whose convention had proposed forty amendments, and whose senate had objected that Congress's were too weak, was the state that completed them.
Massachusetts and Connecticut considered the amendments in the founding years but never completed ratification; Georgia postponed consideration. All three formally ratified the ten amendments in 1939, at the sesquicentennial, as a commemoration. Georgia's legislature in 1789 had postponed the question on the ground that defects in the Constitution "cannot be effectually pointed out, but by experience."⁵³ The first article, on the size of the House, fell one state short and was never ratified. The second, on congressional pay, lay before the states for two centuries and was completed on May 7, 1992, as the Twenty-Seventh Amendment.⁵⁴
Protection or Parchment
Madison had made two predictions about the amendments, and they pulled against each other. One was that written rights would be weak against a determined majority — "paper barriers," "parchment barriers." The other was that courts would make them strong, "an impenetrable bulwark against every assumption of power in the legislative or executive." Lee had made a third: that the powers left standing were "very sufficient to render them nugatory at pleasure."
The two bets were linked. Jefferson had told Madison that a declaration of rights put a legal check "into the hands of the judiciary," and Madison had repeated the argument on June 8: written rights would give judges something to defend. The Anti-Federalists had feared the same judges. Brutus, as Article 20 traced, warned that federal courts holding office for good behavior would answer to no one and would extend the general government's power by degrees. The amendments of 1789 put the people's rights in the keeping of an institution the opposition had distrusted. Whether that was a protection or a risk depended on what the courts would do with them, and the founders could not know.
For a long time the amendments were not tested against the governments Madison most feared. They bound Congress. In 1833 Chief Justice John Marshall, writing for the Court in Barron v. Baltimore, held that the Constitution's amendments "demanded security against the apprehended encroachments of the general government—not against those of the local governments," and that the Fifth Amendment's takings clause was "intended solely as a limitation on the exercise of power by the government of the United States."⁵⁵ Madison's state-restraint article, the one the Senate struck, would have reached further. It took the Fourteenth Amendment, ratified in 1868, and a long line of later decisions — beginning with the takings clause in 1897 and accelerating in the 1920s — to apply most of the Bill of Rights to the states.⁵⁶
A libertarian reading of 1789 sees a trade the opposition lost. Congress wrote down the people's rights, while declining to write down many of the structural limits on federal power that the opposition had sought — express delegation, requisitions before direct taxes, two-thirds for a peacetime army — limits that would have made many of those rights less necessary. On that reading the Bill of Rights is real protection, but it protects at the point where federal power is used, after the limits that would have kept the power from arising were declined. Others answer that the written rights did what Madison hoped. They gave courts something to enforce and citizens something to invoke, and many of the structural proposals would have returned the Union to the weakness of the Confederation. Over the course of this series, as a point of personal privilege, I have said that on consolidation I tend to side with the Anti-Federalist case, that I have gone back and forth on the incorporation of the Bill of Rights against the states, and that some basic civil liberties fall under the purview of every government, state and federal alike.⁵⁷ The settlement of 1789 holds the same tension.

The Skeptic's Case
That Madison Was Keeping a Campaign Promise
The plainest account of 1789 is that Madison promised amendments to win a close race against Monroe, and kept the promise. Leonard Levy argued something like this, in Teaching American History's summary of his view: "Madison was simply delivering on his electoral promise as a practical politician." Paul Finkelman, as a later scholar characterizes his argument, held that Madison's arguments in Congress "emphasized expedience," and that he remained ambivalent about the theoretical value of a federal bill of rights.⁵⁸ Madison's own words give the account real support. He called the work a "nauseous project." He told the House he was moving to win over the opposition's followers. And the Wisconsin editors call his fear of a second convention "paramount in Madison's evolution in thinking on the necessity of amendments."⁵⁹
The reply is in the dates. Madison's letter to Jefferson stating that his opinion "has always been in favor of a bill of rights" on a condition was written in October 1788, before his campaign against Monroe and before the letter to Eve. And the June 8 speech asked for more than the opposition did: a rule that the enumeration of rights should not be construed to enlarge the powers delegated by the Constitution, a takings clause no state convention had proposed, and a restraint on the states that did not appear among the conventions' proposals. Stuart Leibiger has argued that Madison's advocacy "reflected a slow but genuine conversion to the cause of a national guarantee of basic liberty," and Gordon Wood, reviewing Richard Labunski's history of the struggle, judged that Madison's change "was not simply a matter of political expediency."⁶⁰ The evidence supports both readings, and it does not require a choice between them. Madison was a politician under pressure, and he had been thinking about rights and majorities for years.
That the Amendments Were a Tub to the Whale
Burke's charge was that the rights were a decoy, and the record gives it force. The amendments helped undercut the pressure for a second convention, and the structural demands the conventions had pressed were set aside; the few that reached a vote lost. Lee thought the whole idea of subsequent amendments had been "delusion altogether."
But the rights were not a decoy to the people who had asked for them. Of the nine sets of proposals, civil jury trial appeared in eight and religious freedom in seven.⁶¹ Those were what the conventions had asked for most consistently, and Congress gave them. The structural amendments were more various, and their supporters disagreed among themselves about them. Massachusetts wanted requisitions first and Virginia wanted states to raise their own quotas; Virginia wanted two-thirds for an army and New Hampshire three-fourths. A tub thrown to a whale is worthless. These rights were not, and the Virginia senators who called them inadequate were not saying that they wanted none.
That Hamilton Was Right
Hamilton had warned that a list of rights would imply powers not granted. Madison's proposed rule of construction answered that objection, and the Tenth Amendment restated the principle Wilson had promised. But the answer that was ratified was not quite the answer Madison drafted. His June 8 clause did two things: it said the listing of rights should not "diminish the just importance of other rights retained by the people," and it said the listing should not be read "as to enlarge the powers delegated by the constitution." The second half met Hamilton's danger directly, with a rule that the listing of a right could not be read to enlarge a power. It did not survive the select committee. The Ninth Amendment protects the rights not listed. It says nothing about the powers. Whether the answer worked depends on whether courts and Congresses have treated the rights not listed as retained and the powers not delegated as withheld, and that belongs to the history after 1791.
Articles in Addition
The Constitution of 1787 had been drafted in secret and ratified in an argument. The amendments of 1789 were argued out in an open House that mostly wanted to talk about other things, by a man who had doubted they would do much good, and they were ratified slowly by states that thought they did too little. The ten that were ratified added no power to the government. They wrote down what the government could not do, many of them in words carried from Westminster to Williamsburg to Richmond to New York.
What they did not write down was the rest of what the conventions had asked. The word "expressly" was moved twice and failed twice. The requisition requirement was voted down 9 to 39. The second convention never met. The opposition had kept the argument going after it lost the vote, and it got the rights it had asked for most consistently and very little of the structure it had asked for.
By December 1791 the inheritance this series has followed — conscience, the law of the land, the security of a man's house, the jury, the people's retained rights — had been written into the fundamental law of a republic, with a rule that the list was not complete. Whether the people who received it would keep it was a different question from whether the founders had written it well. That question passed to everyone who came after.
Self-Reflection Prompts
Madison wrote in 1788 that written rights had been violated "by overbearing majorities in every State," and in 1789 he proposed them anyway. Is a right that a majority can ignore still worth writing down, and what does writing it down accomplish?
Sherman insisted that the amendments be added at the end so that the Constitution, "the act of the people," would "remain entire." Madison wanted them woven into the text. Which form better tells a reader what the Constitution means?
The House rejected "expressly" 17 to 32 and Tucker's limit on direct taxes 9 to 39. If those amendments had passed, which later expansions of federal power would they have stopped, and which would they have left untouched?
The Virginia Senate called the amendments "so inadequate" in 1789 and then completed them in 1791. Was it right to hold out, and was it right to give in?
The Liberty Test. The Ninth Amendment says that the listing of certain rights "shall not be construed to deny or disparage others retained by the people." If no individual may claim authority over another that the other never surrendered, does a government that recognizes only the rights written down leave Americans more free or more governed?
Endnotes
Thomas Jefferson to James Madison, Paris, December 20, 1787, Papers of Thomas Jefferson, vol. 12, Founders Online, National Archives, https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Jefferson/01-12-02-0454; also printed in Papers of James Madison, vol. 10, https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Madison/01-10-02-0210. The letter survives as a recipient's copy and a file copy, and Jefferson sent an extract with numerous changes to Uriah Forrest on December 31, 1787 (editorial note, Madison Papers). The text quoted is the Founders Online text of the Jefferson Papers.
Annals of Congress 1:761 (August 18, 1789), as reprinted in The Founders' Constitution, ed. Philip B. Kurland and Ralph Lerner (University of Chicago Press), Amendment X, document 6, https://press-pubs.uchicago.edu/founders/documents/amendXs6.html. The reporter's text is in the third person. Tucker's motion would have read "the powers not expressly delegated by this Constitution." On the Massachusetts and New Hampshire wording, see the note on the reserved-powers proposals below. The Articles of Confederation, art. II, reserved to each state every power "which is not by this confederation expressly delegated to the United States, in Congress assembled" (Avalon Project, Yale Law School, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_Century/artconf.asp).
Annals 1:767–68 (August 21, 1789), as reprinted in The Founders' Constitution, Amendment X, document 6. Madison and Sherman voted with the majority.
Madison to Jefferson, New York, October 17, 1788, Papers of James Madison, vol. 11, Founders Online, https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Madison/01-11-02-0218. The first three reasons are paraphrased; the fourth is quoted. "Controul" is Madison's spelling.
Madison to Jefferson, October 17, 1788, as in the note on his four reasons. "Cheifly" is Madison's spelling. Madison had used "parchment barriers" in The Federalist No. 48.
Jefferson to Madison, Paris, March 15, 1789, Papers of Thomas Jefferson, vol. 14, 659–61, as reprinted in The Founders' Constitution, vol. 1, ch. 14, document 49, https://press-pubs.uchicago.edu/founders/documents/v1ch14s49.html.
Editorial note, "Madison's Election to the First Federal Congress, October 1788–February 1789," Papers of James Madison, vol. 11, Founders Online, https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Madison/01-11-02-0219. The editors describe the placement of Orange County as an early example of gerrymandering and note that a one-year residency requirement may have been meant to keep Madison from running in a friendlier district. The legislature's choice of Lee and Grayson, with Madison third, is from the same note, which gives no vote totals for it. The district comprised Orange, Amherst, Albemarle, Fluvanna, Louisa, Goochland, Culpeper, and Spotsylvania counties.
Madison to George Eve, January 2, 1789, Papers of James Madison, vol. 11, Founders Online, https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Madison/01-11-02-0297. The editorial note records that Eve "was ordained a Baptist minister in 1778." The sentence continues with the freedom of the press, trials by jury, and security against general warrants.
Editorial note, "Madison's Election to the First Federal Congress," as in the note on the legislature's choice of senators: Madison won by 336 votes of 2,280 cast in the eight counties. The commonly cited totals of 1,308 to 972 are consistent with those figures; they are not given in the note.
Center for the Study of the American Constitution, University of Wisconsin–Madison, "The Role of James Madison in the Creation of the Bill of Rights," https://csac.history.wisc.edu/the-role-of-james-madison-in-the-creation-of-the-bill-of-rights/ (no author named). New York's call for a second convention, in its circular letter of July 26, 1788, is treated in Article 20.
Annals of Congress 1 (June 8, 1789), as reprinted in The Founders' Constitution, Bill of Rights, document 11, https://press-pubs.uchicago.edu/founders/documents/bill_of_rightss11.html. Sherman's remark in the Convention on September 12, 1787, is treated in Article 19. A different report of the day, quoted in National Archives teaching materials, renders Jackson's view as "This is not the time for bringing forward amendments" (https://www.archives.gov/legislative/resources/bill-of-rights/CCBR_IIA.pdf).
Madison, speech in the House of Representatives, June 8, 1789, "Amendments to the Constitution, [8 June] 1789," Papers of James Madison, vol. 12, Founders Online, https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Madison/01-12-02-0126. The speech was reported by more than one newspaper and differs in wording among the reports; the Founders Online text is quoted throughout. The Annals of Congress text (1:440 ff.) has not been compared word for word.
Madison, June 8, 1789, Founders Online, as above: "First. That there be prefixed to the constitution a declaration—That all power is originally vested in, and consequently derived from the people," and "Fourthly. That in article 1st, section 9, between clauses 3 and 4, be inserted these clauses." The identification of clauses 3 and 4 as the ban on bills of attainder and ex post facto laws and the capitation-tax clause is a reading of the Constitution's text (National Archives transcription, https://www.archives.gov/founding-docs/constitution-transcript), not a statement in the speech.
Madison, June 8, 1789, Founders Online, as above. The proposed clause is the last clause of his fourth resolution. Hamilton's warning in The Federalist No. 84 is treated in Article 20.
Madison, June 8, 1789, Founders Online, as above, eighth resolution, to be inserted as a new article 7 after article 6. The same resolution carried a separation-of-powers clause.
Madison, June 8, 1789, Founders Online, as above, fifth resolution: "No state shall violate the equal rights of conscience, or the freedom of the press, or the trial by jury in criminal cases."
Madison, June 8, 1789, Founders Online, as above. The phrase "paper barriers" is the speech's; "parchment barriers" is from the letter to Jefferson of October 17, 1788. "One mean" and "controul" in the speech are the printed text's.
Fisher Ames to Thomas Dwight, June 11, 1789, in Helen E. Veit, Kenneth R. Bowling, and Charlene Bangs Bickford, eds., Creating the Bill of Rights: The Documentary Record from the First Federal Congress (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1991), 247, as reprinted by the Constitutional Sources Project (ConSource), https://consource.org/document/fisher-ames-to-thomas-dwight-1789-6-11/.
Annals 1 (July 21, 1789), as reprinted in The Founders' Constitution, Bill of Rights, document 11: the House divided "34 for it, and 15 against it," and referred the subject to "a committee, to consist of a member from each State." North Carolina and Rhode Island were not yet in the Union, so the committee had eleven members. "Mr. Vining, from the Committee of eleven," reported on July 28 (House proceedings for that day, as printed by Teaching American History). No source consulted here describes Vining as the committee's chairman. A draft in Roger Sherman's hand, apparently prepared for the committee, survives in the Library of Congress (Veit, Bowling, and Bickford, Creating the Bill of Rights, 268, as reprinted by ConSource, https://www.consource.org/document/roger-shermans-proposed-committee-report-1789-7-21/).
Roger Sherman, draft of amendments, July 21–28, 1789, in Veit, Bowling, and Bickford, Creating the Bill of Rights, 268, as reprinted by ConSource, https://www.consource.org/document/roger-shermans-proposed-committee-report-1789-7-21/, which calls it "apparently Sherman's proposal to the House select committee"; the manuscript is in the Manuscripts Division, Library of Congress. The rejection of Madison's prefatory declaration is from Teaching American History's congressional history, https://teachingamericanhistory.org/resource/cong_history/, for August 19, 1789. The connection to Locke, whose account of the social compact is treated in Article 10, is an inference from shared language; Sherman's draft names no source. The Virginia Declaration of Rights of 1776, sec. 1, speaks of rights of which men "when they enter into a state of society" cannot deprive their posterity (The Founders' Constitution, Bill of Rights, document 2).
Annals 1 (August 13 and 19, 1789), as reprinted in The Founders' Constitution, Bill of Rights, document 11: on August 19 "Mr. Sherman's motion was carried by two-thirds of the House." The editors of the Madison Papers likewise record that on August 19 the House adopted Sherman's motion declaring the amendments a "supplement" to the Constitution (Madison to Alexander White, August 24, 1789, n. 1, Founders Online).
Annals 1 (August 15 and 20, 1789), as reprinted in The Founders' Constitution, Amendment I (Religion), document 53, https://press-pubs.uchicago.edu/founders/documents/amendI_religions53.html. Peter Sylvester of New York feared the committee's wording "might be thought to have a tendency to abolish religion altogether." Ames's version of August 20 read "Congress shall make no law establishing religion, or to prevent the free exercise thereof, or to infringe the rights of conscience."
Annals 1:749–52, 766–67 (August 17 and 20, 1789), as reprinted in The Founders' Constitution, Amendment II, document 6, https://press-pubs.uchicago.edu/founders/documents/amendIIs6.html. The House text sent to the Senate read "but no one religiously scrupulous of bearing arms, shall be compelled to render military service in person" (House resolution of August 24, 1789, as reprinted by CSAC). The Senate's copy shows the militia paragraph struck through in part (National Archives, Senate revisions of September 9, 1789, National Archives Identifier 3535588, described at https://www.docsteach.org/documents/document/senate-revisions-bill-of-rights); no Senate vote on the proviso has been checked here.
Madison to Richard Peters, August 19, 1789, Papers of James Madison, vol. 12, Founders Online, https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Madison/01-12-02-0230.
John P. Kaminski, Thomas H. Linley, Timothy D. Moore, Oindrila Chattopadhyay, and Dustin Cohan, eds., The Documentary History of the Ratification of the Constitution, vol. 37, Bill of Rights [1] (Madison: Wisconsin Historical Society Press, 2019), introduction, 231–32, as reprinted by CSAC, https://csac.history.wisc.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/281/2024/05/DC10-03-01_Introduction.pdf: "All totaled 292 amendments were proposed," and "Eliminating duplicates, 102 individual amendments were recommended." The same introduction states that the division into a rights list and a structural list began with the Virginia convention. Other counts are in circulation: a National Archives blog gives "more than 200," and the 1992 edition of the Library of Congress's Constitution of the United States: Analysis and Interpretation gives 124, citing Bernard Schwartz and Herman Ames. They count differently, and the documentary edition's figures are used here.
Annals 1:731–45 (August 15, 1789), as reprinted in The Founders' Constitution, Amendment I (Petition and Assembly), document 17, https://press-pubs.uchicago.edu/founders/print_documents/amendI_assemblys17.html; vote from Teaching American History's text of the Annals for that day, https://teachingamericanhistory.org/resource/house-debates/0815-2: "10 rising in favor of it, and 41 against it." No names were recorded. Virginia's declaration of rights of June 27, 1788, art. 15, as printed by the Avalon Project, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/ratva.asp. In the Senate, a motion to add the same words failed 2 to 14, Lee and Grayson in favor (The Founders' Constitution, Amendment I (Speech), document 14).
Aedanus Burke, House of Representatives, August 15, 1789, Annals 1, as printed by Teaching American History, https://teachingamericanhistory.org/resource/house-debates/0815-2. The sentence continues past the words quoted.
Massachusetts form of ratification, February 6, 1788, amend. 1 ("all Powers not expressly delegated"); New Hampshire, June 21, 1788, amend. 1 ("expressly and particularly delegated"); South Carolina, May 23, 1788 ("every power not expressly relinquished"); Address and Reasons of Dissent of the Minority of the Convention of Pennsylvania, December 1787 ("not by this constitution expressly delegated"); and the Maryland convention committee's proposals of April 1788, which the convention did not adopt ("no Power, but what is expressly delegated"). Virginia, June 27, 1788, amend. 1, and North Carolina, 1788, amend. 1, read "not by this Constitution delegated"; New York, July 26, 1788, and Rhode Island, May 29, 1790, read "clearly delegated." Texts as printed by the Avalon Project (ratma.asp, ratsc.asp, ratva.asp, ratny.asp, ratri.asp) and CSAC. That all nine sets of proposals contained a reserved-powers provision follows Lochlan F. Shelfer, "How the Constitution Shall Not Be Construed," 2017 BYU Law Review 331, at 353 and n. 91, https://law.stanford.edu/wp-content/uploads/2017/09/How-the-Constitution-Shall-Not-Be-Construed.pdf, whose nine are the conventions of Massachusetts, New Hampshire, New York, North Carolina, South Carolina, Virginia, and Rhode Island, the Pennsylvania minority, and the Maryland committee.
Annals 1:773–77 (August 22, 1789), as reprinted in The Founders' Constitution, art. 1, sec. 8, cl. 1, document 19, https://press-pubs.uchicago.edu/founders/print_documents/a1_8_1s19.html, with the yeas and nays, 9 to 39. The motion provided that a state which should "neglect or refuse to pay its proportion, pursuant to such requisition" could have its share collected by Congress. Massachusetts, amend. 4; South Carolina; New Hampshire; New York; Rhode Island, amend. 8; Virginia, amend. 3 (Avalon Project). New York made the requisition a condition of its confidence in ratification as well as a recommendation.
Virginia recommended amendments, June 27, 1788, amends. 7, 8, 9, and 14 (Avalon Project, ratva.asp); New York, July 26, 1788, recommended amendments 7–9 (Avalon Project, ratny.asp). North Carolina's amendments repeated Virginia's on these points; New Hampshire asked for three-fourths of both houses for a peacetime army.
House resolution of August 24, 1789, articles 14 and 16, as reprinted by CSAC; Annals 1 (August 17, 1789), as reprinted in The Founders' Constitution, Amendment I (Speech), document 14, for Madison's remark. The Congressional Register's report of the same remark, printed in Papers of James Madison, vol. 12 (https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Madison/01-12-02-0227), reads "on the whole list." The Senate's marked copy of September 9, 1789, carries "dele" against the state-restraint article (National Archives Identifier 3535588, as described on DocsTeach); the date of the Senate's vote has not been checked against the Senate Journal.
Richard Henry Lee to Patrick Henry, September 14, 1789, Veit, Bowling, and Bickford, Creating the Bill of Rights, 295–96, as reprinted by ConSource, https://www.consource.org/document/richard-henry-lee-to-patrick-henry-1789-9-14/. Lee and Grayson wrote to Governor Beverley Randolph on September 28 that the amendments were "propositions so inadequate to the purpose of real and substantial amendment" (DHRC, vol. 37, 578–80, as reprinted by CSAC, https://csac.history.wisc.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/281/2025/04/Letters-from-Senators-Richard-Henry-Lee-and-William-Grayson.pdf).
William Grayson to Patrick Henry, September 29, 1789, Veit, Bowling, and Bickford, Creating the Bill of Rights, 300, as reprinted by ConSource, https://www.consource.org/document/william-grayson-to-patrick-henry-1789-9-29/.
CSAC, "The Role of James Madison in the Creation of the Bill of Rights," as in the note on Madison's fear of a second convention.
Journal of the Senate, September 3 and 9, 1789, as printed by Teaching American History, https://teachingamericanhistory.org/resource/senate-journal/. On September 3 the Senate rejected several versions, including one forbidding Congress to establish "any particular denomination of religion in preference to another."
National Archives, Center for Legislative Archives, "Bill of Rights," https://www.archives.gov/legislative/features/bor, which dates the start of Senate consideration to September 2 and the consolidation into twelve articles to September 9, 1789. The House resolution of August 24 (CSAC) has seventeen articles. The specific deletions and mergers follow the National Archives' Congress Creates the Bill of Rights materials (https://www.archives.gov/legislative/resources/bill-of-rights/) and the marked Senate copy as described on DocsTeach; the date of each Senate vote has not been checked against the Senate Journal. On "or to the people," the Annals record Daniel Carroll's motion as agreed on August 18, 1789 (The Founders' Constitution, Amendment X, document 6), but the House's August 24 text ends "reserved to the States respectively."
Conferees as given by Teaching American History's editorial note on the First Congress's approval of the twelve amendments; the date of the Senate's appointment of its conferees has not been checked. Final text from the National Archives transcription of the joint resolution, https://www.archives.gov/founding-docs/bill-of-rights-transcript.
House message receding from its disagreement, September 24, 1789, in Journal of the Senate, as printed by Teaching American History, https://teachingamericanhistory.org/resource/senate-journal/; National Archives, "Bill of Rights," for September 25. The House vote on the conference terms has not been checked.
George Washington, "Circular to the Governors of the States," October 2, 1789, Papers of George Washington, Presidential Series, vol. 4, Founders Online, https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Washington/05-04-02-0087. The editorial note records that the House asked the president to send copies to Rhode Island and North Carolina as well as to the ratifying states.
Joint resolution of Congress, as transcribed by the National Archives, https://www.archives.gov/founding-docs/bill-of-rights-transcript; Madison, June 8, 1789, as printed by Teaching American History from the Annals, https://teachingamericanhistory.org/document/speech-on-amendments-to-the-constitution/. Gerard N. Magliocca, The Heart of the Constitution: How the Bill of Rights Became the Bill of Rights (New York: Oxford University Press, 2018). Magliocca's dating is disputed: Kurt T. Lash, "Becoming the 'Bill of Rights': The First Ten Amendments from Founding to Reconstruction," 110 Virginia Law Review 411 (2024), https://virginialawreview.org/articles/becoming-the-bill-of-rights-the-first-ten-amendments-from-founding-to-reconstruction/, argues from antebellum usage that, "Long before the twentieth century, and decades before Reconstruction," Americans commonly called the 1791 amendments the Bill of Rights. The description of Magliocca's argument is the publisher's ("Until the twentieth century, few Americans called the first ten constitutional amendments drafted by James Madison in 1789 and ratified by the states in 1791 the Bill of Rights"), as reproduced at https://univ-droit.fr/recherche/actualites-de-la-recherche/parutions/25405-the-heart-of-the-constitution; Oxford's own page has not been reached, and the bibliographic data are confirmed from Lael Weinberger's review in Constitutional Commentary 34, no. 3 (2019), University of Minnesota repository, https://conservancy.umn.edu/items/94260ceb-932a-4f30-84d1-94f9e9833e28. The National Archives' listing for a talk on the book states that the Bill of Rights "did not achieve its modern form as the most powerful symbol on the limits of governmental power until after World War II" (https://www.archives.gov/calendar/event/the-heart-of-the-constitution-how-the-bill-of-rights-became-the-bill-of-rights). The book itself has not been consulted.
Joint resolution, National Archives transcription, as above.
English Bill of Rights, December 16, 1689, 1 W. & M., sess. 2, c. 2, item 10, as reprinted in The Founders' Constitution, Bill of Rights, document 1, https://press-pubs.uchicago.edu/founders/documents/bill_of_rightss1.html; Virginia Declaration of Rights, June 12, 1776, sec. 9, The Founders' Constitution, Bill of Rights, document 2, https://press-pubs.uchicago.edu/founders/documents/bill_of_rightss2.html; Virginia declaration of rights, June 27, 1788, art. 13 (Avalon Project), which reads "ought not be required"; North Carolina's thirteenth article is identical. The English Bill of Rights and its passage are treated in Article 11, and Mason's Declaration in Article 18.
Virginia Declaration of Rights, 1776, sec. 10; Virginia declaration of rights, 1788, art. 14 (Avalon Project); final text from the National Archives transcription. "Siezures" is the 1788 text's spelling. The general warrants and writs of assistance that stand behind the Fourth Amendment are treated in Articles 8 and 18.
Virginia Declaration of Rights, 1776, secs. 8, 13, and 16; Virginia declaration of rights, 1788, arts. 8, 15, 16, 17, and 20 (Avalon Project); New York declaration, July 26, 1788 (Avalon Project, ratny.asp). The Pennsylvania minority's third proposition carries the same rights of the accused. That the final language came by these documents, rather than independently, is an inference from the wording, which is shared phrase by phrase; Madison's June 8 proposals follow the 1788 texts closely.
Magna Carta, 1215, clause 39, Latin text and translation as given by the Magna Carta Project, University of East Anglia, https://magnacarta.cmp.uea.ac.uk/read/magna_carta_1215/Clause_39: "nisi per legale judicium parium suorum vel per legem terrae" — "except by the lawful judgment of his peers or by the law of the land." Virginia Declaration of Rights, 1776, sec. 8; Virginia declaration of rights, 1788, art. 9. Magna Carta is treated in Article 4.
New York declaration, July 26, 1788, as printed by the Avalon Project (ratny.asp) and The Founders' Constitution, Bill of Rights, document 8, https://press-pubs.uchicago.edu/founders/documents/bill_of_rightss8.html; Massachusetts, amend. 6 (Avalon, ratma.asp); Madison, June 8, 1789, fourth resolution (Founders Online). Among the state proposals of 1787–1790 — the Pennsylvania minority, Massachusetts, South Carolina, New Hampshire, Virginia, New York, North Carolina, and Rhode Island — only New York's uses "due process of law"; the others use "law of the land" or neither. No takings clause appears in any of them, and the DHRC chart of proposals that became the Bill of Rights has no row for one (DHRC, vol. 37, 233–40, as reported in the CSAC introduction).
Virginia recommended amendments, June 27, 1788, amend. 17 (Avalon Project); New York, July 26, 1788 (Avalon Project): such clauses "are to be construed either as exceptions to certain specified powers, or as inserted merely for greater caution." Madison, June 8, 1789 (Founders Online). Final text from the National Archives transcription.
DHRC, vol. 37, 464, "Dates of State Approval of Proposed Amendments," as reprinted by CSAC, https://csac.history.wisc.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/281/2024/05/DC10-05-02_Dates-of-State-Approval.pdf; the footnote to the amendments in the House Manual, Constitution, Jefferson's Manual, and Rules of the House of Representatives, 119th Congress, https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/HMAN-119/html/HMAN-119-pg94.htm, which dates Rhode Island's approval June 7, 1790, against CSAC's June 11. Which articles each state approved follows the state instruments as printed by Teaching American History, https://teachingamericanhistory.org/bor/ratification_of_amendments/.
CSAC, North Carolina chronology, https://csac.history.wisc.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/281/2023/12/DC9-12-00-02_N.C.-Chronology.pdf, for the vote of 194 to 77 and the General Assembly's adoption of the amendments on December 22, 1789; CSAC, Rhode Island chronology, https://csac.history.wisc.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/281/2023/12/DC9-13-00-02_R.I.-Chronology.pdf ("18 May U.S. Senate passes bill discriminating against R.I. in commerce"; "29 May R.I. Convention ratifies Constitution, 34–32"); Samantha Payne, National Archives, Pieces of History, May 18, 2015, https://prologue.blogs.archives.gov/?p=15426. The sources consulted tie Rhode Island's decision to the commercial bill rather than to the amendments.
Virginia Senate proceedings, December 8 and Saturday, December 12, 1789, DHRC, as reprinted by CSAC, https://csac.history.wisc.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/281/2024/05/DC10-05-16_Virginia_15Dec91.pdf. The third, eighth, eleventh, and twelfth articles of the twelve became the First, Sixth, Ninth, and Tenth Amendments. On December 14, four senators protested the majority's reasons.
Edmund Randolph to George Washington, Richmond, December 11, 1789, Papers of George Washington, Presidential Series, vol. 4, Founders Online, https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Washington/05-04-02-0278.
Act admitting Vermont, effective March 4, 1791, and Vermont's act of November 3, 1791, as reprinted by CSAC, https://csac.history.wisc.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/281/2024/05/DC10-05-15_Vermont_3Nov91.pdf; Virginia Senate, December 15, 1791, CSAC Virginia document, as in the note on the Virginia Senate's reasons. Virginia had ratified the first article separately on November 3, 1791. Jefferson, as secretary of state, notified the states on March 1, 1792, that ten of the twelve articles had been adopted (CSAC editorial note to the Vermont document).
CSAC, Georgia document, https://csac.history.wisc.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/281/2024/05/DC10-05-05_Georgia_24Mar1939.pdf, which prints the joint committee's report of December 1, 1789, and the 1939 resolution; CSAC's introduction to the state actions, https://csac.history.wisc.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/281/2024/05/DC10-05-01_State-Actions-Introduction.pdf, which describes the 1939 ratifications as symbolic and records that the two houses in Massachusetts and Connecticut could not agree on the same articles in 1789–1790. The 1939 dates are Massachusetts, March 2; Georgia, March 18 (the resolution is dated March 24); and Connecticut, April 13 or April 19, as the CSAC table and the House Manual differ.
David C. Huckabee, "Ratification of Amendments to the U.S. Constitution," Congressional Research Service Report 97-922 GOV, September 30, 1997, table 3, https://www.everycrsreport.com/files/19970930_97-922_ebded0a0c9f961ffabb21b4364d260b76a0b8d11.html, which counts ten states ratifying the apportionment article; Jessie Kratz, "A Record-Setting Amendment," National Archives, Pieces of History, April 11, 2016, https://prologue.blogs.archives.gov/2016/04/11/a-record-setting-amendment/, for Michigan's ratification on May 7, 1992, and Archivist Don Wilson's certification on May 18, 1992.
Barron v. Mayor and City Council of Baltimore, 32 U.S. (7 Pet.) 243 (1833), as reprinted in The Founders' Constitution, Amendment V (Due Process), document 26, https://press-pubs.uchicago.edu/founders/print_documents/amendV_due_processs26.html.
National Archives, "14th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution: Civil Rights (1868)," https://www.archives.gov/milestone-documents/14th-amendment; Chicago, Burlington & Quincy Railroad Co. v. Chicago, 166 U.S. 226 (1897), which the Federal Judicial Center describes as "the first time the Court used the Fourteenth Amendment to apply a specific provision of the Bill of Rights" to the states (https://www.fjc.gov/history/timeline/chicago-burlington-quincy-railroad-company-v-chicago); Bruce E. Auerbach, "Incorporation of the First Amendment," Free Speech Center, Middle Tennessee State University, https://firstamendment.mtsu.edu/article/incorporation-of-the-first-amendment/, on Gitlow v. New York, 268 U.S. 652 (1925).
On consolidation, Article 20, "The Loyal Opposition," published November 1, 2026; on incorporation, Consequential Actions, Episode 17i, at 57:00; on civil liberties and the nation, Episode 17A, at 41:19.
Teaching American History, "Father James and the Levy Thesis," https://teachingamericanhistory.org/resource/themes/father-james/, stating Leonard Levy's view. Paul Finkelman, "James Madison and the Bill of Rights: A Reluctant Paternity," Supreme Court Review (1990): 301–47, as characterized and cited by Stuart Leibiger, "James Madison and Amendments to the Constitution" (cited below), n. 47; Finkelman's article has not been consulted here, and the citation is Leibiger's.
CSAC, "The Role of James Madison in the Creation of the Bill of Rights," as in the note on Madison's fear of a second convention.
Stuart Leibiger, "James Madison and Amendments to the Constitution, 1787–1789: 'Parchment Barriers,'" Journal of Southern History 59, no. 3 (August 1993), at 443, as reprinted by CSAC, https://csac.history.wisc.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/281/2025/03/PD-creat-rat-of-BoR-JM-role-Leibiger-JamesMadisonAmendments-1993.pdf; Gordon S. Wood, "Without Him, No Bill of Rights," review of Richard Labunski, James Madison and the Struggle for the Bill of Rights (New York: Oxford University Press, 2006), New York Review of Books, November 30, 2006, https://www.nybooks.com/articles/2006/11/30/without-him-no-bill-of-rights/.
Shelfer, "How the Constitution Shall Not Be Construed," 353: civil juries were "supported by eight states," and "The next most popular rights were religious freedom (seven states)." Shelfer's nine are listed in the note on the reserved-powers proposals.
Sources and Further Reading
Primary Sources
Annals of Congress. The Debates and Proceedings in the Congress of the United States. Vol. 1. Washington, D.C.: Gales & Seaton, 1834.
Barron v. Mayor and City Council of Baltimore, 32 U.S. (7 Pet.) 243 (1833).
English Bill of Rights. 1 W. & M., sess. 2, c. 2. December 16, 1689.
Grayson, William. Letter to Patrick Henry, September 29, 1789.
Jefferson, Thomas. Letters to James Madison, December 20, 1787, and March 15, 1789. Founders Online.
Joint Resolution of Congress Proposing Twelve Articles of Amendment. September 25, 1789. National Archives.
Journal of the Senate of the United States. September 1789.
Kaminski, John P., et al., eds. The Documentary History of the Ratification of the Constitution. Vol. 37, Bill of Rights [1]. Madison: Wisconsin Historical Society Press, 2019. Center for the Study of the American Constitution, University of Wisconsin–Madison.
Kurland, Philip B., and Ralph Lerner, eds. The Founders' Constitution. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1987.
Lee, Richard Henry. Letter to Patrick Henry, September 14, 1789.
Lee, Richard Henry, and William Grayson. Letters to Governor Beverley Randolph and to the Speaker of the Virginia House of Delegates, September 28, 1789.
Madison, James. Letter to Thomas Jefferson, October 17, 1788; letter to George Eve, January 2, 1789; speech in the House of Representatives, June 8, 1789; letter to Richard Peters, August 19, 1789. Papers of James Madison, vols. 11–12. Founders Online.
Magna Carta. 1215. The Magna Carta Project, University of East Anglia.
Randolph, Edmund. Letter to George Washington, December 11, 1789. Founders Online.
State forms of ratification and recommended amendments: Massachusetts, South Carolina, New Hampshire, Virginia, New York, North Carolina, and Rhode Island, 1788–1790. Avalon Project, Yale Law School; Center for the Study of the American Constitution.
Veit, Helen E., Kenneth R. Bowling, and Charlene Bangs Bickford, eds. Creating the Bill of Rights: The Documentary Record from the First Federal Congress. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1991.
Virginia Declaration of Rights. June 12, 1776.
Virginia Senate. Proceedings, December 8–14, 1789.
Washington, George. Circular to the Governors of the States, October 2, 1789. Founders Online.
Secondary Works
Center for the Study of the American Constitution. "The Role of James Madison in the Creation of the Bill of Rights." University of Wisconsin–Madison.
Finkelman, Paul. "James Madison and the Bill of Rights: A Reluctant Paternity." Supreme Court Review (1990): 301–47.
Huckabee, David C. "Ratification of Amendments to the U.S. Constitution." Congressional Research Service Report 97-922 GOV. September 30, 1997.
Labunski, Richard. James Madison and the Struggle for the Bill of Rights. New York: Oxford University Press, 2006.
Lash, Kurt T. "Becoming the 'Bill of Rights': The First Ten Amendments from Founding to Reconstruction." Virginia Law Review 110 (2024): 411.
Leibiger, Stuart. "James Madison and Amendments to the Constitution, 1787–1789: 'Parchment Barriers.'" Journal of Southern History 59, no. 3 (1993).
Magliocca, Gerard N. The Heart of the Constitution: How the Bill of Rights Became the Bill of Rights. New York: Oxford University Press, 2018.
Shelfer, Lochlan F. "How the Constitution Shall Not Be Construed." BYU Law Review 2017, no. 2: 331.
Wood, Gordon S. "Without Him, No Bill of Rights." New York Review of Books, November 30, 2006.
Next: Article 22 — "The Inheritance and Its Keepers"



Comments